22°c A few clouds
25°c Chance of thundershowers
Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION
Local diocese challenging refugee health-care cuts in Federal Court
The local diocese of the Anglican Church has gone to Federal Court in a bid to reverse the federal health-care cuts to the refugee program.
In a hearing in Federal Court in Winnipeg this morning, the Rupert's Land Diocese made an application for judicial review, effectively asking the court to rule the Harper government cuts are a breach of contract with sponsoring organizations and order the government to keep them in place.
Related Items
"All we want is a declaration of a breach (of contract)," lawyer David Matas told Federal Court judge James O’Reilly during a two-hour hearing.
The Harper government announced in April that it was trimming the health-care benefits provided to all refugees, eliminating what it considered supplemental benefits: dental and vision care, prescription drugs, counseling, prosthetics, wheelchairs and other similar services.
The move was supposed to save the federal government $100 million over five years.
In June, the government quietly amended the changes, restricting the cuts to only refugees sponsored by private, and mostly faith-based, organizations, allowing them for government-chosen refugees like victims of human trafficking, a cause championed by local Conservative MP Joy Smith.
Matas, who represents the Rupert's Land Diocese of the Anglican Church, said the court action seeks to restore the cuts only for those refugees who were brought to Canada under the terms of a January 2012 agreement with the federal government.
Matas said the non-profit faith-based organizations that sponsored the refugees did so assuming Ottawa would provide the broad coverage of health benefits in its Interim Federal Health program.
Matas said Ottawa acted arbitrarily, without consultation with the affected groups who now are faced with providing the extra care for the refugees.
Matas said the cuts were also discriminatory, adding the benefits remain in place for other refugees but not for those who come to Canada through privately funded organizations.
Federal government lawyer Joel Katz said Ottawa continues to provide basic health care to the affected refugees, adding it’s up to the refugees to find the means for the additional benefits if they want or need them.
Katz said the faith-based organizations that sponsor these refugees are under no legal obligation to provide the supplemental benefits.
Katz said the federal government has the right to alter existing programs or introduce new programs, regardless of who they might impact. Katz said that new programs could result in a breach of contract, adding however that doesn’t mean a court can order the changes to be reversed.
Private organizations entered into a contract with the federal government, Katz said, adding that they agreed to provide sponsored refugees with food, clothing, transportation and other necessities for up to 12 months. The contract does not stipulate the groups must provide health-care benefits, he said.
Katz said that if any of the faith-based sponsorship groups believes there has been a breach of contract, then they should sue the federal government and prove the damages they have incurred as a result of the breach.
Katz said that Manitoba opted to provide the supplemental benefits Ottawa cut, adding the Rupert's Land Diocese and its private partners have suffered no financial hardships.
After the hearing, Matas said that while Manitoba and Quebec stepped in when Ottawa withdrew the supplemental benefits, other provinces did not and the sponsoring groups are incurring unexpected costs to provide the additional benefits.
Matas said that if the court rules in the diocese’s favour, the ruling would be binding on Ottawa for all groups across the country.
History
Updated on Wednesday, February 6, 2013 at 4:17 PM CST: corrects typo in headline
More Local
- Back to Top
- Return to Local
More Local
(1 of 30 articles for today)
Run to be named after crash victim
8:04 PM 0Winnipeg’s annual Empower Run is changing its name in memory of a race organizer killed in a car crash.
The run, ...
Poll
Most Popular Local
- Community's children apprehended by province
- Glover quits quarrel over election costs
- Bar closing at Royal Albert
- Motorists complained about unsafe practices at site of crash that killed worker
- Blogger found in contempt of court
- Métis ready to ring bell again
- Kids of St. Ignatius make Sweet gesture to beloved crossing guard
- New crowd plan for Taylor Swift get-together
- Ex's Mach 3 an adrenaline accelerator
- Fatal crash 'could have happened to anyone'; defence seeks weekend sentence
- Safeway stores likely to close
- Squirrel crawls out of Winnipegger's toilet
- Poolside feeding prompts eviction
- Basic arithmetic back in class
- Court told driver hysterical after vehicle fatally hit highway worker
- Community's children apprehended by province
- Stoppage of play off the field
- Glover quits quarrel over election costs
- Child in critical condition after West End crash
- Kenyan wins Manitoba Marathon
- Father blasts 'horrific' movie
- Safeway stores likely to close
- Man dies after being pulled from vehicle submerged in Winnipeg retention pond
- Flood money paid for CEO's romantic trip
- Car in deadly crash stolen?
- UPDATE: Now with FAQ: Keeping the e-party going without the party-crashers
- Squirrel crawls out of Winnipegger's toilet
- Daycare provider charged with abandonment
- Poolside feeding prompts eviction
- Two people killed in crash north of Winnipeg
- Community's children apprehended by province
- Basic arithmetic back in class
- Métis ready to ring bell again
- Kids of St. Ignatius make Sweet gesture to beloved crossing guard
- Province blows off wind megawatt goal
- New crowd plan for Taylor Swift get-together
- Ex's Mach 3 an adrenaline accelerator
- Blogger found in contempt of court
- Toilet contents need help escaping
- Known as kind, outgoing men
- Basic arithmetic back in class
- Squirrel crawls out of Winnipegger's toilet
- Safeway stores likely to close
- Province blows off wind megawatt goal
- Community's children apprehended by province
- $110-K worth of nickel plates stolen from Thompson mine
- Known as kind, outgoing men
- A day in the life of 13,380 Manitoba Marathon participants
- Stoppage of play off the field
- Bomber fans wowed by new stadium
- Basic arithmetic back in class
- Squirrel crawls out of Winnipegger's toilet
- Father blasts 'horrific' movie
- Developers to unveil plans for bold downtown tower
- Teachers support adding sexual-orientation themes to all curricula
- The crime fighter's revolution
- Safeway stores likely to close
- Car in deadly crash stolen?
- City's first urban reserve born
- On board with the Snowbirds
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
Have Your Say
Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscribers only. why?
Login SubscribeHave Your Say
Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press Subscribers only. why?
SubscribeThe Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.