Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION
Posted: 11/8/2013 5:18 PM | Comments: 0
A Winnipeg man was acquitted Friday of second-degree murder -- but convicted of manslaughter -- for the 2011 stabbing death of Steven Dodge.
A jury took just hours to deliberate before pronouncing Nathan Bricklin's fate.
Bricklin, 20, pleaded not guilty of Dodge's murder in the backyard of an Arlington Street home on June 26, 2011. He fought the case on the basis he was defending himself.
"The Crown must prove that it wasn't self-defence," defence lawyer Evan Roitenburg told the seven-man, five-woman jury in his closing statement delivered Thursday.
Roitenburg said Bricklin immediately tried to explain to police that he never meant to do Dodge harm, and that the victim "came after me."
"Here, you know what was in Nathan's mind because he told you in what he told the police," said Roitenburg.
In pressing for a murder conviction, prosecutors pointed to differing versions of what Bricklin told police of how Dodge came to be stabbed.
Earlier in the evening, Dodge, 26, had played "peacemaker" in a domestic-related argument Bricklin was having with a woman at the home. Bricklin was ultimately asked to leave and a confrontation with Dodge took place outside.
In his initial version to police, Bricklin said Dodge came up behind him and bit him on the arm, according to the Crown. Bricklin said he then turned to punch him and did so not knowing a knife was in his hand.
"Does that make any sense to you?," Crown attorney Brian Bell asked jurors. "We say it shouldn't."
Later in his police interview, said Bell, Bricklin said he injured the victim, "just once," later saying, "it could be two (times)."
A pathologist testified Dodge suffered nine stab wounds.
A sentencing hearing is pending.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Woman charged in North End murder
Folklorama most popular summer fest: poll
Two years of house arrest for senior who stole $38K
Mayoral candidate wants to lower voting age
Warm, wet weekend in store for Winnipeg
11-year-old conservationist gets meeting with polar bears
Accident closes Trans-Canada Highway near Virden
Katz changes listing on Ariz. home
Court date on hold in Brandon inmate's beating
Police forced to moo-ve cows off highway
Province receives request to review damning audits
New rules for rentals start soon
Woman drank self to death, man says
Temple happy to learn about return of urn
Centra Gas rates go down a tad
A walk a day can keep the doctor away
Owner insists nothing's fishy
SOUNDS of success
How the seven mayoral candidates stack up so far
When it comes to getting a few laughs, I've got the scoop
Dead toddler had CFS contact
Mailbox sites anger residents
'This is the reward for the work we do'
Ancient trees discredit drought
Growing Older July 25
Billboard July 25