Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 01/22/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
Manitobans not only rank "dead last" in access to doctors after hours, but the impact on the province's emergency rooms is compromising a system where traditional, lengthy doctor-patient relationships are badly in need of a checkup, according to a high-ranking medical spokesman.
Findings from the 2012 Commonwealth Fund international health-policy survey show not only does Canada lag behind other countries in rapid access to doctors outside working hours, but Manitoba ranks at the bottom compared to other provinces.
"That isn't satisfactory," said Dr. Michael Moffatt, a Winnipeg pediatrician and member of the Health Canada Council, which released the report. "The public actually owns the system, and they should be getting better service."
Moffatt said doctors have "drifted away" from feeling responsible for their patients on a 24-hour, year-round basis, adding emergency rooms have become a "default system" for both physician and patient. Between 85 and 90 per cent of patients who visit emergency rooms have personal doctors, he said.
The survey found Manitoba doctors are among the least likely to have arrangements for after-hours care for their patients.
Moffatt, who also serves as executive director of research and applied learning for the Winnipeg Regional Health Authority, suggested physicians be offered financial incentives to develop support systems and link practices that could share patients. Most practices average between three and eight doctors, said Moffatt, addding "that's not enough to provide 24-hour, year-round coverage."
Moffatt said resurrecting the house call is another option. The report said 58 per cent of Canadian doctors make home visits, compared with between 90 and 100 per cent in the Netherlands, Norway, Britain, France and Switzerland.
"Maybe it (the house call) isn't dead," Moffatt said, noting there are no incentives for doctors to visit their patients. "Maybe it's something that needs to be looked at (reviving)."
Continuing to rely on emergency wards is not the answer, he said. "We've got a lot of congestion in our emergency program," he said. "At this point, we're at a stalemate."
Ultimately, he said, as health issues in an aging society turn to more chronic care, the need for long-term doctor-patient relationships will become more acute.
"It works much better if you have an ongoing relationship with people... who can take care of you over time. They know you, they know your medical history."
Moffatt acknowledged "it's hard to get your own physician if you don't have one."
Manitoba has the lowest availability of resources (doctors and nurses per 1,000 population) in Canada, according to a Fraser Institute report on health care.
Conservative provincial health care critic Cameron Friesen said the NDP government's failure to retain doctors -- more than 1,800 physicians have left Manitoba since 2001, he said -- is only exacerbating the pressure on emergency wards.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition January 22, 2013 A4
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Gilroy seizes Daniel McIntyre after close race
Lukes wins boss' vacated seat in St. Norbert
Voters stick with status quo for school boards
Capital-region voters send law-and-order message
Pagtakhan retains Point Douglas seat
Dobson finds his groove in fourth election attempt
Devi Sharma squeaks in win in Old Kildonan
Pike new mayor in St. Andrews
Morantz edges Duncan in Charleswood-Tuxedo
Brian Bowman wins mayoral battle
Orlikow beats Taz in River Heights-Fort Garry
Wyatt reinstated in Transcona
LIVE: Election night in Winnipeg
Schreyer unseats Steen in Elmwood-East Kildonan
Voter turnout highest in a decade
Mayes re-elected in St. Vital
Matt Allard elected councillor in St. Boniface
Gerbasi holds down Fort Rouge-East Fort Garry
Candlelight vigil being held for babies tonight at 6 p.m.
Family, friends, colleagues bid farewell to Lindor Reynolds
Man, 26, killed in crash on Highway 3 between Sanford and Oak Bluff
Security at Manitoba Legislature tightened after Ottawa shooting
St. Malo man dies after collision
DNA testing will determine if accused is mother of 6 dead infants
Warm weather, possibly rain, on election day
Man pleads guilty to home invasion where kids sprayed
Tough to keep watch on storage lockers: firms
Last chance to vote: Polls open until 8 p.m.
Party sparked tension
Infanticide different than murder: author
MPI says it needs hike to prevent rate shock
Police ID body found in river
It's much scarier than Halloween
Dead newborns found in locker
Teen missing in East Elmwood found safe
Female trustees may outnumber men across province
Activists hope to boost voting in North End