Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Cyclists won't share roadway with cars: Katz
Groups plan noon demonstration
WINNIPEG — The so-called gap in the bike-and-pedestrian path Winnipeg plans to build alongside the southwest rapid transit corridor will not force cyclists to share a narrow underpass with motor vehicles, the city's construction boss and Mayor Sam Katz insist in response to claims by a coalition of non-profit organizations.
Today, The Forks, the Winnipeg Trails Association and five other groups plan to hold a noon demonstration to decry a 500-metre gap in the active-transportation pathway that will run from Queen Elizabeth Way to Jubilee Avenue by 2011 and then on to the University of Manitoba by the middle of the next decade.
The $138-million city plan to build the 3.6-kilometre first phase of the southwest bus corridor includes a bike-and-pedestrian path dedicated entirely for people on foot, bikes or inline skates, except for a section in and around the Osborne Street CN Rail underpass south of Confusion Corner.
The Forks-led coalition claims the city and province have reneged on a promise to build a dedicated bike path alongside the forthcoming busway. But the so-called gap is only temporary -- and will not require cyclists to drive on any roads, said Brad Sacher, the acting director of Winnipeg's public works department.
When transportation engineers drew up the busway plans, the cost of a bike bridge over the CN Rail line turned out to be $20 million, given the height of the clearance required above moving trains, Sacher said.
An alternate plan to build a bike-and-pedestrian tunnel below the rail line would only cost $15 million, but would be pointless because the city is already planning to replace the Osborne underpass within five or 10 years, he added.
The city will build a dedicated active-transportation path through the underpass when it widens the Osborne underpass, he pledged. In the meantime, one of the sidewalks will be redesignated for cyclists and a new traffic signal for bikes and pedestrians will be built at Osborne Street, south of the underpass, said Sacher, noting cyclists will only have to stop once during the entire ride on the new pathway.
"The reality of this is (the gap is) only a stretch of 500 metres in a 3.6-kilometre section of the first phase and ultimately a 10-kilometre full phase," he said.
Spending $15 million on a temporary fix that will cost next to nothing within a decade would be a waste of money, added the mayor.
"I would like to think no level of government wants to take taxpayers' money and flush it down the toilet," said Katz, adding cyclists and pedestrians should appreciate the major strides Winnipeg has made in active transportation in recent years.
The mayor also said Winnipeg's streets are not as dangerous as some cyclists suggest. On Bike To Work Day on June 19, he got home from a trip to Israel and drove downtown and back from his home in Tuxedo without incident, he said.
"I'm here today talking to you. I'm not the most advanced cyclist. If I can do it at my age, then people can do it," he said.
Nevertheless, the city should have made more of an effort to communicate its plan to deal with the gap in the new active-transportation corridor, Winnipeg Trails Association director Janice Lukes said in an email.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition June 25, 2009 A4
The comment period for this story has ended.
-
Breaking News Alerts
Sign up for our new Breaking News Alerts
-
Editor's Bulletin
Sign up for daily bulletins
-
Winnipeg road closures
Check if your commute is affected
-
Blogs to Watch
We pick our favourite local blogs for you to follow
-
Breaking News Widget
Create and embed a Winnipeg Free Press breaking news widget on your site or blog
-
Twitter
Follow our reporters and news feeds on Twitter
Ads by Google
- Back to Top
- Return to Local
Poll
Most Popular
- Hells clubhouse seized
- Bombers stamp out fun: fans
- City family's return from vacation turns tragic
- Corydon bar employee charged in man's death
- Second son dies after Kenora crash
- Hydro picks its west side route
- Happy hubby loves wife's nudity
- Girl tries to kill self at MYC
- Cost jump could change stadium design
- River Rouge runs aground
- Victims of deadly crash are from Winnipeg
- Tornado touches down near Oakbank
- City family's return from vacation turns tragic
- Man killed in motorcycle crash with car
- Night storms jar Manitoba with tornado, washed out roads and hail
- Man drowns in Whiteshell
- Monarch migration mystery solved by Canadian researchers
- Ice Edge loses exclusivity edge in Coyote deal
- Meat Loaf taken off MTS Centre’s menu
- Grandparent scam becoming more common in city
- What's 2204355? It's the latest unexplainable web trend
- Lundar resident faces charges over 911 calls
- Victims of deadly crash are from Winnipeg
- Katz dating younger woman -- but that shouldn't matter
- Teen takes own life after alleged assault
- Have the province and city gone too far in naming a lake and community centre after Jonathan Toews?
- Body found at The Forks tentatively identified
- Human head found at The Forks
- Body found near Grant Park
- Churches crumble across U.S.
- Hells clubhouse seized
- Bombers stamp out fun: fans
- Hydro picks its west side route
- Cost jump could change stadium design
- Cost flap delays start on stadium
- Housing project future of infill
- Three dozen neglected dogs destroyed
- Winnipeg police unveil new decal, motto
- Hey, hey, my, my... why do some fans behave like boors?
- Montana officials trap grizzly, 2 of her 3 cubs, after campground mauling that killed man
- The Oxy dilemma
- Cruisers curse police checks
- Winnipeg police unveil new decal, motto
- Hells clubhouse seized
- Bombers stamp out fun: fans
- Hydro picks its west side route
- Nursing students' careers put on hold
- Program to train aboriginal railway conductors
- Cost jump could change stadium design
- Core chaos shuts eatery's doors
- Katz dating younger woman -- but that shouldn't matter
- The Oxy dilemma
- Bombers boot beer snake
- More than 100 motorists charged under cellphone law
- Cruisers curse police checks
- Winnipeggers demonstrate against G20 protesters' treatment
- Winnipeg police unveil new decal, motto
- Hells clubhouse seized
- 'Dream home' lost, family devastated
- Bombers stamp out fun: fans
- WWII Lancaster Bomber flies into Winnipeg today
- Hydro picks its west side route
- Girl tries to kill self at MYC
- School staffer faces charges for sex crimes
- Province cautious on trials for multiple sclerosis therapy
- Corydon bar employee charged in man's death
- Housing project future of infill
- River Rouge runs aground
- Unfair to students
- Montana officials trap grizzly, 2 of her 3 cubs, after campground mauling that killed man
- Nasty, poisonous plant causes burns, blindness
- Night storms jar Manitoba with tornado, washed out roads and hail
- Nursing students' careers put on hold
- Old, new songs forever Young
- Woman who survived bear attack in US says she played dead to get the animal to leave her
- Saskatchewan premier calls for clinical trials of controversial MS treatment
- Liquid calories
- Tornado touches down near Oakbank
- Computer wiz's alter ego: Sir Lance-a-Lot
- WWII Lancaster Bomber flies into Winnipeg today
- Lundar resident faces charges over 911 calls
- Protection or peril?
- Nasty, poisonous plant causes burns, blindness
- Night storms jar Manitoba with tornado, washed out roads and hail
- Osteoporosis Canada issues updated vitamin D guidelines for bone health
- Nursing students' careers put on hold
- Last Grapes restaurant out of business
- A Royal whirlwind: The Queen's day in Winnipeg
- Bombers boot beer snake
- Katz dating younger woman -- but that shouldn't matter
Events
July 30, 2010
Gavins Chance for Change
Golf Tournament Fundraiser includes 18 holes of golf, cart, smokie or hamburger for lunch and banquet dinner. Registration at 8:30 a.m. Shotgun start at 10 a.m. ...




16 Comments
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Posted by: whatisee
June 26, 2009 at 1:09 PM
I think all cars should come with big, sharp spikes on the steering wheel instead of airbags. The safer they make them, the more invulnerable people feel, and the more reckless they become. People are like that.
Posted by: Beautiful Insanity
June 26, 2009 at 10:22 AM
I am all for people biking! BUT FOLLOW THE SAME RULES AS CARS!!!!! STOP at stop signs! STOP at red lights! Wear a helmet! DONT Squeeze between a turning car and the curb, then get mad when the turning car almost hits you!!!!! I am an environmentalist and I walk 30 blocks to work and 30 blocks home everyday, and cant stand the majority of people on bikes! If people drove cars how people bike it would be insanity! BUT, to the few people that bike safely on the main roads, thank you, but you cant blame the people in cars for getting mad when the majority of people on bikes just do there thing with zero regard for the cars around them! There needs to be some kind of law enforcement to cyclists too.... sorry, I know you are making a choice that is beneficial to us all, but you cant expect to do whatever you want and not have people get mad/hurt.
And it is not this mayors fault that this city was designed around cars. At least he is trying to fix the mistakes of the past. If you want to have all major city streets redesigned for cyclists, start paying into autopac!
Posted by: ggpow2
June 25, 2009 at 6:16 PM
Dear 'senior lady' what cyclists contribute are taxes and, in the near future, I most likely won't be one of the people burdening our ailing health care system by being fat, lazy and sedentary all my life(like I'm pretty sure the majority of the people so-weirdly-opposed to cycling are).
Posted by: Alexis
June 25, 2009 at 2:29 PM
Hate? I'm sorry you are so angry Jay. My children cycle to and from school months out of each school year and I only wish the city would make proper bicycle paths so my children could be safe while cycling.
Posted by: Jay
June 25, 2009 at 12:29 PM
I hate the militant biking minority in this city. All they do is whine whine whine!
Posted by: Islabiker
June 25, 2009 at 12:28 PM
Re Mayor Katz's comment "The mayor also said Winnipeg's streets are not as dangerous as some cyclists suggest. On Bike To Work Day on June 19, he got home from a trip to Israel and drove downtown and back from his home in Tuxedo without incident, he said." Please tell the truth mayor, you felt " safe" riding to work because assigned Police Cycling officers escorted you to and from work. Can we all get that protective cocoon to make us feel safer from aggressive drivers ?
Posted by: Dunder Mifflin
June 25, 2009 at 12:04 PM
Ya.. 500 meters.. did ya see what it's all about? the rail is designed for cars, not for the sidewalk.. There's sharp pointy aluminum beams sticking out of the concrete, if you ride too close and hit one of those, it's major pain time.
Posted by: expatpegger
June 25, 2009 at 11:11 AM
Senior Lady: So if the car lanes are congested, why don't you get out of your car and use the bike/bus corridor yourself? It's ready and waiting.
Posted by: Finn Macool
June 25, 2009 at 11:02 AM
@Senior Lady
The cyclist contributes by taking their bikes, not causing pollution, extending the life cycle of the roadways and pay taxes JUST LIKE YOU!!!!!
Posted by: A Pegger
June 25, 2009 at 10:08 AM
Why not do the safe thing and put the bicycle riders in with all the biggest traffic on the road, say maybe transit buses !
Oh, I forgot, those are called diamond lanes .
Now all the riders are dead, injured or scared to death - problem solved .
View all Comments