Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 08/30/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
Last Modified: 08/30/2013 2:53 PM | Updates
A national environmental group is ramping up its efforts to block a controversial plan to ship crude oil through the northern Manitoba Port of Churchill.
The Wilderness Committee plans to hold town hall meetings in Winnipeg, Thompson and Churchill over the next five weeks to let Manitobans hear from experts why it's too risky to let Omnitrax Canada haul oil by rail to Churchill and then ship it out in tankers through Hudson Bay.
It also has a letter-writing campaign underway urging concerned citizens to send a message to the Manitoba government expressing their opposition to the plan.
The committee argues Omnitrax's rail line passes through remote areas and sensitive wildlife habitat, and an oil spill would be disastrous and difficult to clean up. Spokesman Eric Reder said it has received more than 220 responses since it sent an email last Thursday to its members informing them of the letter-writing campaign, which is being run through its website: www.wildernesscommittee.org/manitoba.
"These are very high numbers for any letter-writing campaign we've run," he said. "We usually don't get more than a few hundred responses... after several weeks."
Winnipeg-based Omnitrax said earlier this month it hopes to ship about 12.5 million litres of light sweet crude oil per year as part of its ongoing efforts to boost the volume of goods passing through the port and to ensure its long-term viability.
They said Omnitrax is talking to several Alberta oil companies that might be interested in using the port to ship oil to refineries in Atlantic Canada and Europe. It hopes to do a test run this October involving a 1.25-million-litre tanker ship.
Omnitrax spokesman Mike Ogborn said this week those talks are continuing.
A spokeswoman for Canada's largest publicly traded oil company -- Suncor Energy Inc. -- said Tuesday it has no plans to ship oil through Churchill.
"It's just not a fit for us at this time," she said. But for competitive reasons, she declined to say if Suncor had discussed the option with Omnitrax.
The Omnitrax proposal has drawn mixed reactions from northern Manitoba residents, businesses and municipal officials. Churchill resident and tour-company worker Alex deVries-Magnifico and hotel operator Dick Hunter are vehemently opposed to the plan because of concerns about the risk of an oil spill and the damage that would do to the environment and to Churchill's tourism industry.
DeVries-Magnifico said all but two or three of the approximately 70 people who attended an Aug. 13 meeting in Churchill were opposed to the plan.
Hunter, who owns the Iceberg Inn in Churchill, also said a spill in the port would contaminate all of Hudson Bay because of the way the water circulates around the bay.
"We definitely have some very big concerns," the former volunteer fire chief added.
However, Churchill Mayor Mike Spence has expressed cautious support for the plan, saying Omnitrax has been safely handling gasoline and diesel-fuel shipments for more than a decade.
While Spence is keen to find new products to diversify the Port of Churchill's business -- which currently relies mainly on grain shipping -- he would want to ensure the Omnitrax plan poses no risk to the environment and meets all regulatory requirements for the safe handling of petroleum products, he said.
The Pas Mayor Al McLaughlan and Thompson city councillor Penny Byers also said after Omnitrax officials explained the precautions it would be taking, including having an emergency response unit and spill-containment equipment on every oil train, most people in their communities seemed to be in favour of the plan.
"After listening to everything that was said... this is without a doubt a good-news story for Thompson and the region," Byers said, adding it could lead to new jobs and to additional sales for local suppliers.
Ogborn said Omnitrax's existing procedures for transporting petroleum products already meet or exceed Transport Canada safety standards.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition August 30, 2013 A6
Updated on Friday, August 30, 2013 at 2:53 PM CDT: Clarified Churchill mayor's statement.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Three years for deadly drug dosage
Feds planning changes to Nutrition North program after it was blasted by auditor general
Locals rally for Ukrainian pilot being held as PoW
U of M staff, students to protest against budget cuts
Hydro works on different section of Bipole III
CentreVenture will have to invite new proposals, will compete against True North
Warming huts from The Forks headed to Winter Design Festival in Ottawa
New application ready for UNESCO recognition for boreal forest
True North adding new seating as part of improvement plan
Committee wants legal details of opening up Portage & Main
Documentary on Death From Above's rise, fall and return to play at Cinematheque
Nationwide warrant for Thompson man's arrest
Speedway International fined after its plant was destroyed by blaze in St. Boniface
Man going to jail for giving deadly morphine dosage
Winnipegger cashes in $1-M lotto ticket
Mayes, Browaty: questions remain on convention centre mess
Few details regarding first homicide of 2015
Racism is Manitoba's 'shame,' Oswald declares
NDP flip-flop on voting very good news for Ashton
Warm today; freezing rain makes for difficult driving
Teepees set up as protest of Bipole III's planned route
Soggy gitch no match for male brain
Remote voting for NDP race
Rising rent imperils daycares
Allard wants better whistleblower protection for city staff
Mix-up of Titanic proportions
Awesome girl makes helping homeless her mission
Team Jones claims seventh provincial curling title
Oswald says racism exists in Manitoba; criticizes Pallister's comments
NDP delegates from remote constituencies get mail-in ballots, electronic voting
Police continue to investigate city's first homicide of 2015
Suspects nabbed in North End robbery
Sapotaweyak Cree Nation sets up teepee to protest Bipole III transmission line
Tobogganing-ban idea ripped
Two young teens face charges after breaking into a Main Street business
RCMP say alcohol was a factor in snowmobile accident in RM of Stanley
Time-travel flick familiar terrain
Mending Today's NDP no easy task