Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Expert rejects meteor claim
Rocks don't look like real thing
BRANDON -- An astronomer from the Manitoba Museum has discounted the claim of a woman who said she found pieces of a meteorite on her property near Riding Mountain National Park.
Nicole Nixon said she experienced a bright light and loud noise Tuesday morning, then found two rocks she believed to be meteorites the following day.
Scott Young, astronomer at the Manitoba Museum and Planetarium, said Nixon "contacted us at the museum several times before, including last week, before Tuesday's alleged sighting.
"Interestingly, she sent us pictures of different rocks with the same story, which look nothing like the rock pictures that ran in the article, and aren't meteorites either."
On Friday, Nixon said the rocks she called Young about the previous week were from Portugal, and that Young is angry with her because she wouldn't give him some of her other meteorites.
"We've had a lot of problems with Scott Young. We had a huge meteor fall in 2009 here and Scott Young wanted some of the meteorites from that fall for free," Nixon said.
Young said it is difficult to tell from pictures alone, but the rocks in the pictures Nixon provided don't have the features normally found on meteorites.
Meteorites are usually dark, not porous (there aren't any air bubbles in them because their isn't any air in space), they don't have any crystals in them (quartz is very common on Earth but not found in meteorites), they are often magnetic, and very heavy for their size.
Nixon's description of the what happened doesn't add up, Young said.
"If you see a flash in the sky, the rock isn't falling where you are because this happens when the meteor's still 50 kilometres up and still moving at a couple hundred kilometres an hour," Young said.
"Once it slows down and stops burning it falls on a ballistic trajectory and it usually lands dozens or a hundred kilometres from where people saw it."
Such a large event is usually seen and heard for more than 100 kilometres, but Nixon has so far been the only person to have reported it.
Nixon said there are 10 other witnesses, but refused to provide their names or contact information for verification.
When meteorites as large as the rock Nixon found (70 kg) hit the Earth, their sonic boom and impact register on seismographs that are monitored in Manitoba.
Young said his office is contacted when this occurs but wasn't contacted about any recent activity.
Even though the Perseids meteor shower occurred recently, Young said there has never been a meteorite associated with a meteor shower.
A meteor shower occurs when the Earth passes through the trail of dust left behind by a comet, which is composed of tiny bits of sand and ice.
On average, the Earth is hit about once a day from meteors, but they usually come down in an ocean or in remote areas.
-- Brandon Sun
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition August 18, 2012 A13
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories?
Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
(1 of 50 articles for this week)4:34 PM 0
Photo Store Gallery
- Man, 45, missing since Monday
- Break-in on top of her grieving
- RCMP charge more than dozen impaired drivers
- Synagogue serves up some Christmas meals and cheer
- Guests welcomed with open arms at Christmas Feast in the West End
- Other alleged victims for therapist charged with assault
- Warm temperatures in Manitoba for Christmas
- No charges laid in fatal collision
- Openings, closings over the Christmas week
- For some First Nations people, like Tina Fontaine’s family, grieving is part of the yuletide season
- MTS says services have been restored
- Winnipeg trucker dies in semi-truck collision
- New Transcona Boulevard offically opens today
- Remains may be decade old
- Break-in on top of her grieving
- Infant remains in locker may be decade old: Brodsky
- Police seek driver after pickup truck hits pedestrian
- No charges laid against man who killed teen mugger
- Oswald officially enters NDP leadership race; promises an "alternative vision"
- Police continue to seek info on driver; hit-and-run proves fatal
- Slain man leaves behind nine children
- Trucking firm in mourning after driver killed in crash
- Teacher pulled from classroom
- 'Fun party for two' ends in tragedy
- Photos released of suspects in coat heist
- RCMP investigate allegations of doctored invoices, improper payment
- Semi driver dies in collision at Lagimodiere, Dugald
- Twelve arrested, including former city council candidate; weapons and drugs
- Keep car windows clear or face fine: police
- Selby among victims of debit card-skimming scam
Ads by Google