10°c Partly cloudy
8°c Light rain
Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Fight club a form of camaraderie?
'I don't understand wanting to have someone punch me:' U of M professor
BORIS.MINKEVICH@FREEPRESS.MB.CA Enlarge Image
Dominick Blais and Curtis Brigham train at Professional Edge Fitness and Conditioning. Owner Jordan Cieciwa (right) says if you feel the need to fight, the controlled environment of a gym is a much safer way of going about it.
Prof. Kenneth MacKendrick can't really grasp why a guy would go out of his way to get punched in the face voluntarily and consensually.
But the University of Manitoba professor of religion and researcher into masculinity understands that there are extremes to which some men will go to declare their vision of masculinity.
Related Items
U of M officials have busted a fight club in a squash court in the Frank Kennedy Centre. Officials believe that young men engaged in voluntary, bare-knuckled altercations arranged through a Facebook site.
There were 87 members of the Facebook site -- primarily U of M students and four part-time staff -- who temporarily had their gym membership suspended. Investigators determined that there were five ringleaders, one of them a part-time staff member, who had their gym membership suspended for a month.
U of M is continuing to investigate what actually happened in that squash court, and could impose academic discipline.
Emphasizing that no one yet knows exactly what went on in that squash court, MacKendrick said that men gain camaraderie by doing things with other men, which can range from going fishing, to joining a movement such as Promise Keepers or Iron John, to the extreme of a fight club.
"To be a man means to be, look at me, I'm in crisis. The bruises are being used as a fashion accessory," he said.
"They did this at the U of M, where, if they needed it, they would have medical attention.
"I understand the impetus, I understand the trials of manhood, of initiation rituals," said MacKendrick. Nevertheless, "I don't understand wanting to have someone punch me."
Over at the Professional Edge Fitness and Conditioning gym in southwest Winnipeg, owner Jordan Cieciwa certainly doesn't know why guys would choose to punch each other out with bare fists.
Cieciwa teaches martial arts as a fitness activity, and also trains Ultimate Fighting Championship (UFC) fighters.
"No, we don't" understand the attraction, he said.
"The guys that are professional, they try not to get injured and not get marked up," Cieciwa said.
"Those injuries take a long time to heal.
Black eyes, broken fingers, possible brain injuries -- they're not conducive to making a good impression in the workplace the next day, he said.
"We want people to know there are better ways to do this. If you're doing it for the rush, there's a better way to do it, without the black eye," said Cieciwa.
At his gym, there's always a referee supervising training sessions, people wear headgear, and their padded gloves are four times the size of the gloves worn in mixed martial arts competitions.
Meanwhile, MacKendrick has studied the novel Fight Club and the 1999 film of the same name starring Brad Pitt, in which young men meet at night for consensual bare-knuckle brawling.
Some of the participants might be too young to remember the book and film, MacKendrick suggested.
"It's becoming a dated reference, but the name Fight Club has caught in people's minds."
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition January 20, 2010 B2
More Local
- Back to Top
- Return to Local
Poll
Proudly brought to you by:
Most Popular Local
- Thieves strip $20K worth of copper wiring from gravel pit
- Cyclist killed on Higgins Avenue was passionate mentor, volunteer
- Pukatawagan RCMP looking for two dangerous suspects
- WWE's Jericho breaks code in Brazil
- Ex-Bomber sued for $4.8M
- Gang members get lengthy sentences for jailhouse beating
- Ex-Hydro boss slams closure
- Every year 4,000 children reported missing in Manitoba
- Man hit before fatal blow, friend testifies
- Union Station to receive $6.5-million makeover
- Bear pulls camper from outhouse, before being shot
- Cyclist killed in collision on Higgins identified
- Cyclist killed on Higgins Avenue was passionate mentor, volunteer
- A SHED is not enough
- Football star's fatal punch probed at manslaughter trail
- Cyclist killed in Higgins Avenue crash
- Sex-scandal inquiry to be heard in city
- Winnipeg man recovering after campground bear attack
- Man hit before fatal blow, friend testifies
- Female cyclist dies on Higgins after falling into semi's path
- Boozy night out, lying cost city man big bucks
- Neighbours shaken by two deaths
- Teen hit by vehicle on Pembina
- Rapid buses rattling homes
- Severe storm warning issued
- Has Gimli gone to pot?
- Bear pulls camper from outhouse, before being shot
- Cyclist killed in collision on Higgins identified
- Triple whammy hits homes
- Cyclist killed on Higgins Avenue was passionate mentor, volunteer
- Pukatawagan RCMP looking for two dangerous suspects
- Ex-Hydro boss slams closure
- Cyclist killed on Higgins Avenue was passionate mentor, volunteer
- At 100, she's still winning friends and winning at bridge
- His life made our world a better place
- Band, council defy feds on aid
- Hydro headquarters named Canada's greenest office tower
- Ex-Bomber sued for $4.8M
- Diplomat saved thousands from Hitler
- Cummings steps out of reunion for sick mom
- Bear pulls camper from outhouse, before being shot
- Pooch paradise, where champion beagles run free
- His life made our world a better place
- Winnipeg man recovering after campground bear attack
- He was enjoying view, bear came out of blue
- Scientists lash Harper government for pulling plug on Experimental Lakes Area
- Diplomat saved thousands from Hitler
- Weeding out the chemicals
- U of W rejects copyright deal as 'money grab'
- Chemicals not par for the course
- Bear pulls camper from outhouse, before being shot
- Has Gimli gone to pot?
- Pooch paradise, where champion beagles run free
- His life made our world a better place
- Scientists lash Harper government for pulling plug on Experimental Lakes Area
- RRC's old gem a beauty
- Attack on hockey ref nets jail time
- Our Village is as good as it gets
- Judge faces second complaint
- Winnipeg man recovering after campground bear attack
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010; View the changes. New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.