Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 05/15/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
NEW YORK -- "I hope that other women can benefit from my experience," Angelina Jolie wrote in a powerful op-ed article Tuesday, explaining her decision to go public with having her breasts removed to avoid cancer.
But amid the accolades for the film star's courageous revelation, doctors and genetic counsellors were careful to note her medical situation -- an inherited genetic mutation putting her at high risk of breast and ovarian cancer -- was very specific, and that her course of action made sense for only a small category of women.
Still, they hailed her bravery and said she would surely help increase awareness -- and thus, perhaps, help save some lives.
"Having this conversation empowers us all," said Rebecca Nagy, a genetic counsellor who works frequently with women who test positive for a defective version of the BRCA1 gene, as Jolie did. "It's wonderful what she's done."
In an op-ed piece in the New York Times, Jolie, 37, began by speaking of her late mother, Marcheline Bertrand, who died of cancer at 56, before she was able to meet most of her grandchildren.
The actress revealed that beginning in February, she underwent three surgeries -- which she succeeded in keeping secret from the public -- in which her breasts were removed, and later replaced by implants.
"I wanted to write this to tell other women that the decision to have a mastectomy was not easy. But it is one I am very happy that I made," Jolie wrote. "My chances of developing breast cancer have dropped from 87 per cent to under five per cent. I can tell my children that they don't need to fear they will lose me to breast cancer."
The actress also hinted she might, at some point, have her ovaries removed, saying she had "started with the breasts" because her risk of breast cancer was higher than that for ovarian cancer. She did not say when she was diagnosed with the faulty gene.
While admiring Jolie's straightforwardness, cancer surgeons and others in the medical community were quick to point out hereditary cases of breast cancer account for only about five per cent to seven per cent of all cases diagnosed each year, and those connected to the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes are an even smaller group.
And so, women shouldn't just run off and get tested for those genes, said Dr. Robert Shenk, medical director of the Breast Center at the University Hospitals Case Medical Center in Cleveland.
"My worry is that people will be inappropriately tested," said Shenk. Instead, he said, genetic counselling, including a close review of a patient's family history, is crucial.
Nagy, who is also president of the National Society of Genetic Counselors, agreed.
"The clues are in the family history. Has there been cancer in multiple generations? Are there clusters of cancers, like breast and ovarian, on the same side of the family? Has the cancer been diagnosed at an early age -- under 50?" she said.
-- The Associated Press
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition May 15, 2013 A4
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Portage La Prairie crash under investigation
Winnipeg family crowd sourcing liver donation for 11-year-old girl
Ethics commissioner dismisses counter-complaint Vic Toews made against Pat Martin
Manitoba's CFS to stop housing kids in hotels in June
Welcome to our cowardly new world order
City to use smoke bombs to control gopher population
Manitoba Hydro has spent $31 million on Conawapa station since report calling for spending to stop
Sentencing today for driver in crash that killed two students
Mayor Bowman target of online post inciting people to attack him; police examining situation
Police seek girl, 13, missing a month
Agricultural fertilizing can begin early: province
Police investigate assault on Hargrave
Mining firm, enviros in defamation court fight
Avalanche warning out for Rockies, parts of B.C.
Manitoba premier apologizes to First Nation
Warm today, but frigid Thursday
Rally against Bill C-51 to be held in Osborne Village
Obama: Canadian oil 'extraordinarily dirty'
Alberta, N.W.T. sign deal on Mackenzie River
Cars in CN train derail in southern Manitoba
Obama again whips up recipe for healthy kids
Grieving dad awaits report on deaths
Councillor to seek Conservative nod
If this were a joke, it would be funny
Compassion in the courtroom
Drawing aboriginal voters to polls
Lifting veil off attitudes about niqab, hijab
No penalty for bringing supper into Canada
Liberals set to roll out federal-election ads
Feds trample on Downs racing
We pledge to not blab to the media
Pal spins a squirrelly story
Annual Litter Index reveals Winnipeg's messiest streets
U of M workers brace for more job cuts
Tax breaks to cost public $7.7B per year: report
Winnipeg students to compete in U.S. ethics bowl
ER doctor acclaimed as federal Liberal candidate
More job cuts expected at U of M
Jeff Browaty wants to be federal Tory candidate in Kildonan-St. Paul