Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 08/22/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
Time is growing short for a decision on whether to build two hydro-electric generating stations in the province's north, Manitoba Hydro says.
In a document posted on its website Friday, the Crown power utility argues the Keeyask and Conawapa generating stations are needed in the next decade not only to meet the province's energy needs, but to meet demands south of the border and to the east and west.
The document is Hydro's Needs For and Alternatives To (NFAT) submission and it's been filed with the Manitoba Public Utilities Board (PUB), which is in the process of scheduling a hearing to see if the two dams are needed or whether there is something else -- and less costly -- Hydro can do to meet forecasted demands.
-- Manitoba Hydro president and CEO Scott Thomson
"Our analysis demonstrates that continuing to develop our hydropower resources is in the best long-term interest of Manitoba Hydro customers and the province of Manitoba," Manitoba Hydro president and CEO Scott Thomson said in a statement.
Hydro's preferred plan is no surprise as it's been the mantra of the ruling NDP for about the past decade.
The provincial government says while the cost of the two dams is high, the payoff to Manitobans through more export sales is bigger.
That's based partly on the phasing out of coal-burning plants in the United States and Canada and an increased pressure on both countries for renewable energy, such as hydro-electric power, in the makeup of a total state, provincial and civic power supply.
Hydro's plan calls for the start of construction of the 695-megawatt Keeyask generating station in June 2014, with the first turbine to start spinning by 2019. That is to be followed by construction of the 1,485-megawatt Conawapa generating station, with a 2026 in-service date.
The forecasted price tag for Keeyask is $6.2 billion and Conawapa is estimated to cost $10.2 billion. There will be an additional cost of running a transmission line to the Minnesota border.
Hydro's and the NDP's vision for the future is not without critics. The Progressive Conservatives say the plan is too costly for Manitobans -- it in part relies on a series of annual rate hikes to pay for it -- and others say the government's terms of reference for the NFAT review are too narrow. There is also concern the public won't have adequate input in the NFAT hearing.
Hydro says its NFAT submission offers the most detailed review of future options for meeting Manitoba's electricity demand. It includes 15 different plans over 27 scenarios involving more than 400 cases. The full NFAT submission is available on Hydro's website.
Hydro says alternatives to its dam-building plan include increased energy conservation by Manitobans, burning cheap natural gas to produce power, adding more wind farms and even importing power at peak times. The timing of Conawapa could also be pushed back depending on what happens in the energy markets.
The PUB is scheduled to hold public hearings during the winter and spring of 2014 and is to issue a report to the Manitoba government by June 20, 2014.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition August 22, 2013 B3
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
WSD hears delegations regarding religious exercises in public schools
Fans fully embrace whiteout tradition at MTS Centre
Lego store coming to Winnipeg, location still to be determined
New key adviser to Mayor Brian Bowman appointed
Jury hears murder confession from Trevyonne Willis
School swap debate forges on
WSD trustees to hear delegations about school swap, Bible studies
Former Conservative MP joins campaign to legalize marijuana
South district superintendent job eliminated
Emergency debate on sale of Wheat Board rejected
Winnipeg police investigate shooting death
Four charged after shots fired early Saturday in Portage la Prairie
Appeal court upholds verdict against former doctor who assaulted teenage patient
Suspicious packages sent to Manitoba courts came from China, posed no chemical threat: RCMP
Byelection for new MLA in The Pas to be held April 21
Brandon airport expansion set for fall
African groups pray for victims of Kenya attack
Committee to meet Tuesday to discuss hiring permanent ombudsman
Chilly start to the week in Winnipeg
Slow progress on revamping city's rooming houses
Liberals' optimism belies harsh realities
Snoring too loud? Blow a flute
Brother goes on Facebook to mourn
Winnipeg man killed in India
Little Brother 'another one of my friends'
Soldiers' sacrifices still not forgotten
University probes professor involved in stem-cell trial