Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 06/15/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
On a sunny afternoon in September 2008, the University of Manitoba signed a letter of intent to house a new Winnipeg football stadium within the sports precinct of its Fort Garry campus.
Four years and nine months later, Investors Group Field opened at the northwest corner of University of Crescent and Chancellor Matheson Road.
Winnipeg Blue Bomber fans could argue that should have been enough time to figure out some means of getting people to and from the new stadium in a somewhat orderly fashion. That, of course, didn't happen on Wednesday, for a variety of reasons.
The football club cites the unexpected willingness of Winnipeggers to take public transit to Bomber games, but that effort likely helped prevent even worse congestion.
Fans can blame the choice of location for the stadium, but Canad Inns Stadium was located in an even more congested area of the city and Pembina Highway, on paper, has a tremendous capacity as a traffic artery.
While the Bombers, the U of M, Winnipeg Transit and police continue to dissect Wednesday's debacle, it appears the transportation chaos wound up being the cumulative result of a series of small bad decisions.
Stopping every driver heading to the U of M campus is inefficient, as any Winnipeg Folk Festival parking-lot attendant could tell you. Given the benefit of hindsight, failing to place experienced police at key traffic checkpoints was another obvious mistake. So was forcing buses to queue up outside the stadium because there was nowhere else for them to go once passengers disembarked.
Another contributing factor was a lack of experience running a major event -- and the absence of continuity at the top of the organizations ultimately in charge of it.
In 2008, when the U of M was chosen as the football club's new home, current Bombers president and CEO Garth Buchko was running a pair of Winnipeg radio stations. Current City of Winnipeg chief administrative officer Phil Sheegl, who's also the chairman of BBB Stadium Inc., was the newly recruited director of the city's planning, property and development department.
The entire stadium project was led by lawyer and property developer David Asper, not the Winnipeg Football Club. Subsequent transit, traffic and parking studies were conducted in good faith to the best abilities of all the people involved -- and then implemented up to two years later.
St. Norbert Coun. Justin Swandel, whose ward includes the U of M's Fort Garry campus, endured what he describes as a very frustrating Wednesday night. But he still believes the game-day plan can be salvaged.
"The road capacity was there. The management of the flow was the issue and I think we'll resolve that over the next few days and over the next events," he said Friday.
The Winnipeg Football Club has no choice but to resolve it, as anything other than a radical improvement will result in financial disaster for the Bombers -- and taxpayers by extension.
The football club is on the hook for repaying $95 million of the stadium's $200-million price tag, plus interest. The first priority is a $10-million BBB Stadium loan to purchase advertising ribbons and other stadium amenities added on to the project after the "guaranteed maximum price" was set at $190 million.
Then comes an $85-million stadium-building loan that's currently serviced by the province. The time frame for paying that off was initially pegged at 45 years.
The entire purpose of building this stadium was to provide the Winnipeg Football Club with new revenues and as a result, long-term financial stability. If fans are too annoyed to visit the venue, those revenues won't materialize. That would endanger the non-profit Bombers and serve as a further drain on the taxpayers carrying the loan.
In other words, even if you don't care about football and have no intention of ever visiting Investors Group Field, it's in your best interest for the Bombers to solve their transportation woes.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition June 15, 2013 A3
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Winnipeg girl escapes grasp of attacker
Police HQ flood renovation costs $4.1 million - so far
Sex offender sought by police
Live on Sunday: NDP leadership vote
Police asking for 1.9 per cent increase in budget
Committee counts late-arriving delegate ballots from Swan River
Provincial ombudsmen express concern over anti-terrorism bill
Pallister compares NDP to Ringling Brothers
Three charged after drugs found in Portage la Prairie home
Eadie blasts frontage levy as unfair
Light snow expected, warmer temperatures for the weekend
Public's input sought on chief's job description
Missing St. Laurent teen last seen in Winnipeg
Man admits to serious assaults
On road to clarity for doctors
Seven years for sexual attack
Homeless, mentally ill get to work on creativity
Ashton sees win on second ballot
Kinsmen seek assurances for city pool
Reporter's Sinclair coverage recognized
Need for shelter never wanes
Timeline of a tragedy: The Candace Derksen case
Audit needed to find blame for stadium fiasco
Birth tops for hospitalization
New trial for convicted killer
Shocked by modern medicine
Another delegate controversy
'One day at a time,' mother pledges
Vaccination best way to avoid painful shingles
Newcomers getting help in drive for independence
Lawyer suspended over misconduct