May 22, 2015


Rooming-house loss a crisis

City's poor losing places to call home: advocates

There are 20 per cent fewer rooming houses in the Spence neighbourhood now than a decade ago.

That sounds like a good thing. Instead, inner-city activists say it's a crisis.

This Spence Street rooming house has 18 suites. Tenant Dave shows the tight hallways in the house.


This Spence Street rooming house has 18 suites. Tenant Dave shows the tight hallways in the house. Photo Store

This Spence Street rooming house has 18 suites and accompanying doorbells.


This Spence Street rooming house has 18 suites and accompanying doorbells. Photo Store

Rooming houses are often demonized as overcrowded, filled with bedbugs, crime-ridden blights -- the sprawling Balmoral Street house dubbed Murder Mansion is the most notorious example. There have been four homicides in five years there.

Despite their bad reputation, though, the dwindling number of rooming houses combined with the paucity of decent rentals for the very poor is the most pressing housing problem in the inner city.

New street-level research by the University of Winnipeg's Institute of Urban Studies and the Spence Neighbourhood Association attaches rare numbers to the problem, one no government has been willing to quantify.

'We know a number of landlords wanting to get out of the rooming-house business. It's not what they bargained for'

-- Spence Neighbourhood Association housing co-ordinator Isabel Jerez

Researchers went door-to-door and counted 117 suspected and confirmed rooming houses in the small West End enclave. Those are old houses that have been carved up into many tiny bedrooms, where tenants share a kitchen, bathroom or both.

Spence likely has the most rooming houses in Winnipeg, so many that the total estimated square footage equals that of the Canadian Museum for Human Rights.

But the number is shrinking. A decade ago, the IUS did the same kind of census and counted 145 rooming houses in Spence.

"We know a number of landlords wanting to get out of the rooming-house business," said SNA housing co-ordinator Isabel Jerez on a recent walkabout through the neighbourhood. "It's not what they bargained for. They didn't plan on being social workers."

No one knows the number of rooming houses in the city. No government keeps track and many rooming houses fly under the radar of the rules.

According to a dozen inner-city experts who spoke to the Free Press in recent weeks, rooming houses and their residents slip through the cracks of nearly every government policy, welfare program and regulation.

The IUS pegs the number of rooming houses in Winnipeg at roughly 1,000, with perhaps 6,000 residents.

In most cases, those 6,000 are the poor, the toughest-to-house, the most marginalized Winnipeggers. Some suffer from mental illness or addictions.

According to the new research, the typical rooming house in Spence is 110 years old, home to nine people who each have about 167 square feet to call their own. That's a little bigger than a parking space.

If two-thirds of all rooming-house residents in Spence are on social assistance, that means the province is spending more than $2 million a year to keep them in some of the worst housing in the city.

The figures are startling, made more so by the fact they represent one small West End neighbourhood, roughly 25 blocks.

"It's been 15 years and I'm still confounded by this issue, the enormity of it," said Jino Distasio, director of the urban institute.

Distasio says the number of rooming houses in a neighbourhood is a volatile thing. Some close, others open, some get flipped, others operate under the table.

And, with increasing real estate values, it's becoming more and more attractive for rooming-house owners to flip their big buildings into a triplex or a single-family home.

"In the longer term, we probably will see sort of a fading of rooming houses," said Distasio. "The market's gone up, they're tougher to manage, there are different pressures than there were five, 10 years ago."

And Distasio points to Osborne Village, once a hotbed of rooming houses, especially along streets such as McMillan Avenue.

Now, you'd be hard-pressed to spot one.

Though Spence has the largest number of rooming houses, West Broadway likely has the biggest concentration, and is the harbinger of gentrification.

"We've lost a ton of rooming houses, and what's left are in such bad shape that their days are numbered," said Greg MacPherson, executive director of the West Broadway Community Organization.

The agency has launched a pilot project to preserve and improve the remaining ones because once a rooming house gets sold and flipped, often a dozen or more affordable units are taken off the market, never to return.

Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition July 12, 2013 B1

Spence neighbourhood rooming houses

Icons indicate approximate locations of rooming houses in Winnipeg's Spence neighbourhood. Click for more information on each one.

Source: Institute of urban Studies (UofW) and Spence Neighbourhood Association. Map by Wendy Sawatzky.


Updated on Friday, July 12, 2013 at 6:20 AM CDT: Replaces photos, adds map, adds sidebar

9:21 AM: Clarifies that recommendations by Institute of Urban Studies were made ten years ago

You can comment on most stories on You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.

Have Your Say

New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.

Have Your Say

Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscribers only. why?

Have Your Say

Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press Subscribers only. why?

The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective January 2015.

Mike Deal | @wfpmdeal

May 21 11:09 pm

Lots of smoke at the #whiskeydix fire… heard on the scanner that flames had been seen. I didn't see any…

Winnipeg Free Press | @WinnipegNews

May 21 9:54 pm

Bombers great and NFL icon Bud Grant is having a garage sale, showcases goods on Twitter

Winnipeg Free Press | @WinnipegNews

May 21 8:50 pm

Classes cancelled on Garden Hill First Nation after death of Teresa Robinson

Winnipeg Free Press | @WinnipegNews

May 21 8:12 pm

Province readying to unseal adoption records next month

Winnipeg Free Press | @WinnipegNews

May 21 7:34 pm

'Use it or lose it' money rule hurts city

Scroll down to load more