15°c Clear
25°c Variable cloudiness
Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Brandon gambles on flood
Brandon is going to get its promised one-in-300-year flood protection, but it will have to wait until the fall of 2014.
"There have been changes in the schedule and the work will not be completed in 2013," city manager Scott Hildebrand told me. "The current schedule would be to complete the drainage works and undertake the first year of earthworks in 2013, then complete the earthworks in 2014. Our priority is to ensure that this project is done right the first time."
This is just the latest in a series of delays, leaving Brandon with worse than one-in-100-year flood protection until the spring of 2015 -- and that is assuming there are no additional delays.
In 2006, then-premier Gary Doer promised to work with Brandon to provide one-in-100-year protection. The city was never told about Doer's promise and the protection was not delivered. Had the promise been kept, three layers of sandbags would have saved Brandon from all of the anxiety, disruption and damages suffered during the 2011 flood.
During the height of that flood, Greg Selinger promised one-in-300-year flood protection for Brandon. On Dec. 27, 2011, he told the Brandon Sun, "We are moving ahead with one-in-300-year flood protection. The tenders are out on that."
In fact, no tenders had been issued at that time. The engineering drawings had not even been completed.
Senior provincial officials presented those drawings to Brandon's city council in May of this year, with a projected completion of this fall.
The plan would have provided Brandon with enhanced protection against flooding next spring, but in a surprising development, the province ceded management of the project to the city in July. With that hand-off in responsibility came a revised completion date of the fall of 2013. Now it's the fall of 2014.
If the province is concerned about the new timetable, it isn't showing it. In a prepared statement, provincial spokesman Jean-Marc Prevost said: "A complex project like this requires proper engineering assessments before construction begins, regardless of who is leading the project. We believe the City of Brandon is taking a responsible approach by ensuring that concerns raised in their engineering assessments are thoroughly addressed."
Progressive Conservative water stewardship critic Larry Maguire isn't buying the government's spin."
"It's another example of off-loading of responsibilities by this NDP government," he says. "With a billion-dollar deficit, they don't have the money to complete these infrastructure projects, so they've farmed it out to Brandon. Now Brandon's paying the price."
Manitoba Liberal Leader Jon Gerrard is more blunt.
"The province has broken its promise by leaving Brandon unprotected without a permanent dike until the spring of 2015... . It is shocking that the NDP have taken such a cavalier approach."
After a community experiences a one-in-300-year flood, it is easy to assume that there are 299 years to get ready for the next one. Is the Selinger government guilty of making this assumption? Are they taking the same risks previous governments have taken following significant Assiniboine River floods, by assuming they have plenty of time before the next big one?
It is a reasonable inference, given the evident lack of urgency they are showing regarding flood-protection improvements for Brandon.
If the 2011 flood taught us anything, it was that the decades-old flood-projection models for the Assiniboine are no longer accurate.
Communities such as Brandon are far more vulnerable, and given the multimillion-dollar cost of emergency flood fighting, it underscores the need for immediate flood protection. By delaying the completion of Brandon's permanent dikes until the fall of 2014, the Selinger government is betting serious flooding won't occur in 2013 and 2014.
It is a calculated risk that gambles with the lives and property of Brandonites, and with the finances of the province.
Deveryn Ross is a political commentator living in Brandon.
deverynrossletters@gmail.com
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition October 18, 2012 A11
More Analysis
- Back to Top
- Return to Analysis
More Analysis
(1 of 28 articles for this week)
Elijah Harper changed my world
06/17/2013 2:31 PM 0WESTBANK, B.C. — When Elijah Harper passed away on May 17, 2013 I felt as though an arrow had pierced ...
Poll
Most Popular Analysis
- Beauty and the (mortgage) Beast
- Best of bad odds in Syria
- That will be $90,000 down, please
- Canadian to expose alien collaboration with U.S.
- Work, not retirement, saves lives
- Was east side misled by NDP government?
- The view of Bipole III from Hart Mountain
- Mau Maus win 50-year-long battle
- Elijah Harper changed my world
- Smart people SLEEP LATE
- Too rural, too white, too male
- Canadian to expose alien collaboration with U.S.
- Smart people SLEEP LATE
- Hydro must serve citizens, not government
- Expense scandal dogs Nova Scotia's fading NDP government
- Was east side misled by NDP government?
- Beauty and the (mortgage) Beast
- Appalling rates of public-sector absenteeism must be addressed
- UNESCO's concerns unrelated to Bipole III
- What might it be like when pot is legal?
- Canadian to expose alien collaboration with U.S.
- Smart people SLEEP LATE
- Key of Bart: Video Killed The Mayor Who Hates The Toronto Star
- Too rural, too white, too male
- A sorry fact -- Katz finds it hard to apologize
- Ford puts Toronto on the map at last
- Manitoba Hydro's halcyon days are gone
- The key of Bart
- Ford can't resign as mayor soon enough
- Obama gets ‘revenge’ with Rice appointment
- Was east side misled by NDP government?
- Smart people SLEEP LATE
- UNESCO's concerns unrelated to Bipole III
- Aging makes women proud — and loud
- The view of Bipole III from Hart Mountain
- Work, not retirement, saves lives
- Hydro must serve citizens, not government
- UNESCO's concerns unrelated to Bipole III
- Canadian to expose alien collaboration with U.S.
- Erdogan — a Chavez-style strongman who gets results
- Aging makes women proud — and loud
- Was east side misled by NDP government?
- The view of Bipole III from Hart Mountain
- Anti-GM foods activist sees the science -- and the light
- Teachers should fast-track inclusive plan
- Power exercised in secret is most easily abused
- No bailouts required for Pollock's
- Teachers should fast-track inclusive plan
- Smart people SLEEP LATE
- Manitoba Hydro's halcyon days are gone
- Hydro must serve citizens, not government
- Shocking exclusion
- Canadian to expose alien collaboration with U.S.
- Gadgets in classrooms are gimmicks
- ‘Stand your ground’ case not what it seemed
- Hydro plans will be scrutinized in public
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
Have Your Say
Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscribers only. why?
Login SubscribeHave Your Say
Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press Subscribers only. why?
SubscribeThe Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.