5°c A few clouds
17°c Sunny
Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Earth Hour: verging on the occult
If previous Earth Hours are any indication, this Saturday's annual ritual will possess a curious blend of contradictions. Switching off the lights for an hour will have little effect on climate change, yet more people participate each year.
Earth Hour won't reduce the consumption of resources. It only delays it. A more effective way to pursue its goal would be to calculate one's annual income, divide it by the number of hours in a year and (cleanly) burn that much money -- less money equals less future consumption.
Some might say Earth Hour is meant to be a symbol. But it won't send a message to politicians and its hollowness causes other problems. And how many Earth Hour participants really enjoy sitting in the dark, as opposed to playing flashlight tag and attending Earth Hour concerts? The message politicians get is that people think this fights climate change, and any policies that actually restrict access to carbon-based energy would be political suicide.
Earth Hour dims the image of carbon emission reduction policies by associating them with hardship. If climate change mitigation policies were sold as policies of sacrifice, they'd be even less popular than they are already. The counter to this claim of sacrifice is that new technologies will make the shift to a low-carbon economy painless. Yet giving up light for an hour celebrates sacrifice and renounces technology.
This is the wrong image and the wrong policy. Earth Hour preaches deprivation but wealthier countries are better environmental stewards than poor nations. People tend to look after their most basic needs first and the environment second. Saving the Amazon rainforest as vital carbon sinks is good and well if you live in a country like Canada, but some people in Brazil are desperate enough for survival that the army must fight illegal deforestation. Wealth and technology should be the celebrated hope for solving problems like climate change; instead, Earth Hour symbolically switches them off.
In contrast, one U.S. think tank is promoting Human Achievement Hour, designed to coincide with Earth Hour. It's a meditation on economic and technological progress that, since 1800, has doubled life expectancies and fed six times more people than ever before. Human achievement all but eradicated countless diseases such as polio and tuberculosis; it also puts 300,000 new books on the shelves yearly, and so on.
I would bet long odds against Human Achievement Hour being anything but a fringe event. Popular culture has moved away from the values that created our prosperous society by choosing a festival that celebrates downplaying or opposing our wealth and technology.
At the most flourishing time in human history, popular culture takes human achievement for granted. Instead, it seeks symbolism that renounces the Enlightenment values of the last 200 years: quantifiable data, measurable results, reason and the liberation of humanity and nature from the effects of poverty that destroys both human souls and nature. In the broad sweep of history, movements such as Earth Hour are usually described as occult.
David Seymour is a senior policy analyst at the Frontier Centre, www.fcpp.org.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition March 26, 2010 A12
More Analysis
- Back to Top
- Return to Analysis
More Analysis
(1 of 32 articles for this week)
The number of words MPs speak in House counts
1:00 AM 0As a measure of gauging the volume or quality of work of Canada's members of Parliament, a series of calculations ...
Poll
Most Popular Analysis
- BlackBerry: off the mat, hitting back
- Japan's PM risks bankruptcy
- Physician networks a way forward for health care
- Canada's super energy potential
- Political opportunity knocks to abolish Senate
- A decade after Mad Cow — the legacy of a crisis
- Public debt management, the Alberta example
- Smart people SLEEP LATE
- Can't lose when ends justify means
- This summer, check out health care elsewhere
- The Angelina Jolie effect
- BlackBerry: off the mat, hitting back
- What is Struthers afraid of?
- 'Most hated man' in Senate
- Cash for coitus scheme gets axed in Oz
- Physician networks a way forward for health care
- Can't lose when ends justify means
- Never take candy from a stranger
- Ruining lives for cash flow
- Low turnout makes farce of B.C. election
- Don, it's not about nakedness
- Speeding fine only half of it
- Ashton might try to get the facts straight
- Ageism is rampant in Canada
- Canadian to expose alien collaboration with U.S.
- Smart people SLEEP LATE
- 'Done deal' offends Whiteshell cottagers
- What are they smoking at First Nations Bank?
- Manitoba could follow B.C. on surrogacy issue
- City council can't decide which bus to ride
- THIS IS NO WAY TO MAKE A POINT!!!
- Mental health system lacking funds, awareness
- Japan's PM risks bankruptcy
- Ruining lives for cash flow
- THIS IS NO WAY TO MAKE A POINT!!!
- What is Struthers afraid of?
- Harper embraces multilateralism on Arctic issues
- Mental health system lacking funds, awareness
- 'Genetic engineered' might save planet
- Why we assume the worst
- Public debt management, the Alberta example
- Japan's PM risks bankruptcy
- 'Done deal' offends Whiteshell cottagers
- Kim Sigurdson It's time for government fish monger to cut bait
- Speeding fine only half of it
- How CBC and others torque ratings
- Where is Canada's strategy to help Ukraine?
- Climate options -- grim, grimmer, grimmest
- Mother Nature springs into action
- Industry, First Nations partnerships exploding
- Ageism is rampant in Canada
- Female chiefs needed
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.