Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 08/25/2014 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
Last Modified: 08/25/2014 3:21 PM | Updates
For 38 years, Manitoba Hydro has managed the level of the province's largest lake and the flow of its largest river. It does so by means of Lake Winnipeg regulation (LWR), which includes the Jenpeg control structure -- located near my people's main community of Cross Lake -- and three man-made channels that increase outflow from Lake Winnipeg into the Nelson River.
After operating LWR for 38 years under an interim licence, Hydro has applied for a permanent licence.
Hydro is requesting no change to the water levels and flows stipulated in the interim licence. Hydro is requesting continuation of business as usual. For us, business as usual is a disaster.
Society has changed since the interim licence was granted. Best practises in environmental management have changed. Recognition of aboriginal rights has changed. The final licence for LWR must reflect these changes.
In a report recently submitted to the Clean Environment Commission, which will hold hearings into LWR licensing next year, Hydro acknowledges that LWR "has significant effects" north of Lake Winnipeg and that these effects "have been most pronounced for aboriginal communities." For Pimicikamak, the nation I represent, those effects include:
A homeland that was once intimately known, life-sustaining and beautiful is now dangerous and despoiled. Lake Winnipeg Regulation is a wound on our lands and in our hearts.
Every mention of "clean" energy is like salt in that wound. Every hydro bill is a reminder of the injustice we suffer.
Manitoba Hydro will say it has signed agreements with us and continues to address our concerns. An agreement does exist and Hydro has taken some measures, but the bitter reality is that the south is much better off as a result of the project and we are worse off.
As former Pimicikamak chief George Ross said, "the south is benefitting at the expense of our misery." This is why we cannot tolerate business as usual.
Hydro is not responsible for all the ills we experience, but it is in a good position to contribute to a better future. Hydro produces an average of over $3.5 million of electricity on the Nelson River every day. We are surrounded by tremendous wealth, but most of that wealth flows south down the transmission lines, leaving us poor and dependent on government. We don't want dependence.
There is an alternative. On July 2, Manitoba Conservation Minister Gord Mackintosh encouraged Hydro to work toward "reconciliation" with all hydro-affected peoples. I expect many Manitobans would welcome reconciliation, if it helped reverse the shameful inequality in our country.
Here's my four-part proposal for reconciliation, extending to LWR and beyond.
Benefit-sharing arrangements with aboriginal people affected by development have become common practice across much of Canada.
Like Pimicikamak, each affected community would have additional specific concerns to be addressed, but the above plan could serve as an overarching framework.
Next year, the government could issue a final licence for business as usual or it could use the occasion to make a bold commitment to tangible reconciliation.
I invite other hydro-affected peoples to stand up for this vision of reconciliation. And I invite all Manitobans to consider the value of such a path for the province as a whole.
Cathy Merrick is chief of the Pimicikamak executive council.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition August 25, 2014 A9
Updated on Monday, August 25, 2014 at 3:21 PM CDT: corrects typo
Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Plague, attraction of IS spreads
Still need public face on public space
The day it all changed
China wrestles to mimic, contain Hong Kong
Mediocrity in, mediocrity out
Please! A little perspective on byelections
Democracy run off the road in Cuba
Dangerous pandering to public on Ebola
Pinkwashing the cancer risk
Where have all the mayors gone?
Trudeau charm unlikely to woo Quebecers, polls suggest
U.S. leaders want to arm Ukraine
Not all Albertans thriving in booming economy
Drug treatment for female sexuality not about equality
Reworking Canada's prostitution law
No instant solutions for complex problems at city hall
The world's war on Ebola
Mulcair, Trudeau wrong on Islamic State
Subjugation, humiliation ultimate male power trip
Straight talk on Ebola risks
Chipping away at Hong Kong’s protests
A disservice to Murray and the museum
Russia’s real economic threat: falling gas price
Iran draws hard line on nukes
Solar gets cheap, challenges energy markets
Brandonites to vote on trust?
Make our child-care policy about education
Texas hospital ignorant, incompetent, indecent
Robot car: hit the shopping cart or stroller?
Other Opinion: Jolt globe out of economic mediocrity