Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 25/9/2008 (2835 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.
A while back, the erstwhile Hacks and Wonks
and yours truly duked it out over the Harper government's cuts to art funding. To summarize, I suggested
the cuts were bad strategy for the Tories, a policy that would re-affirm all the negative stereotypes about the Alberta-based Tory rednecks. The Hack eloquently suggested
I was out to lunch, and that cutting arts funding only affected a small group of fringe voters who do not support the Tories anyway. I think many blog readers agreed with the Hack, but I think that was because he wrote WAY MORE than I did. Quantity does tend to sway public opinion, IMHO. Seriously though, it was a vigorous debate with both of us trying to forecast what, if any, impact this policy would have on the electorate.It's way too early for anyone to say "I told you so" but there is some evidence that the arts cuts are hurting the Tories. Maybe not across the board, but in at least one key battleground - Quebec. The Globe's Adam Radwanski makes this observation
today, and references a steady slide in support for the Tories in Quebec, as reported by polling's It-Firm, Nanos Research.
The arts cuts are big news in Quebec, as witnessed by the rising up
of a group of Canada's most famous screen, stage and television actors. Will this translate into problems on e-day? That is the question the aforementioned Hack and I are hashing out.First, if all it took was an endorsement from a bunch of overpaid actors to win an election, the Democrats would have a lock on the White House. But the issue being debated here is whether this convinces voters who have traditionally rejected the Reform/Alliance/Conservative brand, and thus kept them from the promised land of a majority government. Many pundits smarter than me (and by that I mean they write more than me, too) believe a majority is only possible with a breakthrough in Quebec. Certainly, it was thus for Prime Minister Brian Mulroney
.If the Conservative campaign remains stalled with the support of about 38 per cent of decided voters, which is just short of what is needed to form a majority, the question should be asked about what it could have done (or not done) to get over that magic hump. By election day, we'll know for sure whether a combination of policies including the arts funding cuts doomed the Tories in Quebec. And then we'll know for sure whether it was decisive or not.UPDATE: The Globe's strategist panel weighs in on the arts funding issue.
I added to this post because, frankly, they all agree with me. I am mostly ignoring opinions that conflict with my own. That is, after all, the beauty of a blog, no?. :)-30-