Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION
Posted: 03/19/2014 12:18 PM | Comments: 0
I received two snippy emails on my coverage of school boards budgets.
Well, OK, a lot more than two complaints, but these two were signed.
One thanked The National Post for running a Frontier Centre report on public school costs increasing at a faster pace than enrolment, noting that he sure hadn’t seen that report in the Free Press.
The second found it funny that I make no mention of school trustees allegedly performing a tax grab under the confusion of reassessment.
Each year I read the FRAME (Financial Reporting and Accounting in Manitoba Education) report when it comes out in the fall, and I analyze it for both the newspaper and at far greater and more rambling length here in my blog.
And as enrolment has stagnated the last few years — up a few kids, down a few kids, statistically insignificant overall — I’ve pointed out that the costs of running the $2.1-billion public education system are going up seemingly inexorably each year by a ballpark figure of $75 million, maybe 3.5 to 4.2 per cent. Most of that is higher salaries and benefits combined with more people being on the payroll.
Each year, reader, each year.
As for the second, I’ve written about the assessed values of properties being the driving force behind the entire public school financing system — though taxes are the visible tip of the iceberg — about assessment’s creating inequities in what is purportedly an equitable public education system.
And I’ve explained umpteen times how to sleuth out if there’s been a tax grab.
One more time.
A mill rate is set by taking the assessment base and dividing it into the amount of money that school trustees want to raise through education property taxes, then doing a whole bunch of arithmetic. The result will be two digits, usually in the teens — occasionaly a single digit or in the 20s — followed by at least three decimal places.
Values usually go up during a reassessment, so now it’s a far bigger number being divided into the amount of money raised through taxes. Thus, mill rates usually go down after a reassessment.
That’s where trustees could pull off a tax grab, by raising far more money than usual in taxes, knowing most people couldn’t figure out what had happened.
So, the key is to look at the amount of money raised through the special levy year to year.
If it’s up 3.6 per cent, then the school board is not trying a sneaky tax grab. If it’s up 9.2 per cent, you have a gotcha moment.
A few years ago, after reassessment, Winnipeg school board claimed to have frozen taxes when the mill rate was the same as the year before. However, the amount collected through the special levy rose something like 7.7 per cent, so I reported a huge tax increase, which got the trustees really miffed.
Another year, another reassessment, St. James-Assiniboia compared the taxes paid by $100,000 homes year-to-year, and said it had kept taxes to about a $2 increase on that home, and most media reported that.
I reported a record tax jump for the division, something north of 15 per cent.
That’s because a $100,000 house before and after reassessment is not the same house; that $100,000 house last year will be a $119,000 house, or an $111,000 house.
All sorts of things affect how your tax bill this year will compare to last year, in percentage changes.
More taxpayers may have joined the tax rolls to share the burden, which generally will lower your poential increase — IKEA, for instance, or new homes in Amber Trails or Sage Creek paying property taxes for the first time.
Let’s say the average change in assessed value of homes in your division is an increase of $17,000. If your home went up $24,500, you’ll be paying a greater share than you did the year before, and the percentage that your taxes go up will be greater than the average; If your home went up $8,200 in assessed value, then the reverse happens, and you’ll pay a smaller share. On a typical tax bill with an average change of $50, you might be paying $60 or $40.
How different categories of properties change will also affect what you pay. If commercial reassesment went up seven per cent, while homes went up 19 per cent, more of the burden will be shared by homeowners.
And next week, someone who hasn’t read this blog will complain that I’m keeping this information hidden from befuddled taxpayers.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Why school taxes are going up volume 2015 chapter 1
Miami worth a trip in January
Delighted to be mobile at 8 a.m.
Warm and fuzzy feeling not enough for this donor
Somewhat bizarre correspondence
All the no-news that's fit to print
Today's news from the Babinsky bureau
Every once in a long while, I do something right
How come terrific read never gets nominated for a Giller?
And with a few keystrokes, repugnant misogyny
Babinsky remains a rebellion of one
Why not all bullying allegations lead to stories, and other stuff
Another user fee I'm thrilled to pay, Brian
How a sexual assault charge was handled within one school division
They ran, they lost, will they be back?
All kinds of stuff about Ed Hume
Yes, Rocky, it would have been OK, and other trustee election stuff
Ramos, at 19:58 of the third
Some reality checks on claims about WSD
Liberals have education vision, few detailed policies
Personal attacks taking over school board elections
Here's the real election excitement
Is anything at Red River College any of our business?
Why bother involving education minister, teachers in schools?
Saying you're a good person is not a campaign platform
Irascible senior gives rare glimpse of grumpy side
WSD election already down two incumbent trustees
Rare coverage for a school board candidate --- is it all planned?
On the beach, talking hockey back in the day
Student protests and oodles of other stuff, even some that's relevant
Missed my chance with The Prince of Pot
In which I presume to know more than Mr. Webb
Punting into the wind on objectification
Seriously, you need to book Expedia before convocation eve
Health minister endorsing fries?
Never know whom you'll meet
Two convocations and some unsolicited non-expert advice
One of my more unusual chastisings at the soccer pitch
Pallister seeks your education advice
Couchsurfers prefer a sedentary senior...alas...