August 1, 2015


$content.byline

Telling Tales Out of School

Doer gym honour survives, barely

Gary, your majorities with the Manitoba electorate were a lot more impressive than your 5-4 squeaker at Winnipeg school board this evening.

Though, to be fair, Gary Doer isn’t proposing that the George V School gym be named after him, he’s not campaigning on it, and no one knows what he thinks of the idea, since the Canadian embassy in Washington hasn’t responded to requests for comment.

FRED CHARTRAND / THE CANADIAN PRESS ARCCHIVES

The motion was to bounce trustee Mike Babinsky’s proposal to consider naming the soon-to-be-built elementary school gym after Doer over to a committee for study. Note that the motion is to consider naming, not to name, the gym after the former premier.

Among those opposing the referral were N-Dipper trustees Kristine Barr and board chair Suzanne Hrynyk.

You first read about Babinsky’s idea in our dead trees edition; you can refresh your memory here http://www.winnipegfreepress.com/local/trustee-says-name-new-gym-after-doer-others-puzzled-118638094.html.

Babinsky made a long, rambling pitch for his idea, relying on data he’d accumulated through extensive research on the department of education website and Wikipedia.

School divisions have named schools after all kinds of people, said Babinsky. WSD has named schools such as Norquay and Greenway after premiers whose ridings weren’t even in Winnipeg, let alone the division.

Lots of things other than schools have been named after politicians, he said — Sterling Lyon Parkway, Norquay Community Centre, The Knowles-Douglas Building at Brandon University.

Nary a school gym in there anywhere.

"The party he represented spent a lot of money in my community," said Babinsky.

It should be noted that there has never been a suggestion that Babinsky is a New Democrat. He’s a right winger on a lot of issues, once inexplicably ran for the provincial Liberals, but I’ve never heard him call himself a Tory.

Babinsky said that Doer represented Concordia riding for 23 years, and that George V is one of two WSD schools in Concordia, the other being Kent Road School. He didn’t mention that the vast bulk of Concordia encompasses River East Transcona School Division.

Babinsky did allow that he wasn’t advocating putting the proposal to a yes or no. "You have to ask the school parents whether they’re interested, you have to ask the community," he said.

Trustee Catherine Collins, a New Democrat who said she’s on a first name basis with Doer, eventually backed sending the referral to a committee, but was not particularly enthusiastic.

"The issue is, we don’t really have a naming policy," Collins said. When she was on the provincial heritage committee, people had to be dead five years to be considered for naming honours, the same policy that Ottawa uses, Collins said.

"We run the risk of doing what the City of Winnipeg did when it named Milt Stegall Drive — everyone wondered where it came from," Collins said.

Stegall, it should be pointed out, like Doer, didn’t ask to be involved in this discussion.

Relying on the Mr. Spock logic for which his debating skills are renowned, Babinsky pointed out to Collins that the school division has named 77 schools and other buildings without having a naming policy.

Barr said that the only named gym in the division is the Audrey Jones Fieldhouse at Tec Voc, named only after the community came forward and the division held widespread consultation.

Barr wanted to toss the whole idea.

"It will send a message to our community that we’re going to start naming gyms" in all 77 schools, said Barr. "I don’t believe we should open that can of worms."

Eventually, everyone voted, with Babinsky, Collins, Rita Hildahl, Anthony Ramos, and Darlyne Bautista putting it on a future agenda of the policy and program committee.

Opposed were Barr, Hrynyk, Joyce Bateman, and Jackie Sneesby.

Your tax dollars at work.

You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.

Have Your Say

New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.

Have Your Say

Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscribers only. why?

Have Your Say

Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press Subscribers only. why?

The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective January 2015.

Scroll down to load more

Top