Freezing fog

Winnipeg, MB

-3°c Freezing fog

Full Forecast

Freezing drizzle advisory in effect

The Crime Scene

Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION

Davis murder trial, the evidence in week four

Posted: 02/17/2014 3:00 AM

Advertisement

  • Print

Two men on trial for a brutal crime: The alleged premeditated murder of a handsome young Winnipeg man, Chad Davis, who went missing for months and was found July 23, 2008 in a barrel pulled from the Lee River.

Corey Tymchyshyn, 37, and Kristopher Brincheski, 31, are accused and presumed innocent.

This is a comprehensive recap of the fourth week of evidence heard in this complex, unusual and largely circumstantial case.

First week recap can be found here. Second week here. Third week here.

Allegations made in the Crown's opening argument can be found here [required reading, really].

Stories from the week are here and here if you don't want the full blow by blow. 

Although long, a close reading of Alex Brincheski's statement below is key to understanding his testimony. 

This was the final week of the Crown's evidence, prosecutors have now closed their case and jurors are due back Tuesday [Feb. 18] to see what's next for them.

Day 15

Alex Brincheski, affirms to tell the truth

Direct testimony, Crown Eyrikson examining

  • 25-years old, brother is Kristopher Brincheski. 
  • The last he and Crown spoke was at the preliminary hearing in 2010
  • Not under the influence of intoxicants today. 
  • Made a statement to police in 2008, and participated in the prelim in 2010
  • He got transcripts of the preliminary hearing from Gerri Wiebe, Kris' lawyer. 
  • He more looked over his police statement, just read "a little bit" of the prelim transcripts. 
  • "I was just more focused on my original statement."
  • His Sept. 5, 2008 statement to police: reviewed it on "friday night."
  • No, no threats made to him regarding his in-court testimony. 
  • Has lived in Lac du Bonnet, grew up there with Kris. 
  • Kris moved out at age 18, "I'm pretty sure."
  • Kris is not living in LDB now, he's married to DS.  
  • Alex, at age 18-19, came to live with Kris in Winnipeg at 52 Beeston Dr. 
  • He worked with Kris at "Brincore" roofing company. 
  • "It was just me, Kevin [Marchand] Kris and Corey."
  • He worked replacing shingles, his brother taught him the ropes. 
  • "Most of the time, I was just usually helping my brother."
  • The only nickname for his brother he knew of: "Burn."
  • "Skinner" was Tymchyshyn's nickname. 
  • At that time, a young woman named B.B. was his girlfriend. 
  • DS had a son that wasn't Kris', believed him to be around 7-8 years old at that time.
  • No, wasn't aware of DS and Tymchyshyn ever having an affair. 
  • No, never saw those two texting back and forth that he's aware of. 
  • Did not know a person named Chad Davis. 
  • On Sept. 4, 2008 was living at Beeston Dr. 
  • Yes, something happened that saw them displaced from the residence. 
  • He and Kris were working at a roofing job when Kris got a call from DS, saying that "there was police coming to the home for a search."
  • He witnessed this call. "He was told the cops were coming to the house to search."
  • This was around noon or 1 p.m.
  • He and Kris went home to Beeston, might have been a 20-30 minute drive. 
  • "It was kind of just like out of nowhere" that they were going home. 
  • "He said that police were coming to search the home, he didn't say exactly why."
  • "We got there and he started moving stuff around."
  • Yes, it did seem hurried, leaving the job site they were at. 
  • "He just seemed that he was really panicked." 
  • Kris was grabbing "miscellaneous items" and putting them in his truck.
  • "He said that the had to get rid of Chad's stuff out of the house … cops were coming to search the house."
  • "I was just kind of in shock." 
  • A surround-sound system and a TV was what was grabbed, loaded into the box of his truck. 
  • He's "pretty sure" Kris didn't say where Chad's stuff came from. 
  • He didn't help move the items, seemed "wrong."
  • "I didn't want to help him move somebody's stuff that was stolen — become an accomplice."
  • At that point, he knew Chad Davis wasn't alive, and "not very good" was how he felt about that. 
  • There was a big-screen TV in their basement. 
  • "I remember him saying that he bought it but I don't know exactly where it came from."
  • He ID's photos of items RCMP took at Beeston. 
  • They left Beeston and stopped at a 7-11 store to use a pay phone and get a drink. 
  • He arranged to go to Assiniboine Park where DS and BB were. 
  • Yes, is fair to say Kris seemed "scared," "frightened" and "frantic."
  • "I really didn't know what to think at the time." 
  • Kris dropped him off at the park, took about 45 mins to an hour to get there. 
  • He didn't ask where Kris was going. 
  • "I was more or less just wanting to see my girlfriend."
  • DS was having cheerleader practice, BB was watching. 
  • He felt "a little bit freaked out."
  • "I probably did" talk to BB about the incident. 
  • They were allowed to go back to Beeston to get a couple of things. 
  • He's unsure today if he and DS discussed what was going on. "We must have discussed it but I can't remember that far back."
  • The drive back to Beeston — with DS, BB and a friend of DS's — was anywhere from 30-60 minutes. 
  • He's unsure if the fact Kris had a dead person's stuff was part of the conversation. 
  • "It may have. But I can't remember anything we talked about in that car."
  • The get there, the place is taped off and police cruisers were there. 
  • He doesn't remember phoning Kris when he got there. DS or BB "may have" called him, is unsure.
  • They were allowed in to get a few things, like a toothbrush and change of clothes, not to "clean out the closets."
  • "It was kind of obvious they were doing a search," and Kris had said they were coming to search the house. 
  • Yes, the only time he actually knew the cops were at the house was when he saw them there. 
  • The RCMP, for "the most part" treated him with respect. 
  • They were there for 10-15 minutes, and watched by officers as they gathered things. 
  • The went to BB's uncle's apartment to stay (He and BB) — can't remember the street name it was on, but says it took about 20-30 mins to get there, was on the other side of the Chief Peguis trial bridge. 
  • They went there because they needed a place to stay. 
  • DS was the one who dropped them off. 
  • She "was as normal as she could be — she seemed a little worried about Kris at the time."
  • Said the main doors of the apartment they went to didn't lock. 
  • Can't remember if BB's uncle's family was informed that Beeston was being searched. 
  • Yes, he was curious about what Kris may have been involved in. 
  • He and BB looked stuff up on the internet. "I was a little bit stressed out."
  • Can't remember exactly what he and Kris talked about with respect to Davis being missing — can't remember.
  • Can't recall having contact with Kris that night. No, didn't try calling him. 
  • The next morning (this is now Sept. 5) he either texted or called him. 
  • BB had had his cellphone the day before, that's why the 7-11 pay phone was used. 
  • Kris knew Alex didn't have any money, so Kris drove to the apartment to give him some money. 
  • He drove a Ford F-150 truck. 
  • Kris said he was "sorry about the house being taped off."
  • "Just that he was sorry that he dropped this on me."
  • To Alex, that meant: "Stuck in the middle of it," that Kris meant it was his "fault you can't go home."
  • Yes, anybody would have been curious about these circumstances, but can't remember asking Kris any questions. 
  • "He seemed like he was in a hurry and I had to go drive my girlfriend to work."
  • Kris said "he stayed at a hotel." 
  • BB worked in the downtown, at the Sears building, doing "phone ordering."
  • He then went back to the apartment and called CS, a friend. "I didn't want to sit in the apartment the entire day."
  • May have called his parents, isn't sure. 
  • He had BB's car for the day, and met with CS at his apartment between 10 a.m.-12 p.m.
  • They drove around and went to buy weed, maybe an 8th or a 1/4 oz. They smoked some of it in the car. 
  • "We had a water bong in the car."
  • "I'm pretty sure we ended up smoking the whole bag" [that day].
  • Believes he gave some to Kris, met up with him at the hotel he was at, possibly the Cavalier. 
  • Kris walked over to the car, they gave him 1-2 grams. This was somewhere around 10:30 a.m. to 12:30 p.m.
  • They didn't discuss the incident at Beeston Drive because CS was there. 
  • Can't remember telling police or the preliminary hearing about the Cavalier meet-up. 
  • It may have been in the preliminary hearing he said this, can't be sure. 
  • They were there for 10-20 minutes, then drove around. 
  • "I wasn't really that high at that point," had only smoked about 1/2 joint before meeting Kris. 
  • "Wasn't completely stoned." 
  • Yes, was a seasoned pot smoker then. He'd smoked it daily at the job sites they worked, before we started around 6-7 a.m.
  • They'd work long days, over the course of the day, he'd smoke 2-4 joints. 
  • "Three to four, maybe."
  • He didn't use power tools at the sites. Mostly, he moved shingles, cleaned up, stripped them off roofs. 
  • Yes, required balance to move shingles up ladders. 
  • After the Cavalier, he and CS drove around, smoking weed, sharing it equally. 
  • No, he wasn't concerned about driving, was aware of what's happening around him. He was driving. 
  • No, they didn't run any lights and had no accidents. 
  • They went back to apartment, where BB's uncle's partner was "weirded out" by CS being there. 
  • They went out to sit in the car to continue to smoke up, were there for about two hours. 
  • "I was pretty stoned at that point."
  • They were more or less cautions about being caught smoking up in the car. 
  • He then drove CS back to his downtown apartment, no runned lights, no accidents. 
  • This took about an hour, to his knowledge not smoking any more pot. 
  • Can't remember the street CS lived on, maybe Broadway. They went up to his place. 
  • He didn't discuss the previous day's events with CS, despite that he was one of his "better friends." 
  • They were in the apartment for about an hour, no more drugs, no alcohol was consumed. 
  • He then drove from there to get BB, 10-20 mins away in the downtown. 
  • He didn't smoke on the way — but is "getting tired, still kind of feeling the effects."
  • The bong is on the back seat floor No he didn't want people to see it. 
  • He often left the bong in the car — "I don't think [BB] enjoyed it being there, but I don't think she minded it being there."
  • She got a call from a step-realtive and they went to McDonalds to meet up and get a bite to eat. 
  • Yes, this was the first time he'd disclosed they'd gone to McD's.
  • He had a burger and fries. It took about 45 minutes — it's now about 4 or 5 p.m.
  • He and BB went back to the apartment, but doors locked and they had no keys, so they sat outside on the front steps, then walked to the car. 
  • Two officers pulled up. He felt "burnt out" from the weed and really tired at this point. 
  • He was feeling some paranoia, but could still tell right from wrong. 
  • The cops were in suits, in unmarked vehicle. No lights or sirens. 
  • They ID themselves, were "for the most part" polite. 
  • They didn't cuff him. Asked he and BB to come for a talk. 
  • No, not under arrest, not charged with anything. 
  • They drove at "normal speed" back to D-Division HQ on Portage. 
  • The conversation in the car was "pretty light."
  • He didn't find them intimidating, particularly. 
  • He believe cops wanted to talk with him because "of our house being taped off — it was because of the search" and Kris's possible involvement. 
  • They went in the front door of D-Division, into the lobby area and sat down with BB. 
  • "Tying to both figure out why we were there." 
  • Was pretty sure it was because of the house being taped off. 
  • Can't recall giving BB instructions on what to say to RCMP. "It's possible."
  • In front of an interview room, RCMP officer took his particulars. 
  • Yes, there was time when he was with Kris on a roof, on Ashmore St.
  • They were alone. 
  • Yes there were times he was in a vehicle with Tymchyshyn and Kris. 
  • Yes, there was a time when the truck were in pulled over and Tymchyshyn and Kris got out to talk. He stayed in. 
  • "It seemed a little bit odd." — "Seemed weird," had never seen them do that before. 
  • He was with Kevin and watched Tymchyshyn and Kris talk away from the vehicle. Was a 5-10 minute conversation. 
  • Yes, at the prelim he testified and told the truth

Jury excused briefly. 

  • Yes, "I felt like I was" being honest with the police on Sept. 5 — "being as honest as I could."
  • No, didn't tell the total truth to the police that day, same thing he said in his "recant."
  • On Sept. 23, 2008, sent a 1-page document to Wiebe's office (Brincheski's lawyer) to "Recant."
  • The main issue "Just the fact that I said my brother was there."

Jury excused briefly. 

  • The conversation of Ashmore: was just the two of them (he and Kris) there. 
  • The conversation: "Just that he told me what he figured happened to him … what he knew."
  • "He just told me."
  • "That that guy had gone to Corey's and that was the last place he had seen."
  • Kris had told him about spending the night in "the cop shop," where he was questioned "about Chad," "His disappearance." 
  • His assumption is Kris was in Winnipeg police custody. 
  • "He didn't really say anything that involved him directly."
  • "He never said anything to me that directly involved him."
  • "The only thing that I know of is that his stuff was at his house."
  • "He never said he was there. I've been in that garage before too."
  • Kris had said "somebody had snuck up on him when he entered the garage."
  • "He knew — somebody else had told him." 
  • "He told me what he thought he knew … what he figured he knew."
  • Didn't remember Kris saying anything to him about a barrel. "Not that I remember."
  • "No," Kris never said anything about weights being put in a barrel. 
  • More on what Kris said: "Just that Chad went into the garage and there was someone waiting in there for him."
  • Kris didn't say how he knew this information. 
  • "I really didn't want to be involved in it."
  • Kris said "that he was beaten to death."
  • "I have no idea" how he knew that. 
  • Kris came into Chad's stuff: "apparently him and Corey split it up at some point."
  • No, Kris never talked about "luring" Davis to 703 Prince Rupert Ave.
  • "Yeah," he loves his brother. 

Morning break, court resumes

[To spell things out more clearly, am now moving to a mixed Q and A format of exchange between Alex Brincheski and Crown Keith Eyrikson. Note: the answers, not the questions, are the evidence.]

  • No, didn't discuss his evidence with anyone over the lunch break. 

On the rooftop on Ashmore: Did your brother tell you where the homicide of Chad Davis occurred?

  • "Yes he did."

Where?

  • "Corey's garage."

Was he present when it happened? 

  • "I don't know." He didn't ask if Kris was present. 

Are you sure of that, sir?

  • "Yes."

Positive? 

  • "Yes."
  • No, seeing his police statement to refresh his memory won't help in that regard. 

Not a thing? 

  • "Nope." 

It won't help you at all? 

  • "No."

And the reason is because you read it already?

  • "Yes." 

Kris didn't tell you the number of people present in Corey's garage?

  • "No."

Did he tell you if he was one of the persons present? 

  • "No."

Or tell you he was forced to participate in the homicide of Chad Davis?

  • "No he didn't."

[Paraphrased question] Did he mention a storage locker?

  • "No."
  • Yes, he did tell RCMP that Kris was present, he concedes. 
  • "At that time I thought he actually was there."
  • A week or two after telling them this, he changed his mind about this. 
  • "I don't remember him telling me he was there … it was nearing the end of my statement and I wanted to leave."
  • Yes, he went into the RCMP room where BB was and talked to her. "They let me go in there."

Did you tell her to tell the police the truth? 

  • "Yup … I told her to tell them what they wanted to hear — not drag it out."

[Jurors hear Eyrikson tell Justice Keyser the Crown is making an application to her under section 9(2) of the Canada Evidence Act.]

Jurors excused briefly, and then they return. 

Alex Brincheski, ctd:

  • The only thing he lied to police about on Sept. 5, 2008 was saying that Kris was there. It was to get out of RCMP custody. 
  • Everything else in his statement was "completely the truth."
  • And yes, told police Davis was killed in the garage. 
  • "According to what (Kris) told me."
  • Kris told him the murder happened at Corey's house in the garage, and was telling the police the truth. 

He didn't tell you anything about a barrel? 

  • "No."

[Eyrikson challenges him with portions of his police statement

He told you he was there … what else did Kris tell you? What did they do with him?

  • "Put him in a barrel." 
  • Yes, he could have told police he'd heard about this some other place. 
  • "I was trying to do my best to help them [the police]."
  • "I really wanted to leave at that point … I was trying to be as honest as I could."
  • Knew that he'd be kept there longer if he didn't tell them something. 
  • "After, I realized I wasn't being truthful about me saying that he was there."
  • He had no idea there were weights put in the barrel. He just made this up.

How many people did you tell police were there?

  • "I remember just two."

Police statement: Const. Bairos asks, "who was all there when he was killed?"
A: "As far as I know, it was just him and ...

  • "That's what I assumed."
  • Yes, he left police with the impression this is what Kris told him directly. 

So, you didn't tell police the truth and instead implicated your brother in a homicide?

  • "Yup."

[He's challenged more on things he told police and the court at the preliminary hearing.]

  • "I never asked him how he knew."
  • Only "yes and no" wanted to know if Kris was actually involved in the killing. 
  • "I was worried he was involved in it."
  • Yes, he did tell police how Davis died, and that information came from Kris. 
  • Yes, he was telling police the truth. 
  • "He never specified if he saw it happening or knew from somebody else." 
  • He doesn't know how his brother knew this information. 
  • It would surprise him, yes, that Kris wasn't interviewed by RCMP prior to them approaching him. 
  • "I just wanted to get it over and done with and leave." 
  • No, the police never threatened him to say anything. 
  • "I know, I swear I'm not lying to you now," he told RCMP on Sept. 5, 2008. 
  • Yes, he was telling the police the truth. 
  • Yes, he does want to be in court to testify. 

"This is what I know. I'm not just guessing giving you false … make shit up just to give you," he told police.  "From the most of my knowledge, this is what I know," he said.

  • He told RCMP "they took him into the garage" to get out of the police station. 

[More challenges on the contents of his police statement.]

Don't you think it would have been more helpful to say, 'you know what — I don't know where he got this stuff from?

  • He agrees he never mentioned in his interview that he wasn't certain where Kris got his information from. 

[More challenges.] 

  • Says his understanding was what he was telling police was to remain between him and the officers. 
  • Acknowledges that he knew they were videotaping his statement. 

Eyrikson, directly: Your brother admitted this homicide to you. 

  • "No."

You didn't have any idea … your brother could be arrested for this homicide?

  • Said he called RCMP after Kris's arrest to complain about their conduct. 

Eyrikson, directly: You didn't know what to do but tell the police the truth that day. 

  • "Yeah." 
  • He and BB returned to the apartment afterwards, yes, RCMP were kind to them. 
  • Yes, it was a great weight off his shoulders because his brother had confessed a homicide to him and he'd gotten that information out. "Yes."
  • He hoped the letter to the lawyer on Sept. 23, 2008 to recant his police statement would be shared with the police and the Crown. 
  • He wanted the whole thing gone and his statement quashed. 
  • Agrees that in that letter he never says: "I lied."
  • It was "not the total truth" what he told police. 
  • Yes he could have said that Kris got the information he shared from different sources. 

Court recesses for the day and subsequent day. 

Day 16 — Alex Brincheski, ctd.

[Jurors are shown the video statement Alex Brincheski gave to police on Sept. 5, 2008] 

BRINCHESKI Alex Statement - Edited Copy:REDACTED by James Turner

 

 

After it's shown, Keyser warns the jury they're only to use it in their deliberation of the case against Brincheski, not Tymchyshyn.

Cross-examination by Gerri Wiebe, for Brincheski:

  • Yes, was 19 at the time came to live on Beeston Drive, Kris was 26. Kris had moved out of the Lac du Bonnet family home when he was 17-18 years old. 
  • Up until coming to live with Kris on Beeston, hadn't lived with him for 8-9 years. 
  • He was living in Lac du Bonnet on July 23, 2008 when Davis was found. 
  • He then lived with parents and his girlfriend, BB.
  • BB and the parents had a falling out, so he upped and moved with her in a "relative hurry."
  • They moved in with Kris, DS and her son on Beeston. 
  • Yes, it would surprise him to hear that DS's son was 2-3 years old and not 7-8 as he thought. 
  • Kris and DS had been together for about a year, and yes they'd had some troubles. But they seemed like a regular couple. 
  • Yes, their relationship [DS and Kris] was "complicated."
  • No, he'd known nothing about roofing, he'd been a butcher at a Lac du Bonnet store. 
  • Kris showed him the roofing ropes, he was his helper, he'd always work with him. 
  • 'Brincor' was Kris and Corey's company. 
  • Had seen Kris use cocaine once right in front of him, got impression he was using more than he saw. 
  • Kris had spent time at Addictions Foundation of Manitoba rehab. 
  • Seeing him use cocaine was concerning to him. 
  • Alex himself was smoking pot pretty much each day back then. 
  • He and others at work would have "safety meetings" where they'd smoke joints in the car couple times a day. 
  • The weed would only somewhat affect his ability to work on roofs. 
  • Yes, he smoked up the night before testifying at the preliminary inquiry. 
  • Marijuana does not make him slur words, stumble around. The more he uses it the easier it is for him to hide the effects it has on him. 
  • Yes, weed impairs his ability to make proper decisions, control impulses and what he hears and says.
  • Lac du Bonnet in Summer: its population grows, it's a "small town."
  • The body found in the barrel was a big deal, yes. 
  • Rumours swirling about who it was, when it happened and how. 
  • Before giving statement, he went on the Internet to search out information about the investigation. 

[He's asked about news articles, one from July 24, 2008 where it says two men opened a large plastic barrel with holes in it] 

  • He was aware of this information. Was aware of the men saying they'd been hit by a stench, that industrial plastic was inside, that RCMP went to the location where body was found. It also caused a stir in Lac du Bonnet because several officers in the "musical ride" were called away to the scene. 
  • He wasn't aware of an article saying Davis was last seen on Feb. 6, but was aware of a report saying Davis had stepped out to give a friend a ride, was last seen in the 700 block of Prince Rupert Ave. 
  • Was aware of an article quoting Courtney Sych that Davis's disappearance didn't add up and no taxi was ever dispatched to the home. 
  • It was Kris saying he'd been at the "cop shop" that made him ask him what was going on.
  • Kris had said the questioning was about the disappearance of Chad Davis. 
  • To him, this meant Kris was under police suspicion, so he asked what's going on. 
  • And this conversation happened on the roof on Ashmore. 
  • Yes, he's "really confused" about what he told RCMP in his statement. 
  • Yes, he wanted to help them, and told them the truth, but also lied to them. 
  • He wasn't happy to be in a police station. 
  • Past dealings with police had limited his trust in them. 
  • He didn't feel like he had the right to say no to them. 
  • He thought that Kris might be involved and didn't want to talk with them. 
  • He had no way of getting home if he just decided to leave the police station. 
  • He thought he'd be in trouble for not coming forward with the information he thought he had. 
  • Thought police may be trying to trick him into confessing something.

"What I'm trying to do here is figure out what you mean when you say you were telling the truth but that you were lying," Wiebe tells him. 

  • He believed that Kris was telling the truth when he said what he said on the roof. 
  • At the time of that disclosure, he knew that the body was found in the river, that Tymchsyhyn had been spoken to and it all made sense. 
  • On Sept. 5, 2008, sats he actually believed Kris was involved because of the "cop shop" comment. 

[Wiebe suggests to him that Kris never spent the night in police custody, was in fact trying to cover up an affair.] 

  • At that time, he believed Kris was involved and it was weighing him down. 
  • Yes, he was conflicted because Kris was his brother, but he was also angry for the situation he'd been put in. 

What you thought you knew about what happened was all intertwined in your brain, Wiebe says. 

  • "I agree," he replies. 
  • Says he doesn't have the best memory, it's "pretty average," that on the best of days isn't so good. 

[Wiebe takes him through his recollection of what he says he did on Sept. 5 before the interview, points out that several things differ from what he said at the preliminary inquiry, including: he previously said he picked Kris up and they went to buy weed together, that the hotel was the Silverado then, and that he'd said CS was driving whereas in direct he said he was. Also, at the prelim he never mentioned going back to CS's apartment before getting BB from work and that he's smoked 8 or more joints that day.] 

  • He has a pretty hard time remembering things, especially when he's smoking weed, which is what he was doing on the day of the roof conversation with Kris. He couldn't tell police exactly when or where this conversation took place. 
  • No, doesn't remember the exact words Kris used in the conversation. 
  • Yes, it's fair to say that what he heard was "all mixed up" with things he'd read on the internet and town gossip. 
  • The information he had about the investigation came from a number of different ways. 
  • He made assumptions when he was asked what was used to weigh down the barrel [he'd told police "Maybe rocks or something, I don't know."] 

Wiebe takes him through several passages in his statement, including how he said on Page 15, "I wish I knew, I really don't know how he was killed." and, later, "I don't know" when he's asked how Davis "got his life taken from him."

  • He didn't know that the victim was beaten to death, he tells court. 

Wiebe continues to point out vagueness in some of his police statement answers. 

  • After giving his statement, Kris was arrested within a couple of days, he tried to find phoning police to complain that what he'd told them he thought wasn't to be shared. 
  • When that didn't work out, he sent a "recant" fax to Wiebe's office. He was still angry at the police and blaming them for what happened. 
  • He didn't want police to think he'd lied to them, and yes he got "a little carried away" trying to help them. 
  • When blaming the police didn't work, he retained his own lawyer in October 2008. 
  • He had to get a copy of his statement because he couldn't remember what he'd said. 
  • He was allowed to go to the Crown's office in January 2009 to watch it. 
  • He then, with lawyer Kathy Bueti, drew up a 5-page affidavit sworn Jan. 29, 2009 trying to explain what happened. 

Wiebe reads it into the record. There are 30 points, including that what he told RCMP was not an "accurate recollection" of events, and that Kris did not say that he was there at the homicide. He also says he felt "paranoid," emotional and "pressured" into saying things so he could leave police custody. He was "coaxed and led" by police to the point he felt he was telling them what they wanted to hear. 

  • He was just trying to do what he could to make things right. 
  • Tymchyshyn never spoke to him, ever, about the case. 
  • It's "correct" that Tymchyshyn never told him anything. 

Day 17

Agreed statement of facts:

  • During the initial search of 703 Prince Rupert Ave, heat lamps and small marijuana plants were found under some stairs, in a crawlspace. 
  • During a search of the garage, tools, including a hammer were found. 
  • "The hammer was not seized by officers."

Cpl. Christian (Chris) Rouire, RCMP, sworn

  • 13 years with the RCMP. 
  • 8 Years as Major Crime Unit investigator. 
  • He was "primary" investigator on Davis file, and team commander. 
  • "This is a large investigation."
  • About 70 police officers involved, more than 400 separate tasks. 
  • Disclosure alone ran from 13,000-15,000 pages. 
  • "At least" 150 witnesses interviewed. 
  • No, not every witness called at trial and not all information gathered was presented. 
  • The RCMP took over WPS missing persons investigation because of jurisdiction [Lac du Bonnet] when Davis was found. 
  • RCMP met with Winnipeg police, they turned over their missing persons file, "we verified a lot of their information."
  • A homicide probe is different than a missing persons one. 
  • Not every piece of evidence gathered immediately holds significance. 
  • "We don't know what they may mean but we don't know the importance down the road."
  • Yes, on Sept. 4, 2008 Beeston Drive was searched by RCMP, Sept. 5 Alex Brincheski was interviewed.
  • On Sept. 4, they had DS in RCMP station, she wasn't arrested and she gave an interview. 
  • Afterwards, she was in the lobby "using a phone," indicated she was talking to Kris. 
  • He was told RCMP was coming to secure the home. That was a concern. 
  • "She may be telling him to get rid of stuff."
  • They didn't know where Kris was at this point. 
  • Kris Brincheski was never interviewed or spoken to by RCMP prior to Sept. 5. 
  • A civilian employee's check of the RCMP records showed he was never interviewed in 2008 prior to Sept. 5. 

[Eyrikson takes him through specific bits of the investigation, it switches gears a bit from here]. 

  • He was the one who checked the numbers for the Super 8 motel on Portage. 
  • The 810-20** number the "don't miss" text was sent to was a prefix in Manitoba that was "not in service."
  • That prefix in Manitoba did not exist.
  • On Feb. 6, 2013, he drove the distance from 703 Prince Rupert Ave. to the "Pinawa Channel Bridge" near Lac du Bonnet. 
  • Left from the back lane at 9:35 a.m., through the city to Highway 59, east onto PR 317, left on PR 11, right on PR 313.
  • It took 1 hour and 13 mins to get there, a distance of 116.6 k.m.
  • He drove the speed limit, largely. 
  • "I'm 99 per cent sure it was clear, sunny day that day." 

Holdback information:

  • This is information "we don't disclose." "Don't release to the public." "We don't tell to Chad Davis's family."
  • The holdback evidence is used to verify the truthfulness of their witnesses. 
  • On Sept 5, 2008, holdback evidence included: Cause of death, that objects used to weight barrel down, that a hat was found in the barrel, the description of clothing items. 
  • The interview with Alex Brincheski on Sept. 5 was the first they'd heard of garage as possible crime scene. 
  • "That's the first time we heard of it. We never heard anything about it before that. 
  • Yes, Prince Rupert Avenue was known to the public as the last place Davis was seen [700 Block].
  • "We didn't know where it happened until that day." 
  • DNA results would also be holdback, not disclosed. 
  • Same goes for the "coiled plastics" such as found in the barrel and cleaning kit. 
  • He read four news articles from July 24, 2008, 25th, 27th and Aug. 3, 2008 for court. 
  • Cause of death is not mentioned in any of these articles. 
  • Nor are metal weights. 
  • Nor is the garage on Prince Rupert. "Never seen the word garage." 

George Lancaster

  • Rouire says he was never shown results of text messages
  • They did talk about phone records, because there were some calls that Lancaster was asked to verify were his. The pages of the records were held by Rouire and shown to him. Lancaster never even held the pages. 
  • The text messages were not on the records shown to him. 
  • No, the hammer was not seized from the garage on Prince Rupert. 
  • "I wish we would have (seized it). At the time, we knew the cause of death was blunt force trauma … could have been anything in the garage … just like the black plastic coils (Winnipeg Police saw when searching Davis's Jeep months earlier), I wish it had been seized."
  • He knows Cpl. Forester would have seized it if it was deemed an object of interest. "If there was blood on that hammer, it would have been seized."
  • MTS phone records were sought for Brincheski, but the company only keeps them for 90 days. 
  • Brincheski's name was first ever uttered in connection with the investigation on Aug. 14, 2008. 

The taking of Alex Brincheski's statement

  • He went up to Alex in the lobby of D Division, was only a few feet away from him. 
  • Was with him in an interview room for a time. 
  • In 13 years as a cop, he's become familiar with people who are high on marijuana, the indicia of intoxication. 
  • Yes, he "absolutely" looks for such signs when interviewing someone. 
  • "Not at all" was there a smell emanating from Alex. 
  • "Nothing at all" in terms of indicia he was intoxicated.

The plastic sheeting

  • He went online to see if he could locate the "specific plastic" Davis was found wrapped in. 
  • Learned that material was available for purchase in bulk in multiple lengths and widths. 
  • "Black on one side, white on the other."
  • He knows its sometimes called "Malomar," sometimes "poly,"
  • "I call it black and white plastic."
  • He went to a hydroponics store and found "like plastic." Store clerk said he could order it in different thicknesses, but only the 6-mm thickness was available. 

Exhibits in the case

  • "Hundreds and hundreds" of exhibits were seized in the investigation. 
  • He went online to price out the value of a Breitling watch that was seized. It was worth between $6-7,000 online. 
  • Davis's Jeep was unavailable to use for the barrel experiment because it had been written off by then. 
  • Stuart Davis had sold it and the new owner had written it off. 
  • The actual barrel remains a "biohazard" and could not be brought to court. 
  • The barrel "absolutely" would fit in Davis's Jeep. 
  • Phone records weren't obtained by RCMP until early October 2008. 
  • He wasn't aware that Cpl. Forester didn't measure the inside of Davis's Jeep's hatch. The fact there are wheel-well humps doesn't change his view the barrel would fit in there. 
  • "You could also fold the seats down and slide it in lengthways if you wanted to."

The plastic bits

  • He's shown photos of holes drilled in barrel's lid and of the plastic bits. 
  • "The remnants — when you drill a hole — the remnants that fall to the ground."
  • There were experiments in drilling done on a barrel he sourced that was "as close as I could get" to the original.
  • Drill bits were purchased to try and replicated the ones that were seized. 
  • The RCMP used "two sizes up and down" from a 3/8 drill bit to see what they produced. Different speeds and pressures on the drill were also tried. 
  • Paper was used to capture anything that fell to the floor. 
  • The experiments netted remnants "very similar" to what was recovered from the Davis barrel. 
  • "Speed five with a light pressure." 
  • No, he's not an expert in drilling plastics. 

Cross-examination

  • Rouire swears the 810-20** number was checked out by RCMP to see if it belonged to someone. He placed a call to the number on Oct. 16, 2008 and learned the number was "not in service."
  • "It was checked." It was another RCMP officer — a ranking one who fills out search warrants — who had the task. 
  • It's not in the police notes that this task was done. 
  • He agrees Crown evidence can be put into the public domain at bail hearings. 
  • Phone records obtained in Oct. 2008, bail hearings were held in January 2009. 
  • "If you go to court" information can get out, he agrees.
    [At that time, Lancaster and Tymchyshyn's mother were residing together, says defence lawyer Campbell.]
  • Yes, Lancaster said different things to police over the years, some of his statements were inconsistent. 
  • Yes, he and partner went to serve him a subpoena on Nov. 22, 2013 at a bar. 
  • Agrees Lancaster said: "He will tell you what he knows when he's done drinking after the weekend."
  • "That's what he said."
  • In that bar, while he was drinking, Lancaster said "he saw them load him up; that he heard them say 'don't miss;' that he didn't see what happened, but he knows."
  • Rouire confirms that nobody would have known about anything that was in the barrel. 
  • He's confronted with aspects of Alex's statement, how he'd asked Rouire to leave, how at no point does he mention a hat, coiled plastic or specific weights in the barrel. How Alex speculated that the barrel was weighted down by rocks. 
  • "From what I recall he just said 'weighted down.'"
  • When pressed, Alex discloses: "they told me they beat him to death."
  • "I believe he said a hard object … I'm pretty confident that he said it was a hard object."
  • "He also did not say that he was shot, he did not say that he was stabbed."
  • Yes, he agrees phone numbers can change subscribers over time. 
  • Yes, phone records are an important part of the case. 
  • There was a number 218-18** that "popped up a lot" on Davis's records, had called him a number of times on Feb. 6, 2008. 
  • After the "we will be in soon" text (sent from CT's device) at 12:43:55 p.m., There are no more calls from 218-18** on that day. 
  • The next time that number is on Davis's records is Feb. 9, at 4:09 p.m.
  • It's not in the police notes that someone looked into who the 218-18** number belonged to. 
  • "I'm sure somebody did … somebody would have tried to find it."

CROWN CLOSES CASE

 

Fact Check

Fact Check

Have you found an error, or know of something we’ve missed in one of our stories? Please use the form below and let us know.

* Required
  • Please post the headline of the story or the title of the video with the error.

  • Please post exactly what was wrong with the story.

  • Please indicate your source for the correct information.

  • Yes

    No

  • This will only be used to contact you if we have a question about your submission, it will not be used to identify you or be published.

  • Cancel

Having problems with the form?

Contact Us Directly
  • Print

Comments are not accepted on this story because they might prejudice a case before the courts.