13°c Overcast
16°c Cloudy with showers
Winnipeg Free Press - ONLINE EDITION
Bipole III: $11,000 vs $13.68
Here's a partial transcript of what happened Monday night at the legislative building.
It was sent to me by the NDP.
The Selinger government sees itself increasingly under pressure from Hugh McFadyen's Tories on the Bipole III file, and whether the line should be built down the short, and less expensive, east side of Lake Winnipeg instead of the west side of the province.
The NDP is feeling that pressure as we inch closer to the Oct. 4 provincial election.
McFadyen has said if he becomes premier he'll cancel the more expensive west side route for the transmission line and build it down the east side of the province.
McFadyen said Tuesday he stuck by his number.
"Our number is absolutely firm," McFadyen said. "It’s very clear it’s the cost of west side minus cost of east side divided by the number of Manitoba families. It means $11,748 in extra cost for every family in Manitoba going west versus east.
"No matter how desperate the NDP gets going into committee meetings or elections, no matter how much they want to resort to their ‘Crocus’ calculator, it doesn’t change the fact that every family pays $11,748 more."
Here's what the NDP sent me. Here is the full transcript.
The exchange below is between NDP Minister of Labour Jennifer Howard and Manitoba Hydro president Bob Brennan:
Standing Committee on Crown Corporations (Manitoba Hydro)
May 30, 2011
Partial transcript
Minister Howard: (speaking of the PC hydro mailer, that is designed to look like a Hydro bill)
It says that people’s Hydro bills, of the average Manitoba family, are going to go up more than $11,000. I want you to take a look at that. Now I see your logo on that piece of advertising and I know it’s a claim that’s been repeated by Members of the Opposition. I find it to be a very misleading claim. But I wonder if you can tell us if the use of the Manitoba Hydro logo was authorized for that document.
Mr. Brennan:
It was not authorized.
Minister Howard:
Thank you very much, thank you very much for that. Now I did a little math with that number. I did take a lot of math in school, no electrical engineering, but a fair bit of math. So when I multiply that number by the number of families that the chief statistician tell us exist in Manitoba, I get a total amount of $3.8 billion. Now I’ve looked at the presentation you made. The total cost estimate of the bipole is $3.2 billion. So this advertising seems to suggest a total that’s more than the cost, the estimated cost you told us was for the bipole. Would that be accurate? Does your math match up with my math on that or am I off?
Mr. Brennan:
First of all, I got tons of these mailed to me as well (inaudible) probably approaching 50 or so. And then I got quite a few phone calls as well.
I assumed that the amount, I had a hard time with the arithmetic myself. I assumed it was talking about the incremental cost of going one route vs. the other, that’s what I assumed it was. So I went through my own calculations and I seemed to get quite a bit of a different number. I took the distance in the length, made some notes… yeah, I took the difference in length between the two routes. I took the total transmission cost, calculated the cost per kilometre, which really works out to quite an expensive amount I think it was $940,000 a kilometre, and applied that to the incremental length and got a number of $428 million, I did not include what Mr. McFadyen was talking about, increases losses that occur, I excluded that. But that, it wouldn’t double this number, that’s for sure, it would be even less than that.
So then I took the number of households, escalated up to 2017. And that number’s less than the current number of customers, and I took the incremental cost per household (inaudible…)
That number came out to $821 per household.
And then I said, well, that’s over the life of the line so I divided that by 60. And so the annual cost would be $13.68.
Then I figured, well, if we’re talking households, households only use a third of the total amount power that’s used in our system.
So I thought that number should be divided by a third but I didn’t go that far.
Minister Howard:
Thank you very much. You did a lot more math than I did on that.
So by your calculation, $13, and it could be lower than that. That’s seems less than $11,478. Do you think by that math, the numbers contained in this partisan mailing are entirely inaccurate and misleading. Would you characterize it that way?
Mr. Brennan:
It’s definitely a different number.
More Under the Dome
- Back to Top
- Return to Under the Dome
More Under the Dome
(1 of 12 articles for this year)
Closure and Bill 20 — who’ll blink first?
05/9/2013 1:43 AM 0One of the more clever moves Opposition Progressive Conservative Leader Brian Pallister has made is making Steinbach Tory MLA Kevin ...
About Larry Kusch and Bruce Owen
Larry Kusch has been a journalist for 30 years, the last 20 with the Winnipeg Free Press. His is one of the newspaper's two legislative bureau reporters.
Raised on a Saskatchewan farm, he received an honours journalism degree from Carleton University in 1975.
At the Free Press, Larry has also worked as a general assignment reporter, business reporter, copy editor and assistant city editor.
Bruce Owen joined the Winnipeg Free Press in 1990 after four years working in other media.
He's worked in a number of positions at the Freep, including pet columnist, assistant city editor and police reporter. Right now he takes up space at the Manitoba legislature.
Bruce is one of five reporters who won a National Newspaper Award for the paper’s coverage of the 1997 Flood of the Century. He's also the recipient of the 1996 Volunteer Centre of Winnipeg Media Golden Hand Award and the 1995 Canadian Federation of Humane Societies Media Commendation Award.
In a past life Bruce worked at YMCA-YWCA Camp Stephens. He has a blog where he and others write about camp and the people who worked and played there.
You can also find Bruce on Twitter where he posts and retweets all sorts of stuff.
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.