November 30, 2015


-6° C, Clear

Full Forecast


Katz's scandals are less scandalous

Our mayor is better off than Harper or Ford

By any stretch of the imagination, the past 18 months have been a terrible, horrible, no good, very bad time for Mayor Sam Katz.

In the spring of 2012, Winnipeg's once-all-powerful mayor was forced to watch helplessly as his long-held dream of spending $7 million in public funds on a private water park died thanks to a suddenly rebellious city council.

Mayor Sam Katz

Mayor Sam Katz

City of Toronto Mayor Rob Ford


City of Toronto Mayor Rob Ford

Prime Minister Stephen Harper


Prime Minister Stephen Harper

In the fall of that year, he tried -- and failed -- to contain the damage from a fire-paramedic-station construction scandal that spawned two separate external audits.

That same fall, Katz appeared embarrassed by public reports of his decision to buy an Arizona shell company from city chief administrative officer Phil Sheegl, swap it back several weeks later and also acquire an Arizona home from the sister-in-law of a prominent Winnipeg developer.

Last April, he suffered the indignity of hearing a Manitoba judge declare he exhibited "bad political and ethical behaviour" even as she cleared him of violating conflict-of-interest rules.

In October, he was forced to allow his friend and confidante Sheegl to resign from his position days before the release of an audit that deemed Sheegl responsible for the fire-paramedic station scandal.

And on the first day of November, Katz was forced to eat words he uttered only two years ago, when he assured residents of this city they will not pay another penny for an over-budget police headquarters.

"Any cost overruns now are the responsibility of those who are building it, not you or me or any other taxpayer," Katz said in 2011, when the city negotiated a "guaranteed maximum price" that was neither guaranteed, nor maximum.

City taxpayers will foot the bill for another $17 million of spending on the police headquarters. A project that started as a $19-million facelift for a 49-year-old police building is now a $211-million behemoth involving the acquisition and renovation of a 58-year-old former federal warehouse.

There are calls in some circles for Katz to resign. Two left-of-centre councillors have made this call, though that opinion isn't shared by others on council. One of my colleagues at another media outlet has issued this opinion in a column. And there's no doubt some Winnipeggers feel the same way.

But if you're Mayor Sam Katz, why would you resign?

Sure, you've lost control of council to the point where it isn't clear whether anyone wants to fill two empty seats on the powerful executive policy committee.

Yes, your credibility has taken a hit by claiming one week you have no idea why Sheegl resigned and insisting the next it had nothing to do with the police headquarters cost overruns.

Obviously, it isn't any fun being Mayor Sam Katz right now. But if you're Katz, you can look to the east and breathe a sigh of relief.

In Ottawa, no less a political giant than Prime Minister Stephen Harper is struggling terribly beneath the weight of a Senate expenses scandal. If Sen. Mike Duffy is telling the truth about the payments from former PMO chief of staff Nigel Wright, then Harper has lied to Canadians.

Now that would be a reason to resign.

In Toronto, the apparently irredeemable Mayor Rob Ford has been captured by police surveillance in the company of a reputed drug dealer, urinating in public and discarding empty liquor bottles.

And oh yeah, the police are in possession of a videotape that allegedly shows Ford smoking crack.

Hanging out with drug dealers and lying about it for months is one heck of a reason for a mayor to resign.

Katz may be criticized harshly, fairly and repeatedly for some of the decisions he's made as Winnipeg's mayor. But the bar is set too low in Canada right now to motivate him to go.

This mayor does not smoke crack. He doesn't even consume alcohol. Katz has also been careful to avoid answering questions rather than lie to reporters. He has not been led from his office in handcuffs like some of his counterparts in Quebec.

Does this make him the greatest mayor ever?

Of course not.

But as much as his critics don't want to hear it, simply making a series of dubious decisions does not compel the guy to hand over the chain of office.

Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition November 2, 2013 A5

You can comment on most stories on You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.

Have Your Say

New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.

Have Your Say

Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscribers only. why?

Have Your Say

Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press Subscribers only. why?

The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective January 2015.

Scroll down to load more