Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 12/4/2013 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
Take a drive around the outskirts of the City of Winnipeg right now and the need for an expanded Unicity may just smack you in face.
On the edge of North Kildonan, the city is planning to barricade roads leading into East St. Paul to dissuade a Toronto developer from building a Walmart just outside the city's boundaries.
On the edge of Transcona, a residential-property developer hoping to build affordable housing has wound up in conflict with heavy industry across the border with the RM of Springfield.
On the edge of Richardson International Airport, the nascent CentrePort industrial development is struggling to secure servicing because the RM of Rosser falls outside a century-old deal governing the use of water from Shoal Lake.
And in every Winnipeg bedroom community, ex-urban residents are stewing as a result of a city decision to prioritize city dwellers over suburbanites when it comes to signing up for recreation services such as swimming lessons.
All of these headaches -- and potentially many more -- might just disappear if the City of Winnipeg did something it has not done for more than four decades: Swallow up some of its neighbours, either in whole or in part.
In 1972, Winnipeg merged with 13 of its suburbs as part of an effort to reduce the bureaucracy associated with what was then a two-tier system of municipal government. Before Unicity, residents of the old inner city and its neighbouring municipalities were governed by their own councils as well as a regional metropolitan government.
The amalgamation, which predated similar efforts in Ottawa, Toronto and Montreal by nearly three decades, was supposed to make municipal government more efficient as well as end an annoying situation where residents of lightly taxed suburbs were consuming city services without paying for them.
Unfortunately, the expanded City of Winnipeg did not live happily ever after. Even after 510 Main St. gained control over the vast majority of the Winnipeg metropolitan area -- the area where more than half the workforce commutes to the city every day -- outlying areas of the early megacity continued to develop at the expense of the inner city.
Today, the city continues to contain the vast majority of its metropolitan population: 714,000 people live inside the City of Winnipeg, while only another 75,000 people reside in the 11 municipalities that make up the Winnipeg Census Metropolitan Area.
Nonetheless, residential, industrial and commercial growth in some of those municipalities -- particularly the St. Pauls, Rosser, Springfield and Headingley, the latter of which seceded from the city in 1993 -- is taking place without any apparent co-ordination with the city itself.
In theory, Winnipeg and its neighbours are supposed to hash out their differences through an entity known as the Manitoba Capital Region. But this weak stab at a regional government has proven utterly useless.
The city will only be able to control its fate if it controls more land. And that means swallowing up entire portions of its neighbours, not just within the Winnipeg CMA, but also just outside of it in the RMs of Rockwood, Cartier and St. Andrews.
Why go so far? If you look at the expanded City of Ottawa, you'll see the nation's relatively well-planned capital controls vast areas of agricultural and natural land well outside its former borders.
Ottawa was allowed to swallow up so much land in an effort to co-ordinate regional transportation, servicing and land-use plans without having to negotiate the messy business of intergovernmental relations.
While it might seem weird to find formerly independent Ontario towns such as Stittsville and Manotick within Ottawa's city limits, there's no doubt 110 Laurier Ave. -- Ottawa's city hall -- has been empowered to control its destiny.
In Winnipeg, the city has never quite managed to fulfil the Unicity promise. But North American city planning is a lot more advanced in 2013 than it was in 1972, thanks to lessons learned across the continent. If Winnipeg does not expand, at least to absorb adjacent neighbourhoods within the existing urban agglomeration, the city is destined to fight endless battles with its neighbours.
Such a move will not be popular on Broadway or in any of the city's bedroom communities, where many property owners pay artificially low municipal taxes. But that's just too freaking bad. Winnipeg's next leader must be brave enough to grapple with the annexation question, which is coming whether Broadway cares to admit it or not.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition December 4, 2013 B1
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
A time to reflect on all our blessings
NDP in tough spot for 2015 election
Ensure emotions can handle play date
Two stand out against all other candidates
A doggone happy reunification
Exit a body blow for Selinger
Talkin' 'bout a revolutionary
Earl Grey squares
#Decolonize2014: Boundary-defying exhibitions by indigenous artists help define art in Winnipeg this year
A mommy not required to stick up for husband
Persian, Somali food in short supply in Winnipeg, so this duo is a great discovery
City, Shindico still at odds over expropriation
Time to deal yourself in, Chevy
Return to Dog River so much fun you could spit
Generosity doesn't solve poverty
Hush-hush bar fight leads to fidelity concerns
A pooch's present
Time to deal yourself in, Chevy
Daughter makes her mom proud
Dad feeling dumb after being caught smoking pot
Tolkiening it to the next level
Brace for return of Bellefeuille, Etcheverry
Scandinavian-style spa steaming up Fort Garry
Eggnog Sandwich Cookies
The buddy system can be complicated thing
First fashion boutique on Waterfront
Chronic condition and obesity inspire local woman to join reality show about bodybuilders
Marry who you want, don't invite co-workers
Hutchinson deserves more
Whatever happened to Joe Kapone?
Did he die in vain?
Many queries, few answers in police-HQ probe
Your weekend weather
Watch out for overheated canola, farmers warned
Politicians shouldn't finance reporters
It's all about helping good people