15°c Clear
28°c Isolated showers
Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
No place for politics as ridings change
OTTAWA -- There was a whole lot of shouting last week over whether there is something nefarious at play in the redistribution of Saskatchewan's 14 federal ridings.
The opposition smelled blood after the Conservatives had to admit the party was behind a robocall aimed at rousing public anger against proposed changes to Saskatchewan's ridings. The party's spokesman, Fred Delorey, and Saskatchewan MP Tom Lukiwski, denied the party was behind the calls, which claimed the changes betrayed "Saskatchewan values."
After an investigation by the Ottawa Citizen matched the voice on the call to the owner of the Edmonton robocall company used mainly by the Conservatives, Delorey admitted the call came from them. He blamed an "internal miscommunication" for the fact the calls weren't identified as coming from the Conservative party. That violates Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission rules requiring all calls to identify the source.
So, now we have the opposition yelling that the party broke CRTC rules and is trying to gerrymander Saskatchewan all at the same time.
On the first count, it appears the party did break the rules. Liberal Frank Valeriote's Guelph riding association was fined $4,900 by the CRTC last year for not identifying itself as the source of a robocall during the 2011 federal election. Conservative MPs have crowed about it for months. (Pot, meet kettle?)
But what about the other accusation? Is a push poll by a political party evidence of gerrymandering?
At worst, it's likely this poll was in bad taste, as it appeared to question the ethics or impartiality of the independent three-member commission in Saskatchewan that's making the decision about the riding boundaries.
The root of the issue is eight of the 14 ridings in Saskatchewan are known as "rurban" ridings, a mix of rural and urban areas. The riding redistribution commission in Saskatchewan last year announced plans to rejig the ridings to have five ridings that will be almost entirely urban. The idea is that city folk have more in common with other city folk and rural folk with rural folk.
But there is also a political fight at play because the existing ridings see the NDP's more urban vote split between ridings. Despite earning one in three votes in Saskatchewan in 2011, the NDP didn't win a single seat, and finished second in 13 of them.
The Conservatives' knickers are in a knot about the changes mainly because they could lose several seats in the next election, although their public argument is the changes will pit rural and urban voters against each other.
So the question may be, is it gerrymandering in favour of the NDP to change the ridings or are the Tories attempting to gerrymander to keep Saskatchewan ridings easier to win?
At the end of the day, Canadians and Saskatchewan residents have to trust the commission will make its decision based on what's right for voters, not for any of the political parties.
In each province, a three-member commission is appointed to do the redistribution. The commission is made up of a provincial judge appointed by the chief justice in each province, and two members chosen by the Speaker of the House of Commons. In this case, that is Conservative MP Andrew Scheer, but his choices were not partisan. In Manitoba, he chose two political science professors.
They listened to submissions from the public and MPs -- including some who seemed intent on changing ridings to favour one party or another. Three Conservative MPs wanted to redraw Elmwood-Transcona to remove the NDP-leaning Elmwood and replace it with more Conservative-friendly rural areas to the east.
But there were also presentations made by other party supporters seeking to prevent the more Conservative-friendly Lindenwoods from being added to Winnipeg South Centre, which will make the riding harder for the Liberals to win back.
The commission rejected both ideas.
A push poll may be questionable and for the Conservatives to deny involvement is sketchy. But at the end of the day, it is still a non-partisan committee making the new maps.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition February 11, 2013 A7
More Columnists
- Back to Top
- Return to Columnists
More Columnists
(1 of 5 articles for today)
My arm tattoo has me thinking
1:00 AM 0I have a swell new tattoo on my right arm.
Prepare to be extremely jealous, because it artfully depicts a pink ...
Poll
Most Popular Columnists
- Bible Belt's bogeyman still haunts town
- At 55, I'm wise to what's real in life
- Blue offence must make teams pay for blitzing Buck
- Mack, Burke give each other room to do their jobs
- Mau Maus win 50-year-long battle
- Boyfriend's right; you should wait
- Nepinak's leadership gathering steam
- Bigger Byfuglien in no shape for a trade
- Bark in the park more than a lark
- 'Nice' guy taking sex partners for granted
- Fiasco fixers
- Bible Belt's bogeyman still haunts town
- Nice new digs, but Buchko has work to do
- What a knockout!
- Nepinak's leadership gathering steam
- 'Nice' guy taking sex partners for granted
- Discovering your wife's kinky behaviour isn't an invitation to join the party
- Your new 'friends' have unlocked a mystery
- Offensive linemen move faster than buses
- UFC 161 a smash success
- When the Ford jokes stop
- Ground control to Major Chris
- Burmistrov wants out of Winnipeg
- Bigger Byfuglien in no shape for a trade
- Immobilizer program too cosy, some charge
- A new mom's booze-fuelled hell
- Fiasco fixers
- Downtown's parking facilities tell story of city's development
- Katz bogeys again
- Bible Belt's bogeyman still haunts town
- Bible Belt's bogeyman still haunts town
- At 55, I'm wise to what's real in life
- Mau Maus win 50-year-long battle
- Bible Belt's bogeyman still haunts town
- At 55, I'm wise to what's real in life
- Mau Maus win 50-year-long battle
- Take a walk in the park to fight prostate cancer
- Psychics pull off a little magic
- Fiasco fixers
- Nepinak's leadership gathering steam
- Downtown's parking facilities tell story of city's development
- Offensive linemen move faster than buses
- Helping others despite the cost
- Downtown's parking facilities tell story of city's development
- When the Ford jokes stop
- Bible Belt's bogeyman still haunts town
- St. Norbert sees condo boom
- Immobilizer program too cosy, some charge
- Changes to CPP rules worth looking into
- Lessons learned in 4-H last a lifetime
- At 55, I'm wise to what's real in life
- A new mom's booze-fuelled hell
- Ground control to Major Chris
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
Have Your Say
Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscribers only. why?
Login SubscribeHave Your Say
Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press Subscribers only. why?
SubscribeThe Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.