Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 07/5/2014 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
Five years ago, rookie River Heights-Fort Garry Coun. John Orlikow was greener than a July tomato when he was handed a nightmare of a proposal for his ward.
On July 13 of that year, Winnipeg suddenly faced a proposal to swap one of the largest parcels of undeveloped city-owned land for a smaller chunk of land belonging to developer Andrew Marquess.
The plan called for the city to give up 24 hectares of unserviced city land in the Parker neighbourhood of Fort Garry. In exchange, the city would receive 3.6 hectares of serviced land near Winnipeg Transit's Osborne Street headquarters.
A report that initially went before a closed-door session of council's property committee said both pieces of land were assessed at $1 million.
The exchange would give the city room to expand a Winnipeg Transit garage, while Marquess could proceed with a plan to transform the Parker neighbourhood into a residential district and build 3,500 townhouses.
When these details were made public, on July 15, 2009, residents near the Parker lands flipped out. Some were angry at the proposed elimination of a patch of semi-forested prairie that includes a dog park. Others were frightened by the proposed extension of the Sterling Lyon Parkway. Mostly, they were outraged the idea was put before city council in only nine days after its sudden appearance.
Orlikow, who was elected the previous March, struggled to comprehend what was happening. The rookie councillor learned about the plan by reading the Free Press.
Faced with angry voters, he put together a town hall at Victoria Community Centre, where his constituents told him flatly to do anything to prevent the swap from passing.
On July 22, council approved the transaction by a 10-6 margin. Orlikow voted against it, as did Transcona Coun. Russ Wyatt, who wasn't buying whatever senior city officials were trying to sell.
"The fact that this is being rammed through here at 8:30 on a Wednesday in the middle of July is a bunch of garbage," Wyatt seethed.
Orlikow was reduced to meekly complaining that as the new guy, he shouldn't have to play the role of political eunuch.
Now, five years after the fact, the real estate audit reveals Orlikow and his constituents weren't just acting like a bunch of whining NIMBYs.
Auditor EY found the city didn't inspect the properties in question, didn't conduct proper assessments, and didn't even provide a rationale for swapping the properties.
Even worse, the auditors found city appraisers complained their $1-million assessments amounted to a back-of-the-napkin "rush job" that were intended only for internal purposes.
The city appraisers complained time restraints made it unreasonable to assess the two pieces of land.
Most disturbingly, the auditors also found the value of the Parker land to be "significantly greater" two years after the exchange. They ultimately suggested it was highly problematic to part with this city property without issuing a tender.
Orlikow, however, doesn't feel vindicated by the audit conclusions.
"There's lots of 'I told you sos' in this thing, but I'm not sure that helps," he said Friday. "There's no reason why the land swap wasn't evaluated and why it was rushed through."
Marquess told the Free Press he played no part in the city decision. While the auditors essentially concluded he wound up with a sweet deal, he said it was tough for him to comment on city processes. "It's been five years. I've moved on from that," he said.
In response to the auditor's comments about the increased value of the Parker land, city officials noted this area had yet to be contemplated for the second phase of the Southwest Transitway. This is beyond belief, considering what appears on page 8 of the report recommending the Parker land swap to council in 2009: A diagram of a "proposed bus rapid transit" line running one block north of Parker Avenue.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition July 5, 2014 A8
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Frolik controls his future with one-year deal
Idiotic shark-storm TV movie takes a big, hilarious, deliciously entertaining bite out of the Big Apple
Seafood riches: Cádiz markets, restaurants blessed with diversity of marine delicacies
Breaking up (the cabin) is hard to do
Flood swamps ability to be fierce deficit-slayer
Sad story of an underpass and a home lost
Bombers without borders
Minority Christian Arabs are on the move
Let the last two years go, fans; Bombers have
Don't let your lust scare off 'nice guy'
Fringe candidates get attention they deserve
World-class 'Elvis' to star at tribute festival in Gimli
Massage therapist on call to help ease labour pains, support birthing mothers
Prize will help guitarist launch career
Careful, don't shut large families out of wedding
City dangerous by design
Tell MD your husband is not taking meds
Red River Settler took the high ground
Fargo embraces Canadian winter
From recycling to riches
Strengthening Abbas offers best hope for peace
Your weekend weather
Lack of genetic diversity threat to livestock
An uncomfortable silence
Trending that caught Doug's eye: Famous babies
Demigod or not, Herc's got the goods
Art film chugs into your living room
Mosquito net can solve problem of biting remarks
Muslims share fears of extremism
More booze isn't always a good thing
How the seven mayoral candidates stack up so far
When it comes to getting a few laughs, I've got the scoop
Walters needs to keep his eyes on the prize
Joke's on those who thought referendum law had teeth
Hockey Manitoba still doesn't get the message
Time to turf police turf war
Tell the gossips you'll take them on
Follow the script