Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 01/29/2014 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
Mr. Stephens was born in 1914, and while he had very little education, he had four lovely children. He worked as a millwright and was predeceased by his wife. At age 80, he fell under the sway of a man who he formerly worked with.
He was diagnosed with Parkinson's disease, and later with Alzheimer's disease. His mental capacity was slipping when the former co-worker pounced. The co-worker offered to help Mr. Stephens, and the two moved in together.
The co-worker gradually isolated Mr. Stephens from his children. He helped with all of the banking. He took care of Mr. Stephens' physical needs and drove him to appointments after he lost his licence. He began to take advantage of Mr. Stephens. He was given a bank card and started to draw money out of Mr. Stephens' account. An agreement was signed to renovate the co-worker's house with Mr. Stephens' money. Large gifts were made.
At the end of the day, when Mr. Stephens passed away, his co-worker had taken more than $400,000. The children, as beneficiaries of the estate, were furious. They sued.
The judge who heard the case described the co-worker's conduct as "shameless." The deceased Mr. Stephens had been vulnerable because of his medical conditions.
Because the co-worker offered to help and Mr. Stephens accepted the help, the judge said a special duty of fairness was placed on the co-worker's shoulders. That duty made it impossible for the co-worker to accept gifts unless Mr. Stephens had independent legal advice. That advice was not received. Mr. Stephens also had to truly know what he was doing if any of the gifts were to stand. He did not.
The judge ordered the co-worker to repay all of the money to the estate. He also had to pay interest. Even more, he had to pay punitive damages of $25,000. Punitive damages are ordered when the court wants to send a message to the community and punish a person for antisocial behaviour.
The law the judge was able to apply is from England in the early 1800s. Judges held people to a certain moral standard in that era. If you step forward to help someone, you are expected to act selflessly. The person receiving the help is entitled to relax and not worry about their wallet being stolen.
The facts in this story are true. They are taken from the published decision of the court that heard the case in 1998. The family name has been changed.
Modern courts are more than willing to apply the principle developed nearly two centuries ago. What was shameless then remains shameless now.
There is nothing wrong with being helpful. Merely driving your neighbour to the store or shovelling their walk does not trigger the special duty. There is a point, however, where you become so helpful that the special duties begin to apply.
John E. S. Poyser is a Winnipeg lawyer with Tradition Law LLP estates & trusts. Contact him at 204-947-6801 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition January 29, 2014 B6
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Get a bit goofy in bed and see how he likes it
We're building a better experience
Candid Carlyle wants back in
Bringing the issue of trust into focus
No peace for Tina's mom
I fenced with a fence and lived to tell about it
Going whole hog: Harley dealership owner has collection of 20 vintage bikes
Selinger playing favourites?
When grain's gone, what to do with the bags?
Klopp taking his cool out of Dortmund
Irish comic heralds impotence (if it happens to come to that)
Partner's touches and affection shouldn't creep you out
The underdog won't back down
Turning the page: Recently divorced mother braces for impact of new financial situation
What's with Roger's moustache?
What summer students need
Radio personality was a voice for wine
Hawks goalie could be next no-name star
Time to get tougher, Buff
Jets couldn't silence Ducks' big guns
Death of the Canadian Wheat Board
Commune marriage still counts, even if not legal
Being short on cash is a tall order
Group envisions mountain-biking hub in Riding Mountain National Park
It will work in Winnipeg: Chipman and Co. set to contend for a long time
Stanley Cup fever taking new forms
Don't underestimate Winnipeg's Mr. Big
Police chief needs to release report on cancelled 911 call if he wants public's trust
Tantalizing rash of rasher stories
An unusual path to press box at the Pond
Sci-fi series Orphan Black is upping its game as it returns for a third season
Destiny's child: Comedy is in Shawn Wayans' DNA
Blue-collar premium: University degrees are nice, but they don't fix the leaky faucet
Getting bugged out by glasses in bed
Cafe Dario's prix fixe dinner offers sophisticated cooking with Latin twists
Too much at stake in Chipman-Bowman impasse
The Maurice factor
Big laughs, big numbers for annual comedy-palooza