19°c Clear
18°c Cloudy periods
Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Why so serious?
Fans respond to negative Batman reviews with death threats to critics
No laughing matter: Christian Bale puts the dark in the Dark Knight.
Back in 2008, The Dark Knight seemed to be setting a new level for comic-book adaptations. The movie did blockbuster box office while garnering good reviews -- and gaining a posthumous Oscar for Heath Ledger's scary, anarchic Joker.
Now The Dark Knight Rises is being billed as the triumphant culmination of director Christopher Nolan's deep, dark trilogy. It's also fuelling a climactic firestorm of fanboy fury against anybody who doesn't see it this way. Viewing DKR as one helluva summer movie is no longer enough. It's got to be The Iliad and The Book of Job and Das Kapital and Nietzsche all rolled into one.
The first DKR reviews that popped up on Rotten Tomatoes were very strong. Then poor Marshall Fine, an L.A.-based career critic, ventured to say that the film was perhaps a bit ponderous. Holding this negative line all by himself, he got pasted. Rampaging Bat-fans crashed his server, and RT removed the review at his request but kept his rating as part of the movie's aggregate score.
Many comments on Fine's review included line-by-line refutations, despite the fact that the film had not yet opened for general viewing. (There's nothing like that tone of crystalline certainty seen in the no-movie-viewing-necessary school of criticism.) The RT people were kept hopping, policing hateful and obscene comments. Once The Associated Press's Christy Lemire sent in her mixed review, they had to watch out for misogynistic comments as well, since she's, like, a girl.
And then there were the death threats.
At this point, Rotten Tomato's editor-in-chief, Matt Atchity, brought in a sense of perspective -- and a much-needed a sense of humour -- in an open letter titled "This Is Why We Can't Have Nice Things." He explained that RT had made the unprecedented decision to temporarily disable the user-comment option. "There are plenty of other things to get angry about," Atchity offered helpfully. "Like war, famine, poverty and crime. But not movie reviews."
Rotten Tomatoes pitches a big tent. That's the whole point of an aggregate site. It doesn't present one critic as a final authority but offers a range of views, making room for loads of professional critics and passionate fans. This openness is supposed to generate discussion. Not death threats.
So, yeah, maybe DKR auteur Nolan is a genius. Or maybe he's a huge no-fun-nik. Maybe DKR is an epic saga. Or a maybe it's a bloated 164-minute gloom fest. Maybe Nolan is making important statements about humanity. Or maybe his icy, cerebral approach makes little room for, you know, actual humanity. Maybe the movie brings New York City grit and realism to comic-book archetypes. Or maybe it's just a Law & Order episode that happens to include a masked super-villain and lots of intense whispering. Maybe DKR's vision of class war, with nothing between corrupt oligarchy and bloody mob rule, is morally and politically complex. Or maybe it's just confused.
Ferocious fanboys seem intent on shutting this conversation down, probably because Batman -- or, as everyone in the movie keeps saying, "The Batman" -- is the comic-book lover's Great Black Hope for gravitas. That dancing Spider-Man and those in-joking Avengers aren't going to do it. The Dark Knight trilogy is fandom's best crack at cinematic weight and cultural prestige.
But -- to quote that lightweight Spider-Man franchise -- with great power comes great responsibility. If DKR is that serious, it should be able to hold up to serious discussion.
alison.gillmor@freepress.mb.ca
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition July 21, 2012 E3
More Columnists
- Back to Top
- Return to Columnists
More Columnists
(1 of 50 articles for this week)
At 55, I'm wise to what's real in life
06/18/2013 1:00 AM 0I turn 55 this week.
I'd never considered the possibility of the palindrome or, if I had, I attached the word ...
Poll
Most Popular Columnists
- Bible Belt's bogeyman still haunts town
- At 55, I'm wise to what's real in life
- Blue offence must make teams pay for blitzing Buck
- Mack, Burke give each other room to do their jobs
- Mau Maus win 50-year-long battle
- Boyfriend's right; you should wait
- Nepinak's leadership gathering steam
- Bigger Byfuglien in no shape for a trade
- Bark in the park more than a lark
- 'Nice' guy taking sex partners for granted
- Fiasco fixers
- Bible Belt's bogeyman still haunts town
- Nice new digs, but Buchko has work to do
- What a knockout!
- Nepinak's leadership gathering steam
- 'Nice' guy taking sex partners for granted
- Your new 'friends' have unlocked a mystery
- Discovering your wife's kinky behaviour isn't an invitation to join the party
- Offensive linemen move faster than buses
- Bigger Byfuglien in no shape for a trade
- When the Ford jokes stop
- Ground control to Major Chris
- Burmistrov wants out of Winnipeg
- Bigger Byfuglien in no shape for a trade
- Immobilizer program too cosy, some charge
- A new mom's booze-fuelled hell
- Fiasco fixers
- Downtown's parking facilities tell story of city's development
- Katz bogeys again
- Bible Belt's bogeyman still haunts town
- Bible Belt's bogeyman still haunts town
- At 55, I'm wise to what's real in life
- Mau Maus win 50-year-long battle
- Bible Belt's bogeyman still haunts town
- At 55, I'm wise to what's real in life
- Mau Maus win 50-year-long battle
- Take a walk in the park to fight prostate cancer
- Psychics pull off a little magic
- Fiasco fixers
- Nepinak's leadership gathering steam
- Downtown's parking facilities tell story of city's development
- Offensive linemen move faster than buses
- Helping others despite the cost
- Downtown's parking facilities tell story of city's development
- When the Ford jokes stop
- Bible Belt's bogeyman still haunts town
- St. Norbert sees condo boom
- Immobilizer program too cosy, some charge
- Changes to CPP rules worth looking into
- Lessons learned in 4-H last a lifetime
- At 55, I'm wise to what's real in life
- A new mom's booze-fuelled hell
- Ground control to Major Chris
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
Have Your Say
Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press print or e-edition subscribers only. why?
Login SubscribeHave Your Say
Comments are open to Winnipeg Free Press Subscribers only. why?
SubscribeThe Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.