Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Posted: 04/7/2014 1:00 AM | Comments: 0
Last Modified: 04/7/2014 6:29 AM | Updates
It would be easy to conclude our beloved national game is broken.
Throughout the season, we've heard nothing but stories of violence, abuse and dysfunction.
On-ice riots in which referees were assaulted. Allegations of racism. Fisticuffs between adults in front of eight-year-old players. It all culminated with a decision by Hockey Winnipeg to ban one couple from all hockey-related activities for three years.
And yet, the stars may be aligning to create a rare opportunity to make a positive out of this negative season.
Through a combination of investment returns and revenue windfalls, Hockey Winnipeg has found itself sitting on a surplus of nearly $1 million. Hockey Winnipeg president Don McIntosh said about half of that money should be expended in some way. "We're a non-profit and it's not good policy for us to be sitting on a fund of that size," he said.
For the time being, an internal committee is studying possible uses for the funds, including a rebate to area associations, McIntosh said.
It would be hard to understate the importance of HW's decision. This money could do a lot of good in hockey, but only if there is a commitment to using it in an impactful way. Unfortunately, returning it to area associations is not the best way of doing that.
Area associations do excellent work. In fact, they do all of the heavy lifting, from registration to ordering jerseys and overseeing tryouts and team formation. Area-association volunteers are the unsung heroes of the game, overworked and underappreciated.
However, area associations should not manage cash windfalls. They are service organizations, with limited oversight and accountability.
Very few area associations post their constitutions, board-meeting minutes or annual reports online. That is not to suggest there is anything untoward. Only that it's not a good idea to drop a pile of cash on them.
But what else could the money be used for? Hockey Winnipeg could make a real impact on the game if it focused the money on areas of greatest need -- things that could create lasting, positive change.
To that end, here are several suggestions that I have collected from fellow coaches, conveners and officials over the past season.
Hockey Winnipeg is currently deluged with smartphone videos from parents or teams complaining about some on-ice incident. However, HW also has a policy not to use submitted video as evidence in disciplinary matters because it cannot guarantee authenticity.
But what if HW had its own video? Cameras in rinks could create independent evidence of any incident on or off the ice. It's also possible that the mere presence of the cameras could have a calming effect on the game.
Under the terms of Hockey Canada's National Coach Certification Program, adults need only obtain Coach Level to manage the bench at all ages and most levels of community and recreational hockey. Once obtained (by attending a one-day clinic), you never have to recertify or be assessed. Ever.
HW would do well to hire top-level mentors to provide regular, mandatory assessment for all coaches, regardless of experience. This would be an opportunity to improve coaches' knowledge of the rules, fair-play policies, practice plans and bench management.
Unlike coaches, referees must recertify each season. However, those clinics are brief, casual and focused mostly on new rule changes. After that, most referees get absolutely no oversight or assessment in a game situation.
Some area associations have hired senior officials to mentor younger officials, with great success. However, there is clear need for a city-wide mentoring program to support and improve the quality of officiating. This would allow HW to pay senior officials to be at the rink, assessing and instructing younger officials in game conditions.
Existing governing bodies do a good job policing players and team officials on the ice. However, off the ice, recent headlines have shown things get ambiguous and complex pretty quickly.
Perhaps it's time to establish a hockey ombudsperson to look at the myriad personal and political issues, including conflicts involving parents, spectators and area associations. The ombudsperson would be a truly objective voice in the game, free of all fear and favour with a central focus on making the game fairer and safer.
A half-million-dollar windfall is pretty rare. Regardless of how they decide to expend it, hockey's guardians must focus on one prevailing question: Did we use it to make the game better?
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition April 7, 2014 A4
Updated on Monday, April 7, 2014 at 6:29 AM CDT: Replaces photos
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
Get a bit goofy in bed and see how he likes it
We're building a better experience
Candid Carlyle wants back in
Bringing the issue of trust into focus
No peace for Tina's mom
I fenced with a fence and lived to tell about it
Going whole hog: Harley dealership owner has collection of 20 vintage bikes
Selinger playing favourites?
When grain's gone, what to do with the bags?
Klopp taking his cool out of Dortmund
Irish comic heralds impotence (if it happens to come to that)
Partner's touches and affection shouldn't creep you out
The underdog won't back down
Turning the page: Recently divorced mother braces for impact of new financial situation
What's with Roger's moustache?
What summer students need
Radio personality was a voice for wine
Hawks goalie could be next no-name star
Time to get tougher, Buff
Jets couldn't silence Ducks' big guns
Death of the Canadian Wheat Board
Commune marriage still counts, even if not legal
Being short on cash is a tall order
Group envisions mountain-biking hub in Riding Mountain National Park
It will work in Winnipeg: Chipman and Co. set to contend for a long time
Stanley Cup fever taking new forms
Don't underestimate Winnipeg's Mr. Big
Police chief needs to release report on cancelled 911 call if he wants public's trust
Tantalizing rash of rasher stories
An unusual path to press box at the Pond
Sci-fi series Orphan Black is upping its game as it returns for a third season
Destiny's child: Comedy is in Shawn Wayans' DNA
Blue-collar premium: University degrees are nice, but they don't fix the leaky faucet
Getting bugged out by glasses in bed
Cafe Dario's prix fixe dinner offers sophisticated cooking with Latin twists
Too much at stake in Chipman-Bowman impasse
The Maurice factor
Big laughs, big numbers for annual comedy-palooza