Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Funding shell games cheat kids
That the history of federal provision of education for First Nations children is fraught with failure, most Canadians today well understand. The lack of sufficient funding played a large role in the outrageously poor conditions — the cold, the damp and the paucity of good food — at Indian residential schools that led to the deaths of children from illnesses that more robust people would survive. Federal politicians were sent numerous reports about the resulting depressing quality of education through the ages.
A 2006 article in the Canadian Journal of Education noted that in 1880, the acting superintendent at Battleford, Saskatchewan, told the Indian Affairs minister that Ottawa would be hard-pressed to hire a teacher for reserve schools for $300 a year, or less. A federal committee on education policy in 1946-48 heard repeated calls for improved funding to boost school resources and to hike teacher salaries.
While the prevailing ethos of education for First Nations children has changed dramatically, reports today on school funding are discouragingly familiar.
First Nations now are given wide latitude over spending of funds transferred from Indian and Northern Affairs Canada to operate schools on reserves with curricula designed to educate children within their culture. This is particularly true for those bands that have block funding for their services.
But the underfunding of schools continues. Bands and their education authorities insist that the federal per student grants fall about 25 per cent below the budgets seen in provincially funded public schools, and so schools lack books, computers and special resources for basics such as reading and arithmetic. Enriched instruction in original languages suffers or is absent. First Nation education authorities complain they have difficulty attracting and retaining certified teachers when neighbouring schools or divisions offer salaries thousands of dollars higher.
For its part, INAC says that its per student grant, between $8,500 to $12,000, is well within the $9,900 average of Manitoba's public schools. First Nations education directors counter that is deceptive: The INAC average includes higher per-student grants paid to non-aboriginal school boards for the band students they instruct, elevating the average.
But the gaming is wide spread. It is a poorly concealed secret that bands, managing competing priorities for spending, hold back a share of the grants ostensibly earmarked by INAC for education. Like all governments, bands dig out of deficit by cutting services across the board. Unlike other governments, bands do not have a tax base from which to draw revenues generally or for education specifically.
Further, with no specific "education act" that lays down governance of schools, criteria for instructors and curricular standards, accountability is slack or missing. Graduation rates, while climbing, fall far below the Canadian average.
Block funding arrangements were intended to empower First Nations leaders, to encourage creative management of priorities. That has failed to materialize, generally, and has allowed the finger pointing to continue, discouraging real progress in the classrooms. Some Manitoba bands have Frontier School Division run their schools because they gain access to professional administration, and to higher per student grants that enrich salaries for teachers. Tribal councils could form regional education associations and mimic the services of Frontier, which operates under provincially established standards.
Education funding should be dedicated for schools. The management of schools must be professional, with good accountability so parents and band members see that students get the instruction they need to stay in school and learn. The shell game that moves money from the federal treasury to the bands cheats First Nations kids of an education even roughly comparable to that of other Canadian children.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition November 24, 2009 A12
- Rate this

-
-
We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high. If you thought it was well written, do the same. If it doesn’t meet your standards, mark it accordingly.
You can also register and/or login to the site and join the conversation by leaving a comment.
Rate it yourself by rolling over the stars and clicking when you reach your desired rating. We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high.
The comment period for this story has ended.
Ads by Google
- Back to Top
- Return to Editorials
-
CON >< CUSSIONS
Examining hockey head injuries
-
Random Acts of Kindness
Your encounters with goodness
-
Open Secrets
Red River students mine government data banks
-
Ski with WFP
Register here to ski Asessippi with the Winnipeg Free Press
-
Miss Lonelyhearts
Maureen Scurfield offers life advice
Poll
Most Popular
- Mild again, but enjoy it while it lasts
- Ice-cutting machine to stay submerged until spring
- Professional, helpful, brave
- Teenage girl charged in man's death
- Off-duty officer stops assault on Transit driver
- Frenchwoman on trial accused of killing 6 of her newborns, hiding corpses
- Huge death toll averted in BC avalanche, but 'stupidity' blamed for two killed
- He can escape her verbal abuse
- Ohio woman: US doctor botched breast surgery, used wrong implants
- Charges considered in machete attack
- Crusader up for Nobel Prize
- From poster couple to problem couple
- Manitoban wheelchair-user badly beaten in Australia
- Six-year-old leads RCMP to attacker
- Off-duty officer stops assault on Transit driver
- New cutting machine breaks through ice near Selkirk
- Musician's mother dies
- Gang showdown 'imminent'
- Mild again, but enjoy it while it lasts
- Mr. Matas a worthy nominee
- Olympic-sized hypocrisy
- Crusader up for Nobel Prize
- Not wrong, just illegal
- Teacher's lapdance caught on tape, watched by world
- Students could be punished
- Is this the worst Olympics ever?
- Second video of lap dance uncovered
- Missing Stonewall man found dead
- Mr. Matas a worthy nominee
- What should happen to two teachers who performed a sexually suggestive dance routine in front of students?
- Ice-cutting machine to stay submerged until spring
- CNIB workers hit the picket line
- Liberals say cutting MP mailings would save $10 million a year
- He can escape her verbal abuse
- Charges considered in machete attack
- If you don't feel like sharing, get your own candy bar miss lonelyhearts
- Mild again, but enjoy it while it lasts
- Off-duty officer stops assault on Transit driver
- Mayor Katz to visit 'homeless' students
- Stop eyeing the over-achiever gym rats and look for a guy who likes to dine out
- Greyhound apologizes for stranding passengers
- Aboriginal elders removed from court on Hydro hearing
- You can't keep grandpa from seeing baby despite childish family dynamics
- Explore drug aids before giving up sex
- Gang showdown 'imminent'
- Lesbian teen faces classmates after school cancels dance over her request to bring girlfriend
- No more quick fixes: mayor
- New cutting machine breaks through ice near Selkirk
- Sex offender at large
- Off-duty officer stops assault on Transit driver
- Teacher's lapdance caught on tape, watched by world
- MP may regret taking aim at Christian youth centre: Mayor Katz
- Students could be punished
- Police shoot and kill suspect
- Second video of lap dance uncovered
- More ominous issue underlies Youth for Christ flap
- Wielding a weapon costs a life
- Mounties hook ice-fishers for open beer
- Youth centre sparks dispute
- Canadian women's hockey team stunned by reaction to post-gold party
- It's the Sharks vs. the Jets in a jazzy rumble
- Ice-cutting machine to stay submerged until spring
- Growing immigrant population means cross-the-board political scrap for votes
- Professional, helpful, brave
- Hometown basks in hero's glow
- You can't keep grandpa from seeing baby despite childish family dynamics
- Former prosecutor ambushed on CBC
- Building where people live
- Black Eyed Peas tickets on sale Saturday
- First Nations want audit before hydro line
- Manitoban wheelchair-user badly beaten in Australia
- Socialism for the rich is Tory way
- Indian Act changing to treat descendants equitably
- New cutting machine breaks through ice near Selkirk
- Gang showdown 'imminent'
- Iceland airline bullish about Winnipeg
- Older women invading Facebook
- Ice-cutting machine to stay submerged until spring
- It's the Sharks vs. the Jets in a jazzy rumble
- Schooling future soccer stars
- Text of Shane Koyczan's opening ceremonies poem, "We Are More"
- Teacher's lapdance caught on tape, watched by world
- Olympic-sized hypocrisy
- Cabela's to open across Canada
- Oprah's on, and so is our Jon!
- Not wrong, just illegal
- Online drug pioneer tumbles
- Mounties hook ice-fishers for open beer
- No listings for buyers flooding the housing market
- Second video of lap dance uncovered
PREVIOUS

2 Comments
Posted by: Luke
November 24, 2009 at 8:07 PM
Maybe instead of block funding, every dollar will have to be designated. X $s for education, x $s for tribal council stipends & expenses. These $s are for housing & only this amount can be spent on housing for tribal council, family & friends. Then audit it. If they can't control the monies in the best interest of the people they represent, take the matter out of their hands. It's not any different then removing certain responsibilities from department heads that seem incapable of using their budget for the best results.
I'm sorry but I've read a number of stories about largely absentee council members living well while the people that elected them live in intolerable conditions.
Posted by: MyOpinion
November 24, 2009 at 9:29 AM
So, if money is earmarked for education, government should make sure it is used for education.
Make the band accountable for any monies, just like governments "supposely" are to be accountable to the people for monies spent.
Once all the monies for education start flowing to education, it should vastly improve the education system for natives.