The View from the West
Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Good reasons to worry about Hydro
Brennan has since publicly denounced the reliability and value of the consultant's study. The consultant responded that Brennan's denunciation of her work contains many statements that are untrue.
Brennan says that Manitoba Hydro has commissioned and obtained a second study that he says shows that Hydro's risk management is "adequate." It is not clear how the assessment was made, since, apparently, the authors of the second study did not have access to the whistleblower's report. Further, Brennan has not released either the terms of reference or the full report of the second study, or, for that matter, the fired consultant's report. Brennan can release the information, but has not. He should.
The whistleblower was not the first or only party to raise concerns about Manitoba Hydro's risk management practices. So has its regulator, the Public Utilities Board (PUB). Last year, the PUB ordered much higher rate hikes for Manitoba ratepayers than Manitoba Hydro had asked for. The PUB stated that it was concerned about the credibility of Manitoba Hydro's risk and revenue projections. The PUB has repeatedly ordered Hydro to provide it with detailed risk management analyses. Hydro has repeatedly failed to do so. Instead of complying with his regulator's orders, Brennan asked for "more time" to put the analyses in "context".
Manitobans bear the ultimate risk for Manitoba Hydro. They're entitled to openness, transparency and accountability from Hydro, its management, and from the government.
Instead, Manitobans have good reason to worry.
Manitobans should worry whether Hydro management has been avoiding disclosure of uncomfortable facts and analyses, spending public money on damage control, and whether Hydro has taken on massive risks without adequate analysis, planning and public disclosure and discussion.
Manitobans should worry about the investigation of Hydro by Auditor General Carol Bellringer. She was a member of Hydro's board and chaired its audit committee in 2004 and 2005. Possible failures of oversight, supervision, personnel decisions and direction by the board during those years might be an issue in a thorough investigation. It is not enough that "outside expertise" will be brought in to work under Bellringer, or that the Ombudsman will provide oversight. In the interests of an independent, rigorous, and objective review of Manitoba Hydro, she should have no involvement in the review to avoid any appearance of being unconsciously influenced by her past close connection with the utility.
Manitobans should worry whether the Public Utility Board has adequate authority to investigate fully mismanagement at Hydro and report on it, or even to force Hydro to comply with its orders.
So what to do?
Hydro must begin by releasing the whistleblower's original reports.
Manitoba's access to information laws provide that technical and scientific reports should ordinarily be made public on request. If Hydro's risk management practices are wanting, then Manitoba taxpayers have a compelling interest in knowing this, and in seeing that they are fixed.
Hydro suggests that releasing the studies would somehow jeopardize Hydro's economic interests. How this is so has not been not explained. The current cloud of secrecy and unresolved doubt over Hydro's methods might in itself hurt Hydro's credibility with potential buyers and suppliers. If there are errors in the whistleblower's studies, Hydro would be free to identify them, and reestablish confidence in its reliability.
It is possible that there are several specific passages in the whistleblower studies that genuinely do warrant protection under our access to information laws. These could simply be blanked out if and when Hydro finally releases them. There is no apparent reason for the wholesale suppression of the report, including its overall findings and conclusions.
Protecting the confidentiality of third parties, such a the whistleblower, can be a ground for a public body to withhold information. But after having her work publicly slammed by Brennan, one expects the whistleblower would be eager to see it released so the people of Manitoba can make their own judgment.
The public has interests of the first order here. Hydro must be open, transparent and accountable; it must have sound governance and risk management practices; and it must contribute to the growth of a dynamic and diverse Manitoba economy.
There is a public need to know, and to know now.
Bryan Schwartz is a professor of law at the University of Manitoba.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition October 28, 2009 A12
- Rate this

-
-
We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high. If you thought it was well written, do the same. If it doesn’t meet your standards, mark it accordingly.
You can also register and/or login to the site and join the conversation by leaving a comment.
Rate it yourself by rolling over the stars and clicking when you reach your desired rating. We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high.
There are no comments at the moment. Be the first to post a comment below.
Post Your Comment
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. Comments are moderated before publication. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
-
Faith Enduring
A look at Manitoba’s Ukrainian community through their churches
-
The Forgotten Disease
The fight to eradicate tuberculosis is far from over.
-
Flu Fight
News about the world's battle against the H1N1 flu pandemic
-
Follow the Way!
Join United Way on its journey toward lasting change and better lives.
-
Winnipeg road closures
Check if your commute is affected
-
Editor's Bulletin
Sign up for daily bulletins
-
Blogs to Watch
We pick our favourite local blogs for you to follow
-
Breaking News Widget
Create and embed a Winnipeg Free Press breaking news widget on your site or blog
- Back to Top
- Return to The View from the West
Advertisement
Most Popular
- Teenager dies in Transcona
- IKEA to anchor high-end retail complex
- Here's why fields are aflame
- Money Makeover: Irony in motion
- Hydro line alters plan for core highrise
- Is Lyle leaving to join Stampeders?
- Couple assaulted three times in Osborne Village
- Woman charged in year-old homicide case
- Jeep rollover gives teens taste of own mortality
- 300 homes evacuated, schools closed after heavy rain, high tide flood Duncan, BC
- Is Lyle leaving to join Stampeders?
- IKEA to anchor high-end retail complex
- Here's why fields are aflame
- Street people will get a home
- Teenager dies in Transcona
- FYI: If we all agree that education is the answer... explain this
- Hydro line alters plan for core highrise
- Sod turned at IKEA site today
- Transit buses switching to winter schedule
- Inquest called into man's death in police custody
- BC hockey dads invent detergent to wipe stench from daughters' hockey gear
- 300 homes evacuated, schools closed after heavy rain, high tide flood Duncan, BC
- Is Lyle leaving to join Stampeders?
- FYI: If we all agree that education is the answer... explain this
- Horror at the movies? That's the snack booth
- FYI: Canada knuckling under, may boot pirates off web
- Book tells FASD kids' stories
- Hydro line alters plan for core highrise
- Street people will get a home
- IKEA to anchor high-end retail complex
Ads by Google


PREVIOUS

0 Comments