Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
How low Tories go
To protect their image, Defence Minister Peter MacKay led an all-out assault on the reputation of career diplomat Richard Colvin even as he was conceding the 2007 reversal on Afghan detainee transfers happened in part because of Colvin's warnings about torture.
And they exploited anti-Semitism without regard for the pain and distress raising this spectre inflicts on the Canadian Jewish community.
The Conservatives targeted five opposition ridings containing large numbers of Jewish voters with political flyers using classic propaganda tools of half-truths and innuendo to smear Liberals as anti-Semitic and anti-Israel.
As Jews and Zionists, whose daughter served in the Israeli Army, Irwin and Ariela Cotler are uniquely qualified to articulate the mixture of outrage and alarm this kind of wedge politics causes in its victims. Irwin Cotler is a former Liberal justice minister who attended the 2001 United Nations anti-racism conference mentioned in the Conservative flyer. Ariela Cotler briefly quit the Liberal Party in 2006 after then-leadership candidate Michael Ignatieff called Israel's bombing of a Lebanese village a war crime. She returned to the party after Ignatieff apologized and withdrew his statement.
Speaking on a motion of privilege on Nov. 19, Cotler denounced as "false, misleading, prejudicial and pernicious slander" Conservative claims that Liberals willingly participated in the UN conference that became a platform for anti-Israeli sentiment.
Pointing out that Israel had asked Canada to remain at Durban to "bear witness" and report the conference's anti-Semitic overtones, Cotler continued: "The Government of Israel publicly commended Canada for Canada's condemnation of anti-Semitism at Durban 1. Does that mean the Government of Israel, by supporting the Government of Canada, was also identifying with anti-Semitism? What kind of absurdity is that coming out of the members of the Conservative government. This is as absurd as it is false."
Cotler had equally strong words for the Conservative accusation the Liberals opposed de-funding Hamas and asked for Hezbollah to be delisted as a terrorist organization. It was the Liberal government that listed both Hamas and Hezbollah as terrorist organizations in 2002. "For shame," Cotler continued. Funding both "was illegal under Canadian law from 2002 onward...How can they take credit that after 2006 they de-funded Hamas? My God, there has to be some respect for truth and some respect for honesty."
In a letter published in the National Post Nov. 21, Ariela Cotler countered every half-truth in the flyer with the offsetting fact it ignored. Then she went to the heart of what is so destructive and dangerous about wedge politics:
"It is presumptuous enough to presume that Canadian Jews only vote on these issues -- regardless of concerns over health care, the environment, social justice, poverty -- and that they vote as a bloc.
"In fact, so far as I know, no other religious community in our riding has been so targeted. But even on the 'Jewish values' issue, the flyer is a series of false and arguably slanderous statements...I condemn the Conservative party for its disinformation."
NDP MP Paul Dewar (Ottawa Centre) calls the flyers "boiler-plate wedge politics...It poisons the well of our political culture."
Retired University of Manitoba historian D.N. Sprague has described such tactics as "the paranoid style of politics." Paranoid or status politics play in the incendiary arena of the self-images of individuals and groups and their power relationships with each other. Status politics easily drown out the interest politics of rational debate on bread and butter realities like jobs and the economy.
Because status politics "stimulate the exposed nerve"' of rivalry based on race, colour, religion, language, class or region, they can unleash antagonisms that have no limit, Sprague says. They are most prevalent during periods of social and economic stress. People who are insecure search for scapegoats, fellow citizens who are different, for example, in language, religion or region, and who are perceived to be better off in some way, prospering at their expense and somehow conspiring to block their opportunity for power, financial success or recognition. Status politics are especially perilous for their perennial target, minorities.
If this is how low the Conservatives go when they are riding high in the polls, imagine what they will stoop to if their grip on power is actually threatened.
Frances Russell is a Winnipeg author and political commentator.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition November 25, 2009 A15
- Rate this

-
-
We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high. If you thought it was well written, do the same. If it doesn’t meet your standards, mark it accordingly.
You can also register and/or login to the site and join the conversation by leaving a comment.
Rate it yourself by rolling over the stars and clicking when you reach your desired rating. We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high.
The comment period for this story has ended.
Ads by Google
- Back to Top
- Return to The View from the West
-
Working in Winnipeg
A close-up look at the jobs people do and why they do them
-
Helping Haiti
Where to make donations
-
Open Secrets
Red River students mine government data banks
-
Ski with WFP
Register here to ski Asessippi with the Winnipeg Free Press
-
Random Acts of Kindness
Your encounters with goodness
Poll
Most Popular
- No peace for dead girl's mom
- Falls from operating table prompt new procedures at hospitals
- Murder charges against top CFB Trenton officer leave military community reeling
- Bombers sue over cancelled Aerosmith concert
- Should have been listening, Tiger
- No support for Winnipeg's 'Homeless Hero' in days before attack: stepdaughter
- Checking out sex show all part of journalist's job
- MPI playing politics with poll question: Tories
- Body found in Delta airplane wheel well after arriving in Tokyo from New York
- Larger garbage carts may become available
- Little boy left cold, crying outside locked daycare
- Woman arrested in Faron Hall beating
- Pilot burnt plane as signal before walking to shore
- Storm warning issued
- Built-in text messages ruined life, says city man
- LaPolice named as Bomber head coach
- City streets very slippery; several vehicles involved in crashes
- No peace for dead girl's mom
- 26 cats too many, woman told
- Car stolen at gunpoint recovered
- Guns N' Roses show a massive rock 'n' roll spectacle
- Extended family pulls together
- Water pressure drop caused by power outage: city
- Little boy left cold, crying outside locked daycare
- Avoid Perimeter: RCMP
- Two dead after crash on Bishop Grandin
- Winter storm warnings issued for Winnipeg, southern Manitoba
- Woman arrested in Faron Hall beating
- Pilot burnt plane as signal before walking to shore
- Cheap Vancouver rentals, if tiny's OK
- Larger garbage carts may become available
- No peace for dead girl's mom
- Take one downtown, fill it with people
- No support for Winnipeg's 'Homeless Hero' in days before attack: stepdaughter
- Councillors nix oversized rolling garbage bins
- Got more trash? It'll cost you
- MPI playing politics with poll question: Tories
- Bombers sue over cancelled Aerosmith concert
- Brian Sinclair's family should get more money for lawyer
- City looking at adding bike lane on Pembina
- Little boy left cold, crying outside locked daycare
- 300 pounds of marijuana found in semi
- LaPolice named as Bomber head coach
- Sick days spike during blizzard
- Woman arrested in Faron Hall beating
- 26 cats too many, woman told
- Car stolen at gunpoint recovered
- Shielding buyers, or 'cash grab'?
- Bad cocaine results in grave illness, hospitalization
- Built-in text messages ruined life, says city man
- 300 pounds of marijuana found in semi
- Girl not a bully, shouldn't have been suspended, says mom
- Arrest tape kills auto-theft case
- Little boy left cold, crying outside locked daycare
- Don't dock students for missing deadlines: NDP
- Alleged mobsters seek to stay
- RCMP investigating after video shows police beating suspect
- U.S. fighter slams Canada's 'Third World' health system
- LaPolice named as Bomber head coach
- Drunk cop crashes motorbike, gets fined
- Site for parents' sore eyes
- Iran playing its hand
- Falls from operating table prompt new procedures at hospitals
- First female boss for Destination Winnipeg
- No peace for dead girl's mom
- Happy 111th birthday to oldest Manitoban
- Food for thought
- Murder charges against top CFB Trenton officer leave military community reeling
- Footprints in snow lead to stolen goods
- Bone-chilling temps become hot commodity
- Little boy left cold, crying outside locked daycare
- LaPolice named as Bomber head coach
- Cat came back: 14 years later
- 26 cats too many, woman told
- A super-lab to fight superbugs
- Hutterite biography to debut despite legal chill
- Pilot burnt plane as signal before walking to shore
- Site for parents' sore eyes
- Built-in text messages ruined life, says city man
- Happy 111th birthday to oldest Manitoban
- 'Tough guys' wanted as film extras
- Nylons still smooth as silk
- Bath & Body Works coming to St. Vital
- Cat came back: 14 years later
- Little boy left cold, crying outside locked daycare
- Guns N' Roses show a massive rock 'n' roll spectacle
- Winnipeg desserts are a piece of cake
- LaPolice named as Bomber head coach
- VIDEO: A winter wonderland?
- Harper really is dangerous
PREVIOUS

8 Comments
Posted by: W.E.
November 26, 2009 at 1:10 PM
The biggest problem for the Liberals (and liberals) is that they are always trying to be fair. They tend to want ALL the facts before defending or condemning. The conservatives are never burdened with such conundrums. They know what's right because god and Mr. Harper TELL them what's right. Can the conservatives sink any lower? Just watch them.
Posted by: Huey Long
November 25, 2009 at 3:53 PM
In response to your last question Ms. Russell, the Cons dealt an enormous body blow to our democracy and attempted tear the nation in half in December 2008.
Posted by:
November 25, 2009 at 12:42 PM
Of course Russell agrees with the Liberals on this. The fact is that nobody accused the Liberals of being anti-Semetic, just anti-Israel. If Liberals want to interrpret that as anti-Semetism, thats fine. But the Liberals and Frances Russell consitantly come out against Israel, and in defense of terrorists and other unsavory characters. Until they can articulate WHY this is, the Conservatives should continue to drive these facts home.
Posted by: Lloyd MacIlquham
November 25, 2009 at 12:32 PM
The attack on Colvin's credibility is, of course, outrageous. So is the 10%-er slandering Irwin Cotler, Ignatieff and the Liberal Party.
The biggest shocker is that these things are being done by the same people who are running our country. This not some two-bit group of misfits operating on the fringe of our society, not now since they got into power anyway.
If I were Cotler I would be talking to my lawyer right now about launching a libel suit against Harper, the Con Party, Vic Toews or whomever it is that is responsible.
Harper and the Con's have developed the biggest propaganda machine seen in Western democracies in recent history that they have no hesitation in using no matter how reprehensible and morally and secularly dishonest, approaching Canadians on an emotional level, with a total disregard for the truth.
Harper and the Con's are only concerned with grabbing onto power and maintaining it, at any cost, and Canada be damned.
Also, one can only wonder to what extent, given the huge amounts of tax payers money, as well as Con Party money, Harper spends on media - central to the smooth running of their propaganda machine, the Harper and Con largess is tied to media that publish pro-Con materials.
With a Press that is willing to write articles in an open, informative, objective manner such as this one, all Canadians will see Harper and his Con's for what they really are.
Excerpt:
Lloyd MacIlquham cicblog
Posted by: Joh
November 25, 2009 at 12:11 PM
So, Russell is appalled that the Cons could smear the Libs as anti-semitic. The Libs (and the MSM) have been smearing the Tories (and Albertans) as racist for years. Suddenly, these
tactics are unacceptable. How predictable.
Posted by: Andrew Bonner
November 25, 2009 at 11:38 AM
A lot of high profile people in western countries and indeed many Israeli citizens are on record for condemning heavy-handed behaviour by Israel against Palestinians. There's nothing anti-semitic about this. Would you really rather have a leader who "unquestioningly (unthinkingly) supports" another country, or would you rather our leaders use their brains and give support where it's deserved?
Nonetheless, Ms Russell's point is centred on the Conservative predilection for smear, and the politics of the gutter. Would you say these flyers are a good use of taxpayer's money? Would you say they have a genuine value as instructional material? Do you think the government has acted correctly in attacking Richard Colvin?
Posted by: Jason Wayne
November 25, 2009 at 10:26 AM
I for one would love them to be in full power, just to read more of this liberal, conservative-hating, bleeding heart tripe.
Posted by: hollinm
November 25, 2009 at 7:19 AM
I guess this columnist cannot write her own columns. She has a distinct habit of filling her columns with the quotes of others.
The fact is the Liberal party is on record and particularly Iffy in condemning the actions of Israel in their fight with Hezbollah.
In fact who can forget Denis Coderre and Gilles Duceppe marching with Hezbollah supporters in Quebec.
So Russell should get off her high horse and call a spade a spade instead of trying to defend the indefensible.
The Libs want to straddle the fence all the time. Harper stands up and is counted in his unquestionable defense of Israel.