Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
HST good for retailers and consumers
Let's take this debate to its most basic level -- Manitoba can't afford not to harmonize without risk of being left behind by the rest of the country and putting our local retailers at a severe competitive disadvantage to those in neighbouring provinces and in the U.S. To hold back is bad for retailers and bad for consumers.
By July 2010, 80 per cent of Canadians will be buying and selling products and services under HST. New Brunswick, Newfoundland and Labrador, Nova Scotia, Quebec, Ontario and British Columbia will all have moved to a harmonized tax.
That means retailers across the country will be benefitting from lower costs due to the provision of input tax credits and a decreased administrative burden.
Why should Manitobans care? Retailers in provinces with harmonization will have the benefit of lower costs making them more competitive, efficient, and in a better position to pass those efficiencies onto the consumer. Why would we not want the same for Manitobans?
Job seekers in the province will also benefit from the cost savings for business. With more money being reinvested in their business rather than into handling tax collection, retailers will be stronger and more likely to grow -- and growth means jobs.
Now that we've gotten past the basics, let's get to the products that are currently PST exempt for which consumers fear they will now pay an increased tax.
As we've seen in other provinces that have moved toward harmonization, it is within the government's powers to exempt certain products. As has happened recently in Ontario and B.C., the Retail Council of Canada believes that the government should include in their plan exemptions for products such as books, footwear, children's clothing and feminine hygiene products among others.
The government also has it within its powers the means to reduce the impact on consumers through income tax reductions for low and middle-income Manitobans as well as a number of additional credits and exemptions they can offer.
Although retailers believe tax harmonization in Manitoba is a positive and needed step, there is one caveat -- that the tax should remain visible at the point-of-sale.
A number of jurisdictions have looked at the possibility of "tax-inclusive" pricing. If this happens, all bets are off.
The cost of hiding the tax will wipe out any savings in addition to fragmenting the domestic market by forcing national and regional retailers to show different prices for the same product, depending on the province where it is sold.
So the question now is: how can Manitoba afford not to harmonize?
Lanny McInnes is director of government relations and member services (Manitoba) for the Retail Council of Canada.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition November 20, 2009 A15
- Rate this

-
-
We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high. If you thought it was well written, do the same. If it doesn’t meet your standards, mark it accordingly.
You can also register and/or login to the site and join the conversation by leaving a comment.
Rate it yourself by rolling over the stars and clicking when you reach your desired rating. We want you to tell us what you think of our articles. If the story moves you, compels you to act or tells you something you didn’t know, mark it high.
The comment period for this story has ended.
Ads by Google
- Back to Top
- Return to The View from the West
-
Working in Winnipeg
A close-up look at the jobs people do and why they do them
-
Helping Haiti
Where to make donations
-
Open Secrets
Red River students mine government data banks
-
Ski with WFP
Register here to ski Asessippi with the Winnipeg Free Press
-
Random Acts of Kindness
Your encounters with goodness
Poll
Most Popular
- Murder charges against top CFB Trenton officer leave military community reeling
- Happy 111th birthday to oldest Manitoban
- No peace for dead girl's mom
- Should have been listening, Tiger
- Checking out sex show all part of journalist's job
- No support for Winnipeg's 'Homeless Hero' in days before attack: stepdaughter
- Body found in Delta airplane wheel well after arriving in Tokyo from New York
- Little boy left cold, crying outside locked daycare
- Pilot burnt plane as signal before walking to shore
- Larger garbage carts may become available
- Little boy left cold, crying outside locked daycare
- Woman arrested in Faron Hall beating
- Pilot burnt plane as signal before walking to shore
- Storm warning issued
- Built-in text messages ruined life, says city man
- LaPolice named as Bomber head coach
- City streets very slippery; several vehicles involved in crashes
- 26 cats too many, woman told
- Car stolen at gunpoint recovered
- Police apologize for not looking into woman's complaint against gynecologist
- Guns N' Roses show a massive rock 'n' roll spectacle
- Extended family pulls together
- Two dead after crash on Bishop Grandin
- Water pressure drop caused by power outage: city
- Avoid Perimeter: RCMP
- Little boy left cold, crying outside locked daycare
- Winter storm warnings issued for Winnipeg, southern Manitoba
- Woman arrested in Faron Hall beating
- Pilot burnt plane as signal before walking to shore
- Cheap Vancouver rentals, if tiny's OK
- Take one downtown, fill it with people
- Larger garbage carts may become available
- No support for Winnipeg's 'Homeless Hero' in days before attack: stepdaughter
- Bad cocaine results in grave illness, hospitalization
- Prominence proving costly to Hall: friend
- Trappers suing for $64M
- More police cars for suburbs: committee
- Got more trash? It'll cost you
- Checking out sex show all part of journalist's job
- Happy 111th birthday to oldest Manitoban
- 300 pounds of marijuana found in semi
- Little boy left cold, crying outside locked daycare
- LaPolice named as Bomber head coach
- Sick days spike during blizzard
- Woman arrested in Faron Hall beating
- 26 cats too many, woman told
- Car stolen at gunpoint recovered
- Zoning memorandums to cost sellers up to $180
- Shielding buyers, or 'cash grab'?
- Built-in text messages ruined life, says city man
- 300 pounds of marijuana found in semi
- Girl not a bully, shouldn't have been suspended, says mom
- Arrest tape kills auto-theft case
- Don't dock students for missing deadlines: NDP
- Two dead after crash on Bishop Grandin
- Alleged mobsters seek to stay
- Little boy left cold, crying outside locked daycare
- RCMP investigating after video shows police beating suspect
- U.S. fighter slams Canada's 'Third World' health system
- LaPolice named as Bomber head coach
- Happy 111th birthday to oldest Manitoban
- Iran playing its hand
- Soft drinks hike pancreatic cancer risk: study
- Steamy weekend
- Friendly credit union to open first city branch
- Checking out sex show all part of journalist's job
- Real-estate association's rules challenged by federal competition watchdog
- Patient died after fall from operating table
- Jobs figures a bit too bright?
- First female boss for Destination Winnipeg
- Little boy left cold, crying outside locked daycare
- Cat came back: 14 years later
- LaPolice named as Bomber head coach
- Manitoba Merv predicts an early spring
- Zoning memorandums to cost sellers up to $180
- 26 cats too many, woman told
- A super-lab to fight superbugs
- Hutterite biography to debut despite legal chill
- Rude rowdies ruin Earle concert
- Pilot burnt plane as signal before walking to shore
- 'Tough guys' wanted as film extras
- Nylons still smooth as silk
- Bath & Body Works coming to St. Vital
- Two dead after crash on Bishop Grandin
- Little boy left cold, crying outside locked daycare
- Cat came back: 14 years later
- Guns N' Roses show a massive rock 'n' roll spectacle
- Winnipeg desserts are a piece of cake
- LaPolice named as Bomber head coach
- VIDEO: A winter wonderland?
PREVIOUS

1 Comments
Posted by: Buck9
November 20, 2009 at 8:59 AM
It is a fallacy that businesses will
pass on HST "savings" to consumers.
A convenient untruth, if you will.
It certainly may be postulated that
the shoring up of lost revenues from income trusts
is likely the reason for the big push
on the HST. There are similarities.
One is that Jack Mintz is once again
providing faulty supporting research.
And Don Drummond is giving his assent. Another is
that Harper and Flaherty are the initiators.
It brings to mind the adage that
one mistake leads to another and another!
The Cons are relying on an unsuspecting
public to buy into their nonsense, once again.
P.S. Unlike Mr. McInnes, I am not employed
by an organization that would
influence my views.