Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Province working on plan to fix child welfare
Gord Mackintosh said he is frustrated he cant, by law, comment on the specifics of Guimonds case because it is under investigation internally and by police.
But he said the province has just embarked on a plan to fix the provinces troubled child welfare system, a plan sparked by the 2005 death of five-year-old Phoenix Sinclair.
This is a profoundly sad and heart-rending tragedy from all accounts, said Mackintosh. Its very painful for many people. That has to be whats first and foremost.
Guimond died Sunday after falling down the stairs in his Magnus Avenue home, but police say the boy had been severely abused while in the care of his great aunt, Shirley Guimond.
Mackintosh said his government has just embarked on the biggest overhaul of its child welfare system in the provinces history, and the system received a 25 per cent funding boost to address some of the staffing and training shortfalls.
But a frustrated Mavis Taillieu, opposition critic for child welfare, said another child killed while in care points to the ongoing failures of the embattled system.
Weve gone through so many reviews of the system, so many recommendations, so much money pumped into it, but we still have a system thats failing, she said.
Taillieu said she supports the principle of devolution, where native and Métis agencies control child welfare services.
But culture aside, you better be sure youre putting a child in a better home than the one they left, said Taillieu.
Last fall, three reviews highlighted failures in the child welfare system, including overworked staff and underfunding. The reports outlined 220 recommendations for improving the child welfare system, including better staff training and province-wide caseload standards.
But the reports prompted by Sinclairs death just months after her child welfare case file was closed found that the systems failures did not directly contribute to the deaths of as many as 145 children connected to the child welfare system between 2003 and 2006.
The studies also said the hand-over of child and family services to Aboriginal agencies, which began around the time Sinclair died, was not too blame for her death.
Most of the 145 children died of natural causes, but another 69 died of accidents, suicides, homicide or some other undetermined cause.
Not long after the trio of reports were released, Manitobas auditor general slammed CFS for failures in the management, record-keeping and accountability systems. Those problems were not fixed before devolution, said the auditor.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition July 24, 2007
Photo Store Gallery
Most Popular Making Changes
- Sagkeeng CFS faces scrutiny over deaths
- Phoenix's legacy is just beginning
- CFS audit combs files of all kids in agency's care
Ads by Google