Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Big numbers, bigger debate
Suspected PED users Clemens, Bonds, Sosa face tough Hall of Fame vote
NEW YORK -- The most polarizing Hall of Fame debate since Pete Rose will now be decided by the baseball shrine's voters: Do Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens and Sammy Sosa belong in Cooperstown despite drug allegations that tainted their huge numbers?
In a monthlong election sure to become a referendum on the Steroids Era, the Hall ballot was released Wednesday, and Bonds, Clemens and Sosa are on it for the first time.
Bonds is the all-time home run champion with 762 and won a record seven MVP awards. Clemens took home a record seven Cy Young trophies and is ninth with 354 victories. Sosa ranks eighth on the homer chart with 609.
Yet for all their HRs, RBIs and Ws, the shadow of PEDs looms large.
"You could see for years that this particular ballot was going to be controversial and divisive to an unprecedented extent," Larry Stone of the Seattle Times wrote in an email. "My hope is that some clarity begins to emerge over the Hall of Fame status of those linked to performance-enhancing drugs. But I doubt it."
More than 600 longtime members of the Baseball Writers' Association of America will vote on the 37-player ballot. Candidates require 75 per cent for induction, and the results will be announced Jan. 9.
Craig Biggio, Mike Piazza and Curt Schilling also are among the 24 first-time eligibles. Jack Morris, Jeff Bagwell and Tim Raines are the top holdover candidates.
If recent history is any indication, the odds are solidly stacked against Bonds, Clemens and Sosa. Mark McGwire and Rafael Palmeiro both posted Cooperstown-caliber stats, too, but drug clouds doomed them in Hall voting.
Some who favour Bonds and Clemens claim the bulk of their accomplishments came before baseball got wrapped up in drug scandals. They add that PED use was so prevalent in the 1980s, 1990s and early 2000s that it's unfair to exclude anyone because so many who-did-and-who-didn't questions remain.
Many fans on the other side say drug cheats -- suspected or otherwise -- should never be afforded the game's highest individual honour.
Either way, this election is baseball's newest hot button, generating the most fervent Hall arguments since Rose. The discussion about Rose was moot, however -- the game's career hits leader agreed to a lifetime ban in 1989 after an investigation concluded he bet on games while managing the Cincinnati Reds, and that barred him from the BBWAA ballot.
The BBWAA election rules allow voters to pick up to 10 candidates. As for criteria, this is the only instruction: "Voting shall be based upon the player's record, playing ability, integrity, sportsmanship, character, and contributions to the team(s) on which the player played."
That leaves a lot of room for interpretation.
Bonds, Clemens and Sosa won't get a vote from Mike Klis of the Denver Post.
"Nay on all three. I think in all three cases, their performances were artificially enhanced. Especially in the cases of Bonds and Clemens, their production went up abnormally late in their careers," he wrote in an email.
They'll do better with Bob Dutton of the Kansas City Star.
"I plan to vote for all three. I understand the steroid/PED questions surrounding each one, and I've wrestled with the implications," he wrote in an email.
"My view is these guys played and posted Hall of Fame-type numbers against the competition of their time. That will be my sole yardstick. If Major League Baseball took no action against a player during his career for alleged or suspected steroid/PED use, I'm not going to do so in assessing their career for the Hall of Fame," he said.
-- The Associated Press
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition November 29, 2012 D4
Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
(1 of 8 articles for today)10:26 AM 0
ATLANTA - The Atlanta Braves have named John Hart as president of baseball operations.
Hart was hired as interim general manager ...
Photo Store Gallery
- Giants pitcher Tim Lincecum injures back in 1st appearance since September
- Handwriting on the wall for Royals: Bench coach Don Wakamatsu's lineup cards are works of art
- Highly touted pitcher Tomohiro Anraku taken first in Japanese baseball amateur draft
- Royals take the fight to San Francisco, evening World Series with 7-2 victory in Game 2
- Federal agents seize phoney World Series tickets, merchandise; tickets had $43K street value
- Royals' bullpen blanks Giants in 7-2 victory that evens World Series as it shifts to Bay Area
- Butler fits in fine: Burly DH delivers 2 big hits as Royals even World Series, beat Giants 7-2
- Giants fan attacked at Dodger Stadium in 2011 shows significant progress in interview
- After nearly 3 decades, Royals who won club's only World Series relishing another deep run
- Plantier fired as hitting coach after Padres hit major league-low .226
- How freaky: Two-time NL Cy Young Award winner Tim Lincecum hasn't yet pitched this post-season
- Wild-card World Series: Gordon, upstart Royals vs tried-and-tested Posey, Giants
- Giants fan who caught home run ball sending team to World Series gives it to player who hit it
- Wrigley Field's outfield walls, bleachers knocked down as part of renovation project
- Down and out: from Mexico to the World Series, Petit shines in reliever role with Giants
- Ishikawa gets souvenir
- A capsule look at the World Series between the San Francisco Giants and Kansas City Royals
- Mike Matheny again leads Cardinals deep into post-season, but no titles yet
- World Series-bound San Francisco Giants mourn sudden death of longtime scout Stan Saleski
- Posey catches on fast, stars at the plate and behind it as Giants bid for 3rd title in 5 years
- 1 more time: Jeter's game-ending hit lifts Yankees over Orioles 6-5 in Bronx farewell
- Royals run wild in thriller, rally past A's 9-8 in 12 innings in first playoff game since '85
- Goldeyes exercise their option on 19 players for 2015 season
- Belt's homer in 18th lifts Giants to 2-1 win over Nats, 2-0 NLDS lead with Game 3 at home
- Royal Flush: KC completes ALCS sweep of O's with 2-1 win, reaches 1st World Series since 1985
- Wong homers in 9th, Cardinals edge Giants 5-4 to even NLCS at 1-all after Molina injured
- Twins fire manager Ron Gardenhire after 13 seasons and 70-92 finish in 2014
- Uh, oh, O's: Britton allows tiebreaking hit in 9th, Orioles lose 6-4, trail Royals 2-0 in ALCS
- Saying goodbye difficult task for Fish
- Bumgarner tames Cardinals, Giants get just enough off Wainwright for 3-0 win in NLCS opener
Ads by Google