Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Qatar World Cup should be played during Canadian winter
It has been a controversial week for the institution of the World Cup. Excuse the poor attempt at a pun, but the world's biggest sporting event has been taking a lot of heat the last few days.
UEFA president Michel Platini ignited the firestorm on Tuesday when he reiterated his oft-repeated and quite sensible position that the 2022 World Cup in Qatar take place during the European (and Canadian) winter.
The oppressive heat of the Gulf state during June and July, which is typically when the World Cup is held, would make a summer tournament uncomfortable at best for fans and players, and unbearable at worst.
"I hope it will be held in winter," he told the London Evening Standard. "We have to go to Qatar when it is good for everybody to participate."
Not surprisingly, Platini's comments set off the predictable round of griping, grousing and Eurocentric grumbling.
The phrase "winter World Cup" is a touchstone for argument these days, nevermind that the last World Cup was held in winter (June in South Africa is, after all, winter in South Africa) and that the next one will be as well.
Of course, what this is really about is the Premier League, La Liga, Serie A and the rest of the continent's big, powerful leagues preferring not to have to take an extended break in November or December, which is when Platini is suggesting the 2022 competition be held.
Having said that, the divisions of Spain, Italy and Germany traditionally take a few weeks off in early winter, anyway, so the adjustment from their end wouldn't be much of a problem at all.
And that's precisely the point. A winter World Cup would not be a problem. Qualification schedules would only have to be moved up about a month, and the affected leagues have a decade to figure out how they'll handle the stoppage.
After all, it's not like this doesn't happen in other parts of the world every four years.
The June-July World Cup goes right through North America's Major League Soccer season, and many South American leagues -- including the lucrative Brazilian championship -- are interrupted by the "summer" World Cups as well. Even in the more wintry climes of Europe, such as Norway, the customary World Cup schedule falls in the middle of their league campaigns.
No country, no region, has a monopoly on the seasons. And if that seems obvious, it's because this issue is actually very straightforward. Events should be held when it makes sense to hold them in the location that is doing the holding.
Plain and simple.
"If we stop from November 2 to December 20 it means, instead of finishing in May, (most of the European leagues) stop in June," said Platini. "It's not a big deal."
Spotkicks
FIFA released the 2014 World Cup match schedule on Thursday, and while they're rightfully taking some heat for the mid-day kickoff times in cities such as Recife and Salvador they essentially had their hands tied from the start by a stubborn organizing committee that insisted the matches be spread across the entire country. Brazil isn't a small place, and the notion that each of the 32 sides should play their group matches over the expanse of it is absurd.
It's been another strange week in the life of Steve Kean.
On Monday it was rumoured the Blackburn Rovers boss had been sacked the night before, only for him to turn up the next morning and conduct training.
Kean is wildly unpopular with Rovers fans who saw their club relegated from the Premier League in May, and on Friday the 44-year-old resigned his position, saying it had become "untenable." If he was at all perceptive he'd have realized that six months ago.
Zinedine Zidane's head-butt on Marco Materazzi during the 2006 World Cup final has been immortalized in art. A bronze statue portraying the incident was recently completed by Algerian sculptor Adel Abdessemed and will be on display at the Paris' Pompidou from October to January.
jerradpeters@gmail.com Twitter @peterssoccer
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition September 29, 2012 C9
More Soccer
- Back to Top
- Return to Soccer
More Soccer
(1 of 20 articles for today)
Bayern Munich, Dortmund take bitter rivalry to whole new level in Champions League final
9:45 AM 0LONDON - Bayern Munich and Borussia Dortmund will take their increasingly acrimonious rivalry to a new level Saturday in the ...
Poll
Most Popular Soccer
- Animal crackers: Walter the orangutan, tapir, 2 otters opt for Dortmund over Bayern in final
- American gets call from Canada, awaits approval from FIFA brass
- German Chancellor Angela Merkel to attend all-German Champions League final in Wembley
- Keisuke Honda, Shinji Kagawa selected in Japan squad for World Cup qualifier against Australia
- Fired Roberto Mancini thanks Man City fans in full-page advert in local newspaper
- Chelsea trains at Busch Stadium for Man City, ready for Mourinho return
- Australia's A-League season to extend into May for the first time from 2013-14
- Germany to miss Bayern Munich, Borussia Dortmund players in squad for US tour
- Roma, Lazio delegations meet Pope Francis at Vatican in peace bid ahead of Italian Cup final
- Manuel Pellegrini cites 'sporting reasons' for plans to leave Malaga; Man City role still open
- German Chancellor Angela Merkel to attend all-German Champions League final in Wembley
- David Beckham's life after football will see him remain a global figure in the sport he loves
- Esteghlal, Guangzhou open 2nd round with away wins in Asian Champions League
- Star-studded Guangzhou wary of A-League champs the Mariners in 2nd round opener
- Beckham a true pro from start to finish, detractors be danged
- Real Madrid to host Atletico Madrid in Copa del Rey final on May 17
- Sydney FC and Del Piero to play friendly against Sagan Tosu in Japan on July 24
- A-League's Adelaide United hires Spaniard Josep Gombau as head coach
- New Zealand forward Marco Rojas to join Bundesliga's Stuttgart from Melbourne Victory
- Santos Laguna to meet Cruz Azul, America plays Monterrey in Mexican semifinals
- Seattle man dribbling soccer ball to Brazil killed by car on Oregon Coast
- Police: Utah soccer referee dies, after player's punch sends him into a coma
- Utah teen charged with homicide by assault in death of soccer referee who died after punch
- Football Association says Liverpool striker Luis Suarez has not appealed his 10-match ban
- Family of Utah soccer referee who died holds vigil; calls on players to control tempers
- German Chancellor Angela Merkel to attend all-German Champions League final in Wembley
- David Beckham's life after football will see him remain a global figure in the sport he loves
- Utah referee in coma after being punched by teen player
- Barca's collapse signifies end of era
- Real Madrid to host Atletico Madrid in Copa del Rey final on May 17
- Seattle man dribbling soccer ball to Brazil killed by car on Oregon Coast
- German Chancellor Angela Merkel to attend all-German Champions League final in Wembley
- Utah referee critically hurt by punch to face from teen upset about call during soccer game
- Ronaldinho boosts chances to make Confed Cup team after great performance in Copa Libertadores
- Eintracht Braunschweig is promoted to Bundesliga after 28 years
- Man United hires Everton's David Moyes to replace Alex Ferguson on 6-year contract
Ads by Google











You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.