Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Sports not exempt from all civilities
Some things OK on field of play, some things not OK anywhere
c_ (CP)
At left, Chelsea captain John Terry exchanges words with QPR's Anton Ferdinand while walking with Chelsea's Branislav Ivanovic. At right, Manchester United's Patrice Evra has words with Liverpool's Luis Suarez. (THE ASSOCIATED PRESS ARCHIVES)
Racism and sport have always had a difficult relationship.
The arena, to the athlete, is a place where the laws governing civilian society simply cannot reach, where once having walked from the parking lot to the pitch the rules have somehow changed.
This is understood and necessary -- and mostly good -- since one wouldn't want to be the victim of a lunging tackle on the sidewalk.
To the fan, as well, the stadium represents something separate from greater society, and once through the turnstiles it becomes acceptable to shout abuse at the authorities, sing with more passion than you ever would in church and scream an assortment of four-letter words at the opposition.
Once again, there's nothing inherently wrong with this. Sport is, for participants both on the field of play and in the stands, a platform for expression. It is not, however, an excuse to abandon civilized behaviour, a time machine that takes you back to a place and period where certain slurs were an unfortunate part of the vernacular, and where using them bore no consequence.
You could forgive Anton Ferdinand and Patrice Evra for thinking they had somehow taken a ride in that time machine last October.
In the space of eight days both defenders were racially abused by opposing players, and in the three months since both have been peppered with questions about how they'll react when they next face their abusers.
The fans, meanwhile, have been instructed to behave themselves, and now everyone is anxiously awaiting today's FA Cup matches, as if what transpires at Loftus Road and Anfield will somehow settle the racism question once and for all.
For Ferdinand, the question is whether to shake John Terry's hand ahead of kickoff. The Chelsea and England captain, is alleged to have made racial slurs at Ferdinand, a Queens Park Rangers defender, and is now the subject of a police investigation.
Evra's situation is rather more convoluted, as the Liverpool player who is said to have repeated a slur at the Manchester United defender as many as eight times is sitting out the final match of an eight-game ban handed down as punishment for the abuse.
For Evra, the offending party is less Luis Suarez than Liverpool Football Club, as it was the club -- in its absurd and unwavering support of Suarez -- that actually attacked his dignity, questioning whether he was a trustworthy witness when Suarez was dragged before an FA inquiry.
Then there are the fans. While many have stayed above the fray through all this some have behaved despicably, whether singing derogatory songs about Ferdinand while on a Champions League visit to Belgium, swamping Facebook and Twitter with unrepeatable remarks about Evra or hurling abuse at unsuspecting Oldham midfielder Tom Adeyemi, who just happened to visit Liverpool when frustration at the Suarez ban was raw. Just this week Ferdinand received a bullet in the mail.
It's at this point the authorities are well within their rights to step in, to interfere and even dismantle the sport-as-separate-from-greater-society paradigm.
Police are often viewed with disdain when thought to be intruding on the self-governing realm of sport, but when the harassment doesn't actually have anything to do with the game being played it's sport overstepping its bounds, not the police.
It's disappointing that their involvement is required at all. Racism is something we like to think was extinguished in the '60s and '70s, that ours is a post-racial society. But the sad fact of the matter is that it's still here, on our streets and in our sports -- an outlet for the very basest expression of those who lack the intelligence to communicate frustration in any other way.
jerradpeters@gmail.com
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition January 28, 2012 C8
More Soccer
- Back to Top
- Return to Soccer
Most Popular Soccer
- Neymar released from Brazil's squad for friendly against Denmark
- Nani bringing skills to Manitoba
- Brazil without young star Neymar for friendly against Denmark in Germany
- Hulk scores 2 as Brazil beats Denmark 3-1 in pre-Olympic friendly
- Makeshift Spain squad to face Euro 2012 warmups without Barcelona, Chelsea or Bilbao players
- Euro 2012: France, England renew football rivalry in unpredictable Group D at Euro 2012
- Croatia beats Estonia 3-1 in a friendly ahead of Euro 2012
- Fernando Torres says he's unhappy at Chelsea after not starting Champions League final
- Copa del Rey Champions
- Eren Derdiyok scores hat trick to lead Switzerland to 5-3 victory over Germany in friendly
- Neymar released from Brazil's squad for friendly against Denmark
- Bayern Munich's downfall could affect Germany's Euro plans
- Chelsea weighs changing a winning formula as Europe's new champion plans for future
- Fernando Torres says he's unhappy at Chelsea after not starting Champions League final
- Chelsea parade first European Cup through streets of London
- UEFA to give clubs Champions League prize money raise from improved broadcast, sponsor deals
- Drogba decides the match
- Makeshift Spain squad to face Euro 2012 warmups without Barcelona, Chelsea or Bilbao players
- Barcelona's 2012-13 preseason tour avoids Asia and North America, team sticking to Europe
- Drogba's drama key to ending Chelsea's quest for Champions League glory against Bayern Munich
- Winnipeg to host FIFA Women's World Cup
- Winnipeg eyed as host city for FIFA Women's World Cup
- Winnipeg a host city for 2015 Women's World Cup
- Possible Man United shift gives Kagawa another chance to make Asia's mark on Premier League
- Barcelona's 2012-13 preseason tour avoids Asia and North America, team sticking to Europe
- Neymar released from Brazil's squad for friendly against Denmark
- Bayern Munich's downfall could affect Germany's Euro plans
- Chelsea weighs changing a winning formula as Europe's new champion plans for future
- Fernando Torres says he's unhappy at Chelsea after not starting Champions League final
- Makeshift Spain squad to face Euro 2012 warmups without Barcelona, Chelsea or Bilbao players
- English FA bans QPR captain Barton for 12 matches for violent conduct in final match of season
- Nani bringing skills to Manitoba
- Winnipeg to host FIFA Women's World Cup
- Winnipeg eyed as host city for FIFA Women's World Cup
- Gale adds force to WSA Winnipeg
- FC Porto wins Portuguese league title after closest rival Benfica draws 2-2 at Rio Ave
- Vincent Kompany's header puts Man City top with 1-0 win over crosstown rival Man United
- City is the last Man standing
- Column: The pendulum has swung - City surpasses United as Manchester's team to watch
- Muamba makes emotional return to Bolton less than 7 weeks after on-field cardiac arrest
- Ajax wins 31st Dutch league championship in successful title defence after beating VVV-Venlo
- Turkish federation clears all 16 teams of charges of match-fixing
Ads by Google









You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010; View the changes. New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.