Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
By George, what a row
Treat CNN commentator's baby talk as time-filling nonsense
The chronicle of the royal family used to be part of the historical record. These days it's just another form of celebrity gossip.
But it's celebrity gossip determined to keep up its pedigree, generally taking a dignified, network-news approach to the House of Windsor, sometimes adding the high gloss of "constitutional significance." Commentators are usually polite, even posh.
Sure, things can get messy. (Oh, those younger sons and Nazi uniforms!) But there's an inclination to keep up the tone and tamp down the controversy, especially when it comes to royal life-cycle events. Even virulent anti-monarchists tend to go easy on the occasion of a regal birth. A baby is a baby, after all, and any talk of the royals as irrelevant, wasteful or representative of a hidebound class system can surely be sorted out later.
Amid all this garden-party decorum, it was fun to watch the social-media scrap that resulted over a stray comment by Victoria Arbiter, CNN's royal correspondent. An Englishwoman based in New York, Arbiter sent congrats to the Duchess of Cambridge, saying "how brilliant a royal Kate is" for delivering a baby boy.
After blithely raising the historical spectres of disgrace, divorce and beheading for queens who couldn't muster a male heir, Arbiter went on: "Kate did it first time."
Critics pounced on her as anti-girl. They denounced Arbiter's shaky grasp of math -- with a roughly 50-50 chance of a boy, this "achievement" isn't exactly unprecedented. And they went after her Henry VIII-like understanding of biology -- it was actually William's chromosomes that determined the baby's gender, even if Kate did the hard labour.
Arbiter seemed flummoxed by the controversy.
Partly, I think, media people were just relieved to have something to grab onto, after being driven into a tizzy of inane time-filling while waiting for reports of the royal infant. For journalists actually on the scene, the boredom of standing around staring at a pair of closed doors had driven them a bit nutty. (One reporter said that veterans of the so-called Great Kate Wait were "starting to sound like guys who've been in 'Nam too long.") The Internet commentators were getting desperate, too.
Arbiter -- who is on record as supporting the new gender-neutral laws of succession that mean that either a boy or a girl would have been equally in line for the throne -- gamely took on her detractors. She claimed that they had missed the irony, tweeting that it's "a Brit thing, lost in translation."
"You are obviously not well versed in the British use of brilliant and our tongue-in-cheek approach," she wrote to one. And it's true that in England the word "brilliant" doesn't mean super-smart. In fact, The Urban Dictionary defines brilliant as "a term the British use to describe everything." Everything!
Arbiter's claim for irony is harder to accept. Christopher Hitchens she ain't. In her bubbly CNN appearance, Arbiter doesn't seem remotely ironic. If her breathlessly earnest coverage of the royal wedding is anything to go by, she is perhaps the least ironic English person alive. She has taken to enthusiastic American gushing like a swan to water.
Arbiter's real talent is being able to elegantly stretch out a whole lot of nothing, padding a scarcity of hard information by saying things like "if indeed it did happen, it would make sense." She's the kind of commentator we're bound to end up with when royal coverage meets the 24-hour news cycle.
She's mostly blandly competent, except for this mesmerizing slip about Kate's miraculous boy-producing powers. After Arbiter's 36-second clip went viral, a Slate magazine headline queried: "Did CNN Just Lock Up the Award For Worst Royal Baby Commentary?"
Actually, I prefer Arbiter when she's screwing up. At least she gave us all something to talk about.
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition July 27, 2013 D12
Please use the form below and let us know.
Having problems with the form?Contact Us Directly
(1 of 19 articles for today)3:45 PM 0
LOS ANGELES, Calif. - Whoever snatched a seal or sea lion pup from a Los Angeles beach early Sunday should ...
Photo Store Gallery
- Rough times in Russia
- Video purports to show Islamic State militants killing captured Ethiopian Christians in Libya
- Canada's turn as Arctic Council head to end at Iqaluit meeting; Kerry takes over
- Caged puppies on car roof trigger flurry of 911 calls in Ohio, police take custody
- Fearful immigrants say South Africans warned they would target anyone with foreign passport
- Egypt court sentences 11 fans to death in 2012 soccer riot, in highly charged case
- California serial killer denied parole; man went on 9-day crime rampage, killing 4
- Sheriff: Cannot arrest woman who bragged on Facebook of killing cat unless photo is genuine
- Republicans disagree on foreign policy
- Man pleads guilty to charges related to 6-year-old daughter's severely rotten teeth
- Dispatcher seemed confused by 911 call: 'I'm inside a plane, and I feel like it's moving'
- Court releases video of 'Suge' Knight running over 2 men, other evidence in case
- As her 2016 campaign debuts, Republican presidential candidates already united against Clinton
- Couple killed with baby when concrete slab fell from overpass onto pickup were youth ministers
- 'Free-range' parenting under the gun
- Police again pick up children, 6 and 10, of 'free-range' parents, take kids to child services
- Milwaukee motorist shot, killed after van strikes child; teen brother of child also killed
- Physicians want Dr. Mehmet Oz gone from Columbia medical faculty, say he lacks integrity
- Driver who hit toddler in US street starts chain of events that leaves 4 people dead
- It wasn't the strippers, it was the noise that led to downfall of a Florida stripper school
- Alps plane crash cause remains mystery; report says audio shows 1 pilot locked out of cockpit
- German co-pilot locks cockpit, deliberately slams plane into Alps; investigators study why
- Co-pilot appeared healthy, but may have hidden illness, torn-up sick notes for day of crash
- Report says 1 pilot locked out of cockpit before crash that killed 150 people
- Al-Shabab gunmen kill 147 at university in Kenya; 4 attackers slain by troops to end siege
- Germanwings co-pilot researched suicide, cockpit doors before crash; France finds 2nd recorder
- German airline could face 'unlimited' damages for crash blamed on co-pilot
- Utility says it removed stolen electric meter from rental home where 8 died of gas poisoning
- Gunman in Kenyan massacre was government official's son, underscoring threat from within
- White SC police officer charged with murder in black man's death after dramatic video emerges
Ads by Google