12°c Rain showers
8°c Light rain
Winnipeg Free Press - PRINT EDITION
Grand Canyon older than believed?
May have been home to dinosaurs: study
Jake Bacon / The Associated Press archives Tourists visit the western end of the Grand Canyon. (CP)
LOS ANGELES -- The awe-inspiring Grand Canyon was probably carved about 70 million years ago, much earlier than thought, a provocative new study suggests -- so early dinosaurs might have roamed near this natural wonder.
Using a new dating tool, a team of scientists came up with a different age for the western section of the gorge in the U.S. southwest, challenging conventional wisdom much of the canyon was scoured by the mighty Colorado River in the last five million to six million years.
Not everyone is convinced with the latest viewpoint published online Thursday in the journal Science. Critics contend the study ignores a mountain of evidence pointing to a geologically young landscape and they have doubts about the technique used to date it.
The notion the Grand Canyon existed during the dinosaur era is "ludicrous," said geologist Karl Karlstrom of the University of New Mexico in Albuquerque.
How the Grand Canyon became grand -- with its vertical cliffs and flat plateaus -- has been debated since John Wesley Powell navigated the whitewater rapids and scouted the sheer walls during his famous 1869 expedition.
Some five million tourists flock to Arizona each year to marvel at the 445-kilometre-long chasm, which plunges 1.6 km deep in some places. It's a geologic layer cake with the most recent rock formations near the rim stacked on top of older rocks that date back two billion years.
Though the exposed rocks are ancient, most scientists believe the Grand Canyon itself was forged in the recent geologic past, created when tectonic forces uplifted the land the Colorado River later carved through.
The new work by researchers at the University of Colorado Boulder and California Institute of Technology argue canyon-cutting occurred long before that.
They focused on the western end of the Grand Canyon occupied today by the Hualapai Reservation, which owns the Skywalk attraction, a horseshoe-shaped glass bridge that extends from the canyon's edge.
To come up with the age, the team crushed rocks collected from the bottom of the canyon to analyze a rare type of mineral called apatite. The mineral contains traces of radioactive elements that release helium during decay, allowing researchers to calculate the passage of time since the canyon eroded.
Their interpretation: The western Grand Canyon is 70 million years old and was likely shaped by an ancient river that coursed in the opposite direction of the west-flowing Colorado.
Lead researcher Rebecca Flowers of the University of Colorado Boulder realizes not everyone will accept this alternative view, which minimizes the role of the Colorado River.
"Arguments will continue over the age of the Grand Canyon, and I hope our study will stimulate more work to decipher the mysteries," Flowers said in an email.
It's not the first time Flowers has dug up evidence for an older Grand Canyon.
In 2008, she authored a study that suggested part of the eastern Grand Canyon, where most tourists go, formed 55 million years ago. Another study published that same year by a different group of researchers put the age of the western section at 17 million years old.
If the Grand Canyon truly existed before dinosaurs became extinct, it would have looked vastly different because the climate back then was more tropical. Dinosaurs that patrolled the American West then included smaller tyrannosaurs, horned and dome-headed dinosaurs and duckbills.
-- The Associated Press
Republished from the Winnipeg Free Press print edition November 30, 2012 A21
More World
- Back to Top
- Return to World
More World
(1 of 7 articles for today)
South Africa's father figure: As frail Mandela fades, his image is still in political fray
11:06 AM 0JOHANNESBURG - Nelson Mandela, old and frail, lives in seclusion in his Johannesburg home. Beyond the high walls of the ...
Poll
Most Popular World
- Phone cracked? Cool
- Swarm of tornadoes slam central US; 2 dead in Oklahoma mobile home park ravaged by twister
- Small Florida city wonders who hit historic $590.5M Powerball lottery jackpot
- Thousands of military sex abuse victims seek disability, health care after leaving service
- Umbrella-gate stirs outrage
- SKorea analyzing if 4 projectiles North Korea launched were missiles or artillery
- Suspect in NYC bias shooting appears in court, charged with murder as a hate crime
- US zoo looking into conception mystery after birth of anteater; no male in pen
- Gay man killed on street in New York
- Canadian Press NewsAlert: Up to 60 injured in Virginia parade crash
- Black bear wanders into LA-area suburbia, chases swimmers from pool, strands kids in class
- US woman credits 'mother's instincts' in chase of 4-year-old daughter's abductor
- Phone cracked? Cool
- Celebrities react to Angelina Jolie's revelation of double mastectomy
- Remote Alaska volcano continues to erupt, with lava fountains, ash plumes
- Swarm of tornadoes slam central US; 2 dead in Oklahoma mobile home park ravaged by twister
- Jurors find Jodi Arias eligible for death penalty after murder conviction in boyfriend killing
- Boston Marathon runners who couldn't finish because of blasts can return in 2014
- Umbrella-gate stirs outrage
- Co-counsel: OJ Simpson became dependent on main defence attorney in robbery case
- Amanda Berry, 1 of 3 women freed after held captive in Ohio home, arrives at sister's home
- Friendship with bomb suspect, complex chain of events leads to 3 being charged
- Police vow to solve shooting that wounded 19 people during Mother's Day parade in New Orleans
- Missing Pa. woman, last seen dropping off kids for school in 2002, surfaces in Fla.
- As Boston mourns, suspected brothers' radicalism comes into focus
- Cleveland police: Ohio captive suffered 5 miscarriages after being beaten and starved
- Jodi Arias convicted of first-degree murder, says she prefers death penalty
- Boston Marathon bombing suspect hospitalized under heavy guard; Boston area breathes easier
- Neighbours: Man in custody comforted missing girl's mom, helped search for missing US women
- Parents of Boston suspect say he travelled to Russia to visit relatives, sleep a lot
- Black bear wanders into LA-area suburbia, chases swimmers from pool, strands kids in class
- Phone cracked? Cool
- Man charged after overnight feast in closed Kentucky supermarket
- Celebrities react to Angelina Jolie's revelation of double mastectomy
- Lawyer: Saudi man travelling with pressure cooker didn't know device used in Boston bombings
- Hatchet-wielding hitchhiker who intervened in California attack arrested in NJ homicide
- Remote Alaska volcano continues to erupt, with lava fountains, ash plumes
- Shady characters: Cookie Monster, Elmo accused of aggressive behaviour in Times Square
- 'Ring of fire' eclipse a delight Down Under
- Highly flammable gas acetylene explodes at W.Va. distributor; 2 workers injured
- 'Coronation Street' actor William Roache charged in UK over alleged rapes in 1967
- Coroner: 5-year-old boy shoots 2-year-old sister in US with rifle he got as a gift
- Hitler ate well, his food taster recalls
- Black bear wanders into LA-area suburbia, chases swimmers from pool, strands kids in class
- As killings for ivory grow, many Tanzanians see official hands in elephant slaughter
- Female guards, rapidly growing in numbers, at heart of U.S. prison scandal
- Boston Marathon bombing suspect hospitalized under heavy guard; Boston area breathes easier
- Bill to alter rules of succession before Kate gives birth nears completion as Lords approve
- US tourists swim for nearly 14 hours after boat sinks near St. Lucia
- IBM makes movie about a little boy - a very little boy - by pushing molecules around
Ads by Google
You can comment on most stories on winnipegfreepress.com. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is register and/or login and you can join the conversation and give your feedback.
Have Your Say
New to commenting? Check out our Frequently Asked Questions.
The Winnipeg Free Press does not necessarily endorse any of the views posted. By submitting your comment, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. These terms were revised effective April 16, 2010.