Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 3/10/2009 (3765 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.
DAVID Asper's real estate company, Creswin Properties, and taxpayers could be asked to pony up money to maintain an aging Canad Inns Stadium if it takes longer than expected to conclude a deal to build a new home for the Winnipeg Blue Bombers.
Winnipeg Football Club board chairman Ken Hildahl said $150,000 to $200,000 is spent every year to conduct routine mechanical, electrical and structural maintenance at Canad Inns Stadium, which the club considers obsolete.
In essence, every year the Bombers continue to play out of the existing facility, that cash is subtracted from the club's bottom line.
But if Creswin requires several more years to find enough tenants at its proposed Polo Park retail development — a 650,000-square-foot "upscale shopping destination" called The Elms — the repair tab for Canad Inns Stadium will rise into the millions.
"That's a discussion the board will have if we get into extraordinary delays," Hildahl said Friday.
"We've given Creswin another year. But if it were to continue a lot longer, we'd want to look at that."
Hildahl said governments would also be approached for cash in such a scenario.
Creswin Properties said Thursday it had been given another year to assemble the Polo Park retail project that will help finance a $135-million stadium and recreation project at the University of Manitoba.
A substantial investment into the building will be required as soon as 2012 and no later than 2015, Hildahl said.
Estimates for extending the stadium's lifespan for a decade or two have ranged from $8.9 million, according to the Tower Report in 2004, to above $40 million, according to Bombers president Lyle Bauer in 2008.
Right now, Creswin's most optimistic projection about its stadium-building project calls for the Bombers to continue playing at Canad Inns Stadium through the 2011 Canadian Football League season.
"We don't expect the deal to drag on extraordinarily. We have just been granted a year's extension and anticipate the project proceeding within that time frame," a Creswin spokeswoman said in a statement.
Winnipeg retail, finance and real estate industry observers are skeptical about Asper's chances to meet that deadline, even as they wish the highprofile lawyer and businessman luck. But politicians have more to lose and are putting on a brave face.
A spokesman for Premier Gary Doer said any discussion about funding repairs or upgrades at Canad Inns Stadium is premature. The prospect of Creswin failing to meet a September 2010 retail-assembly deadline is merely a hypothetical situation, the spokesman said.
"If Asper succeeds, everybody should be dancing in the street. If he doesn't succeed, it won't be a pretty picture," Winnipeg Mayor Sam Katz added.
City council would be reluctant to contribute cash for stadium repairs upgrades or repairs, said the mayor, noting Winnipeg has already turned over all Canad Inns Stadium concession, parking, naming and entertainmenttax revenues to the Winnipeg Football Club and has also charged the team $1 for a 75-year lease on the facility.
"At some point in time, you have to determine what your long-term plan is. If there is an opportunity to build a new stadium, that's your plan and you don't want to flush good money down the toilet," Katz said.
The Winnipeg Football Club has not considered working with a stadiumbuilding partner other than Creswin since 2008, when it chose Asper's realestate company over the Canad Inns hotel chain.
Canad Inns wanted to build a stadium on land it owns in St. Boniface. Officials with the chain did not respond to queries about its continued interest in the stadium project.
THE cost of maintaining Canad Inns Stadium and building a replacement, according to the Winnipeg Football Club and its future owner:
$150,000 to $200,000
Money spent by the Winnipeg Football Club on maintenance to Canad Inns Stadium every year, according to board chairman Ken Hildahl.
About $20 million
Cost of mechanical, electrical and structural repairs required to keep the stadium open for another two decades, according to Winnipeg Blue Bombers president Lyle Bauer in 2007.
Above $40 million
Cost of those same repairs according to Bauer in 2008, factoring in construction inflation and plumbing issues he was not aware of the previous year.
"Close to the cost of a new building."
Cost of conducting mechanical, electrical and structural repairs as well as improving fan amenities such as washrooms and concessions, according to Bauer.
Cost of safety improvements to Canad Inns Stadium that could result from ongoing inquest into the 2006 death of an intoxicated fan who fell from the stands.
Cost of Creswin Properties' proposal to build a new stadium and conduct recreational upgrades at the University of Manitoba, according to David Asper in April 2009.