July 14, 2020

Winnipeg
20° C, Thunder

Full Forecast

Close this
Winnipeg Free Press

ABOVE THE FOLD

Subscribe

As a Hydro-MMF deal analyst, Smyth makes a pretty good police chief

Opinion

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 25/9/2019 (293 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

Winnipeg police Chief Danny Smyth got in a little over his head during a speech at the Manitoba Metis Federation’s annual general assembly over the weekend.

Smyth was commenting on a proposed $67.5-million payout by Manitoba Hydro to the MMF, which was rejected by Premier Brian Pallister last year. He called Pallister’s decision "arbitrary" and lamented that the issue had to go to court.

Smyth was clearly out of his element on this one.

"It’s unfortunate that the courts will be asked to determine whether this was a binding agreement or not," Smyth said in a video recording of his speech, obtained by the Free Press.

The police chief went on to say the Pallister government’s decision not to approve the payout didn’t "exactly scream inclusion" with Indigenous people. He said the decision left him wondering "if people have really grasped the lessons of our shared history."

This isn’t exactly Smyth’s area of expertise. He’s a good police chief. He strikes the right balance between law enforcement and crime prevention. But his comments clearly show he knows little about this file. It’s odd he would comment on it in his official capacity as police chief.

The controversial $67.5-million payout to the MMF was never a done deal. The chairman of Manitoba Hydro at the time, Sandy Riley, made that clear last year.

Winnipeg police Chief Danny Smyth said it was unfortunate the courts had to determine whether the deal between Hydro and the MMF was a binding agreement. (Mikaela MacKenzie / Winnipeg Free Press files)

Winnipeg police Chief Danny Smyth said it was unfortunate the courts had to determine whether the deal between Hydro and the MMF was a binding agreement. (Mikaela MacKenzie / Winnipeg Free Press files)

He said the proposed payout was unlike any Hydro had negotiated with Indigenous groups in the past and that the Crown corporation knew it had to take it to the province for approval.

"We knew it was precedent setting, and we knew it was different than the other agreements that we had done," Riley said at the time. "We wanted to discuss it with (the provincial government) and explain to them why we thought it was a good deal and make sure that they were comfortable with it."

The provincial government wasn’t comfortable with it. So they nixed it.

The payout was made up of a $37-million trust fund and annual payments over 50 years. In exchange for the money, the MMF agreed not to challenge future Hydro projects, either in court or during the licensing-approval process.

Former Manitoba Hydro chairman Sandy Riley helped negotiate the deal with the MMF. (Boris Minkevich / Winnipeg Free Press files)

Former Manitoba Hydro chairman Sandy Riley helped negotiate the deal with the MMF. (Boris Minkevich / Winnipeg Free Press files)

Riley called it buying "peace in the valley for 50 years" and said it was a "very attractive price" to avoid costly challenges by the MMF in the future.

But it wasn’t a done deal until the province signed off on it, he said.

Pallister chose some unfortunate words — as he often does — to describe the proposed payout, calling it "hush money" and "persuasion money." His abrasive and confrontational style often rub people the wrong way. His choice of words are sometimes not becoming of a premier.

But his decision was the right one. This wasn’t compensation to the MMF for specific Hydro projects that may have infringed on their hunting or other rights. This was blanket protection for Hydro against future projects, including unidentified ones.

The Supreme Court of Canada has made it clear that while governments and their agencies have a legal duty to consult with First Nations and other Indigenous groups on resource projects, it has to be related to specific projects. It can’t be based on a speculative impact.

Premier Brian Pallister didn't like the deal and cancelled it. (John Woods / Canadian Press files)

Premier Brian Pallister didn't like the deal and cancelled it. (John Woods / Canadian Press files)

The MMF and the Pallister government disagree on the outcome of this issue. As a result, the MMF is going to court to seek relief, which is its right. The organization goes to court often. Sometimes it wins and sometimes it loses.

There’s nothing wrong with taking legal action to resolve an issue, as Smyth alleges. Indeed, it is through court decisions that we gain clarity on governments’ constitutional duty to consult.

This file could have been handled better by the premier. There should have been face-to-face communication with the former Hydro board (which resigned en masse following the MMF conflict) on this and many other issues.

But Riley said he didn’t resign because of the MMF issue alone. He called those suggestions "a smokescreen." He said it was because Pallister refused to meet with him and the board on a number of issues, including on the financial crisis facing Hydro.

Smyth has a right to his opinion. But he’s woefully misinformed on this one.

tom.brodbeck@freepress.mb.ca

 


 

Winnipeg police chief takes shot at province in Hydro-MMF case

MMF president David Chartrand called Smyth's speech insightful.
MMF president David Chartrand called Smyth's speech insightful.

Posted: 24/09/2019 7:00 PM

Winnipeg's top cop has weighed in on a bitter dispute between the Manitoba Metis Federation and the provincial government led by Brian Pallister, describing the province's actions as "arbitrary."

In a speech to the MMF annual general assembly over the weekend, Winnipeg Police Service Chief Danny Smyth delivered a stinging rebuke of the premier's confrontational style, without once mentioning him by name.

Read Full Story

Tom Brodbeck

Tom Brodbeck
Columnist

Tom has been covering Manitoba politics since the early 1990s and joined the Winnipeg Free Press news team in 2019.

Read full biography

The Winnipeg Free Press invites you to share your opinion on this story in a letter to the editor. A selection of letters to the editor are published daily.

To submit a letter:
• fill out the form on this page, or
• email letters@freepress.mb.ca, or
• mail Letters to the Editor, 1355 Mountain Avenue, Winnipeg, Manitoba, R2X 3B6.

Letters must include the writer’s full name, address, and a daytime phone number. Letters are edited for length and clarity.