August 11, 2020

26° C, Fair

Full Forecast

Close this


Advertise With Us


The Dene: from Little Duck to Tadoule

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 25/8/2016 (1447 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

The Hon. Carolyn Bennett, minister of Indigenous and Northern Affairs, deserves kudos for her effective role in providing the Dene the opportunity to take greater control of their lives after many years of suffering because of ignorance on the part of many governments.

An excellent article, Addressing the fatal ordeal of the Dene by Alexandra Paul, appeared in the Aug. 13 Winnipeg Free Press. It brought back memories, not all of which were pleasant.

JIM COLLINSON PHOTO</p><p>A polar bear scrounges for food at the Churchill dump in 1967. To the left, unseen, a Dene is doing the same thing, but with a fire in an old fuel drum to warm it up.</p></p>


A polar bear scrounges for food at the Churchill dump in 1967. To the left, unseen, a Dene is doing the same thing, but with a fire in an old fuel drum to warm it up.

The apology by the government of Canada, along with compensation for the Dene’s forced move to Churchill, establishes a recognition point for the Dene to be in greater control of their future — something that was eliminated from their lives one fateful day in 1956.

In the scene shown in the accompanying photo, just to the left of the bear, was a Dene man. He, too, was searching for food. The only difference was he had a barrel with a fire in it and a metal plate on the top so he could heat up his food.

The Dene and the bear were only about 25 feet apart, but they seemed to ignore each other quite effectively.

At one point, I was about to take a picture that included both the bear and the Dene, but that struck me as inappropriate. Although both were searching for food, the bear knew that once the bay froze over he would be fine. The Dene was not in that position: he had been moved from Little Duck Lake, just south of the much larger Nejanilini Lake. His skills were suited for living within a caribou range, not the barrens near Churchill.

Trying his best to seek food, he shared an open dump with a polar bear that would soon head off for a winter of great food. He, on the other hand, had a proud but fading past, with nothing to look forward to.

Eleven years prior, he was one of those scooped up at Little Duck Lake by a Canso amphibious cargo plane and dropped off in Churchill. There, he and his family and friends were expected to adapt — virtually without help. Just because the caribou that year had been diverted, possibly by a fire in the lichen to the north, an entire community was taken from its home and deposited into an unfamiliar setting. That the Dene caused any drop in caribou numbers is, quite simply, a lie.

In 1971, I landed with some colleagues on Little Duck Lake and walked into the old community. In an eerie way, it felt as if everyone would be coming back. We didn’t look too closely, as it seemed they might show up at any time.

Most homes we peeked into had good dinnerware set up on the table, as if the meal had been about to be served when the infamous Canso arrived to take them away to Churchill. Many of the homes had small gramophones and 78 r.p.m. records, not all that different than what I remember growing up in the Souris area in the 1940s.

Their coal-oil lamps were no different — quite elaborate, in fact. Clearly, the residents of Little Duck Lake had lived a rounded and relatively comfortable life until it was shattered by a huge mistake.

We left their homes and contents intact, hoping one day they would be back.


Jim Collinson is a management consultant specializing in energy, economic, and environmental issues who has held assistant deputy minister positions in the federal and Manitoba governments.


Advertise With Us

The Winnipeg Free Press invites you to share your opinion on this story in a letter to the editor. A selection of letters to the editor are published daily.

To submit a letter:
• fill out the form on this page, or
• email, or
• mail Letters to the Editor, 1355 Mountain Avenue, Winnipeg, Manitoba, R2X 3B6.

Letters must include the writer’s full name, address, and a daytime phone number. Letters are edited for length and clarity.


Advertise With Us