October 19, 2019

Winnipeg
9° C, Partly cloudy

Full Forecast

Rise of paramedicine means city only needs three ERs

Opinion

The number of patients treated on scene by Winnipeg paramedics, and not taken to hospital, has soared in recent years. It’s one of the main reasons we no longer need full-service emergency departments in every part of the city.

From 2013 to 2017, the number of patients assessed or treated on scene has increased 57 per cent, to 25,716 from 16,366, the City of Winnipeg’s most recent data show. During the same period, the number of patients taken to hospital by paramedics has grown by only 11 per cent.

Paramedicine has become the new health care on wheels. In a growing number of cases, paramedics are able to assess and treat patients on the spot without having to take them to a hospital.

The number of patients treated on scene by Winnipeg paramedics, and not taken to hospital, has soared in recent years. It’s one of the main reasons we no longer need full-service emergency departments in every part of the city.

From 2013 to 2017, the number of patients assessed or treated on scene has increased 57 per cent, to 25,716 from 16,366, the City of Winnipeg’s most recent data show. During the same period, the number of patients taken to hospital by paramedics has grown by only 11 per cent.

Paramedicine has become the new health care on wheels. In a growing number of cases, paramedics are able to assess and treat patients on the spot without having to take them to a hospital.

 

It also means paramedics — particularly advanced-care paramedics, who undergo greater medical training than primary-care paramedics – can more effectively assess and stabilize patients on scene before taking them to a hospital. They can save a life right away.

The number of ambulances staffed with advanced-care paramedics is growing, too; it stands at 77 per cent. Supervisors are also licensed as advanced-care paramedics.

That’s a game changer. It’s why health officials continually advise the public that if they have a medical emergency, especially a life-threatening one, to call 911. It’s the best and fastest way for people to get medical care in those circumstances.

The most important part of the emergency response to the carbon monoxide leak at the Super 8 hotel on Portage Avenue Tuesday was how quickly firefighters and paramedics arrived on scene, took control of the situation and immediately assessed and treated patients.

RUTH BONNEVILLE / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS

The most important part of the emergency response to the carbon monoxide leak at the Super 8 hotel on Portage Avenue Tuesday was how quickly firefighters and paramedics arrived on scene, took control of the situation and immediately assessed and treated patients.

The carbon monoxide leak at the Super 8 hotel on Portage Avenue Tuesday was a prime example. The most important part of the emergency response was how quickly firefighters and paramedics arrived on scene, took control of the situation and immediately assessed and treated patients. Those patients were later taken to one of four hospitals.

The proximity to those hospitals was less important than the speed with which emergency personnel arrived on scene and provided pre-hospital care.

That’s true for most medical emergencies. For people suffering a heart attack at home, for example, the recommendation is to call 911 to get medical care as quickly as possible. Once stabilized, if the patient requires hospitalization, they will likely be taken to St. Boniface Hospital, which specializes in cardiac care, no matter where they live in the city.

City of Winnipeg statistics show the longest wait time for an ambulance for nine out of 10 patients is just over eight minutes. Most people would be hard-pressed to get a friend or family member to an ER, or an urgent care centre, that fast on their own. Even if they did, they wouldn’t necessarily get the immediate medical attention they would from a paramedic on scene.

It’s one of the reasons the Pallister government cut ambulance fees in half to $250: to make the service more accessible and to encourage more people to use it. It’s $219 for treatment but no transport. They should do something to lower that, too.

Officially beginning July 22, ambulances will transport low-acuity patients to one of three urgent care centres in the city: Victoria Hospital, Seven Oaks Hospital or Concordia Hospital (pictured).

SASHA SEFTER / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS

Officially beginning July 22, ambulances will transport low-acuity patients to one of three urgent care centres in the city: Victoria Hospital, Seven Oaks Hospital or Concordia Hospital (pictured).

It’s also why the province is consolidating acute-care hospital services at three facilities in Winnipeg, down from six. With advances in paramedicine, the city doesn’t need six acute care hospitals, each with its own emergency department. It makes more sense to pool those resources at three facilities, including specialty services and diagnostic testing.

Under the new model, when ambulances do transport very sick patients to an acute care facility, there’s a better chance the medical services they need will be there (and a costly, time-consuming transfer to another facility can be avoided).

Ambulances will still transport low-acuity patients to one of three urgent care centres in the city, namely Victoria Hospital, Concordia Hospital and Seven Oaks Hospital (as of July 22). But higher-acuity patients will more consistently go to St. Boniface Hospital, Health Sciences Centre and Grace Hospital.

The challenge has been the implementation of the hospital reorganization plan. It hasn’t gone well. The required resources at the three acute care hospitals to handle the influx of high-acuity patients is still not in place, and likely won’t be when Seven Oaks converts its ER to an urgent care centre. That still requires work.

But whether there’s an emergency department five minutes or 20 minutes away matters far less today than it did in the past. The most important thing now is access to a phone. It can be the difference between life and death.

tom.brodbeck@freepress.mb.ca

Tom Brodbeck

Tom Brodbeck
Columnist

Tom has been covering Manitoba politics since the early 1990s and joined the Winnipeg Free Press news team in 2019.

Read full biography

History

Updated on Thursday, July 11, 2019 at 9:38 AM CDT: Adds missing word

You can comment on most stories on The Winnipeg Free Press website. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or digital subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.

Have Your Say

Have Your Say

Comments are open to The Winnipeg Free Press print or digital subscribers only. why?

Have Your Say

Comments are open to The Winnipeg Free Press Subscribers only. why?

By submitting your comment, you agree to abide by our Community Standards and Moderation Policy. These guidelines were revised effective February 27, 2019. Have a question about our comment forum? Check our frequently asked questions.