February 22, 2020

Winnipeg
-1° C, A few clouds

Full Forecast

Winnipeg Free Press

ABOVE THE FOLD

When it comes to guzzling gas, we're No. 1

Editorial

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 14/5/2019 (283 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

Before Manitobans complain about the carbon-fuel tax that in April increased the price at the pumps by 4.4 per cent a litre, perhaps it's helpful to take a global view.

Canadians have the dubious distinction of topping the worldwide rankings for largest vehicles, highest average fuel consumption and highest carbon dioxide emissions per kilometre driven, according to a recent report from the International Energy Agency, titled Fuel Economy in Major Car Markets.

On a planet that should be desperate to cut carbon dioxide emissions, these are categories in which Canadians should apologize for being No. 1.

The fact that a disproportionally large number of Canadians choose to drive gas guzzlers won't surprise people who have travelled to places like Europe or Asia, or seen video footage of traffic in those regions. Roads there are dominated by small, light vehicles that are fuel efficient.

Canadians love SUVs and pickup trucks. (John Bazemore / The Associated Press files)

Canadians love SUVs and pickup trucks. (John Bazemore / The Associated Press files)

By comparison, the typical Canadian parking lot tends to be filled with SUVs and pickup trucks. More than any other country, Canadian drivers like to sit high, roar along the roads with engines that have plenty of power, and surround themselves with metal chassis that are protectively heavy.

Winnipeggers who drive large personal vehicles might explain their choice by pointing to the disrepair of city streets — whether it's iced ruts in the winter, or potholes after the snow goes, larger vehicles are better able to cope with the jolts and jars that are routine hazards of driving on this city's crumbling pavement.

A second reason commonly offered is personal safety. Drivers of large vehicles point to repeated studies that show when vehicles collide, size matters. In crashes between a heavy vehicle and a lighter one, the worst damage is usually sustained by the smaller vehicle and its occupants.

As common as these explanations may be, the bigger reason why Canadians drive SUVs and pick-up trucks is that they can afford to. People in other countries who want to drive large vehicles are discouraged by a double whammy of expensive vehicle registration and high gas prices.

In European countries, for example, governments use different rates of registration as a tool of social engineering to push vehicle consumers to think small. For instance, registration charges for high-emitting vehicles can be as high as CDN$15,000, while owners who choose zero-emission vehicles can get a rebate of up to $9,000.

As long gas is relatively inexpensive and registration fees are relatively low, Canadians will continue to buy big vehicles that burn an unconscionable amount of fossil fuel. (Jonathan Hayward / The Canadian Press files)

As long gas is relatively inexpensive and registration fees are relatively low, Canadians will continue to buy big vehicles that burn an unconscionable amount of fossil fuel. (Jonathan Hayward / The Canadian Press files)

If that's not enough, the price at the pumps adds another disincentive. For example, here are some current gas prices per litre, in Canadian dollars: United Kingdom, $2.24; Switzerland, $2.46; Greece, $2.28; Norway, $2.49; Japan, $2.36.

By comparison, the Manitoba pumps are at about $1.20 this week, even with the new carbon tax that sparked so much bellyaching.

The discouraging reality is that as long as gas is relatively inexpensive, as long as registration fees are relatively low, we Canadians will continue to encase ourselves in big vehicles that burn an unconscionable amount of fossil fuel.

In related news, data from the Mauna Loa Observatory in Hawaii on Monday recorded atmospheric carbon dioxide levels at 415.26 parts per million (ppm), the highest in human history. And last week, a published report warned that nearly one million species were at risk of extinction thanks to the carbon emissions released as a result of human economy activity.

Canadians can hear such grim news and say, "That's terrible; somebody ought to do something." Or we can look at our reflection in the rear-view mirrors of our trucks and SUVs.

Editorials are the consensus view of the Winnipeg Free Press’ editorial board.

Special Notice: A widespread problem is occurring with our commenting platform; many readers are not able to see comments or submit them. We have notified spot.im, the company that provides the commenting platform, about the outage and await a solution.