April 3, 2020

-8° C, A few clouds

Full Forecast

Winnipeg Free Press


Rural-urban split weighs heavily in Manitoba election

Hey there, time traveller!
This article was published 30/8/2019 (216 days ago), so information in it may no longer be current.

There are 57 seats up for grabs in the 2019 Manitoba provincial election, but voters can be forgiven for mistakenly concluding there is only one: Winnipeg.

Since the writ dropped Aug. 12, the three main political parties have been holding news conference nearly every day somewhere in the capital city. Outside the Perimeter Highway, announcements have been few and far between, with leaders' visits to rural areas quietly under the radar.

It's common for major urban centres to dominate election campaigns, however, in no other province does a single city wield more electoral heft than Winnipeg.

"Winnipeg really is the battleground," said Christopher Adams, an adjunct professor in political studies at the University of Manitoba. "There's no province with as much focus on one city as Manitoba."

In the 2019 election, rural Manitoba is literally on the outside of the Perimeter looking in.

The city didn't always hold this much political clout.

When the province was founded in 1870, there were 22 ridings, of which, Winnipeg-proper held two. By the 1950s, rural ridings still outnumbered those in Winnipeg by a 2-1 ratio, a sign of that era's farm and agriculture-oriented politics.

Today, there are 32 seats in Winnipeg, which gained one in a recent redrawing of electoral boundaries.

The current political map reflects a-urban migration that has taken place over the past decades; in 2019, population estimates show about 61.5 per cent of Manitobans live in the Winnipeg Central Metropolitan Area. In the early 1970s, only half of the province's population called Winnipeg home.

An advance voting station for the Union Station electoral district.


An advance voting station for the Union Station electoral district.

The shift of power is not lost on Bill Campbell, president of Keystone Agricultural Producers.

Campbell says he's been disappointed by the lack of discussion of agriculture concerns thus far in the campaign. KAP's pre-election questionnaire has only been returned by the Greens and the NDP, he says, but overall, "We haven't had very good engagement with the political parties."

"I would have to say the rural engagement is the lowest I have seen in a long time," says Campbell, 64.

Even Brandon, the province's second-largest city, with a population of 50,000, has struggled to factor in the political conversation. A debate to be hosted by the Brandon Sun and Brandon Chamber of Commerce was cancelled last week when Progressive Conservative Leader Brian Pallister declined to participate.

Brandon University political science Prof. Kelly Saunders says relatively stable rural voting patterns (tendencies to vote PC in the south, NDP in the north), leaves the city's ridings for the parties to fight over, which helps explain why the bulk of campaign announcements are made in, and largely about, Winnipeg.

"It's a strategic decision," Saunders says. "We see the same thing at the federal level, where leaders spend an inordinate amount of time in Ontario and Quebec. It all comes down to numbers, and it's the same thing at the provincial level."

"It's just logic," agrees Andrea Perrella, a political science professor at Wilfrid Laurier University in Waterloo, Ont. "It's one of the disadvantages of our current electoral system. Sometimes, it gives parties little incentive to pay attention to (rural) ridings."

The fact the Tories and NDP are in a statistical dead heat in Winnipeg only heightens that focus. According to a Winnipeg Free Press/CTV Winnipeg News poll conducted by Probe Research and released Friday, the PCs have 33 per cent of the city's support, only one per cent ahead of the NDP. Outside the Perimeter, the Conservatives hold 51 per cent to the NDP's 24.

Bill Ashton, director of Brandon University's Rural Development Institute, says there is a political risk of treating rural Manitoba as a single entity. "There are different types of rural."

There are metropolitan rural communities, which lie on the periphery of Winnipeg and whose residents frequently commute between the two; northern and remote rural communities; and agricultural or southern rural communities. Each type has its own concerns — from labour shortages, to agrobusiness, to broadband access — which Ashton says must be reflected by candidates.

Brandon candidates take part in a Disability Matters Town Hall Forum at Rotary Villas at Crocus gardens on Aug. 27.


Brandon candidates take part in a Disability Matters Town Hall Forum at Rotary Villas at Crocus gardens on Aug. 27.

So far, Ashton says these issues have remained an "untapped opportunity" to bring in rural voters.

In Thompson, Mayor Colleen Smook says her city has been visited by Pallister, Liberal Leader Dougald Lamont and NDP Leader Wab Kinew. Smook's main concerns include a need for a community mental health officer, increased support for the mining industry, and improved hospital facilities.

Rural communities face similar struggles to urban ones, Saunders says. In Winnipeg, concerns like those in Thompson are important, but in smaller, more remote places, they can make or break an entire community.

"There's not a lot of wiggle-room out here," she says.

Each of the parties have made a number of promises to alleviate those stresses — namely the Liberals' $1.6-billion northern infrastructure plan, the NDP's pledge to increase hospital funding, and a PC promise to establish a $20-million mineral development fund — and Smook said she's optimistic they'll turn into action when ballots are cast and counted.

While places such as Thompson and Flin Flon get decent politician foot traffic, small, remote communities are rarely key factors in elections, even if they have significant needs.

Bill Reimer, a Concordia University professor who studies rural Canada, says this can be attributed to a few reasons: the changing, increasingly urban media industry means announcements in and related to rural communities don't stimulate much conversation; the demographic concentration in urban centres leads to policy being developed according to an urban focus; and the geographic isolation of rural communities means it's more expensive for politicians to visit.

The Montreal-based researcher doesn't think a rural-urban divide is as prominent as it might seem, and contends there's an interdependence between both types of communities.

But in this election, Winnipeg has become the undisputable focal point.

"It's just the mathematics of winning government," says Adams.


Ben Waldman

Ben Waldman

Ben Waldman covers a little bit of everything for the Free Press.

Read full biography


Updated on Friday, August 30, 2019 at 9:16 PM CDT: Fixes typo.

August 31, 2019 at 9:05 AM: Fixes quote attribution

11:38 AM: Clarifies reference to CTV Winnipeg News

The Free Press would like to thank our readers for their patience while comments were not available on our site. We're continuing to work with our commenting software provider on issues with the platform. In the meantime, if you're not able to see comments after logging in to our site, please try refreshing the page.

You can comment on most stories on The Winnipeg Free Press website. You can also agree or disagree with other comments. All you need to do is be a Winnipeg Free Press print or digital subscriber to join the conversation and give your feedback.

Have Your Say

Have Your Say

Comments are open to The Winnipeg Free Press print or digital subscribers only. why?

Have Your Say

Comments are open to The Winnipeg Free Press Subscribers only. why?

By submitting your comment, you agree to abide by our Community Standards and Moderation Policy. These guidelines were revised effective February 27, 2019. Have a question about our comment forum? Check our frequently asked questions.