Biidaajimowin
Winnipeg Free Press Logo
 

Hate, and how we address it

I’ve been thinking about hate lately.

It’s probably because I am writing my next book on love — but it also could be the rise of hate crimes in this country, the situation in the United States, or even the rise in conflicts globally.

Hate is often considered to be a noun; a thing, rather than a verb, an action. Take, for example, this dictionary definition which defines hate as “an intense hostility and aversion usually deriving from fear, anger or sense of injury.”

The focus is on the “hostility and aversion” rather than where hate comes from; a belief, idea, or perspective.

If hate is identified as a noun, it can be identified, banned, and even criminalized — but the reasons for the hate to be are never dealt with when this happens.

In fact, hate often becomes worse as a result.

What if we thought of hate as something much more than a noun but something valuable, instructive, and inspiring?

In my culture, there isn’t really a word for hate. The verb “zhiingenim” is probably the closest, but that words really means “to dislike” or “to disapprove.”

The stem “zhii” is fascinating. It’s a word we use to describe a vibrating sound of things rapidly hitting one another, like stones in a traditional rattle.

This is why we use the word “zhiishiigwan” for a shaker we use while singing or “zhiishigwe,” the name for a rattlesnake (referring to the sound its tail makes) or “zhiishiib,” the name for a duck (describing its quack, or how air travels through its syrinx and causes membranes to vibrate).

In other words, in the Ojibwa language, hate is considered to be not something that you are but something that inspires dislike or disapproval — like shaking your head or questioning your values.

Hate is not something to eradicate but something to be reflected upon; an inspiration for motion, vibration and the creation of sounds.

Hate has a place in the world; it’s just we have to think about what its cause is and learn from it, rather than try to erase it and its outcomes.

 

Niigaan Sinclair, Columnist

 

Advertisement

 

FIVE STORIES ON TURTLE ISLAND

This week the province of Manitoba will open a new 20-suite detox centre in South Point Douglas that is being called a “different approach” to dealing with addiction by Housing, said Housing, Addictions and Homelessness Minister Bernadette Smith.

Operated by Main Street Project, the centre follows up the province’s somewhat controversial Protective Detention and Care of Intoxicated Persons Act, which was passed on Nov. 6.

It’s well known Indigenous addictions on reserves and in cities is a pressing and critical issue on the rise — something the province and Minister Smith have been focused on since their mandate. Time will tell whether this helps a neighbourhood like South Point Douglas deal with the issue.

Minister of Housing Bernadette Smith tours the new 20-suite detox centre in South Point Douglas. (Mikaela MacKenzie / Free Press)

Minister of Housing Bernadette Smith tours the new 20-suite detox centre in South Point Douglas. (Mikaela MacKenzie / Free Press)


Last week I wrote in this newsletter how Indigenous leaders forced their way into being heard at COP30, or the United Nations Climate Change Conference, taking place in Belém, Brazil.

It appears that some of this activism has worked, with the government of Brazil and President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva announcing the creation of 10 new Indigenous territories.

Protected space for Indigenous communities, however, means very little in the country; police and military often do not enforce federal laws intended to protect Indigenous peoples, the primary reason of why Indigenous activists are protesting COP30 in the first place.


A very interesting case in B.C. was settled this week as TD Bank compensated an Indigenous-Muslim man who was refused service when applying for a bank account.

After using his Indian status card at the bank in Surrey, B.C., Sharif Mohammed Bhamji was turned away and told his ID was “fake,” with the bank later calling the police to report him.

After filing a Canadian Human Rights Commission complaint, the bank paid for a restorative justice ceremony, compensated Bhamji, and agreed to change its policies to ensure this instance of racial profiling does not occur again.


Congrats to my good friend Leanne Betasamosake Simpson for winning this year’s Hilary Weston Trust Prize for Nonfiction for her remarkable book Theory of Water: Nishnaabe Maps To the Times Ahead.

This is an incredible book; check out the author talking about it here.

The award comes with a $75,000 prize but the best part was Simpson’s speech, which gave credit to all of those who created footsteps for Simpson to walk in.


This week, instructed by Pope Leo XIV, the Vatican returned 62 Indigenous cultural items to Canada via the Canadian Council of Bishops, fulfilling a promise made earlier this year.

Taken (often forcibly, but also bought and traded) for a 1925 exposition on the Catholic church’s global reach, these items will now be handled by the Canadian Museum of History before a determination is made on what is to be done to investigate their origins and final destinations.


IN PICTURES

An Indigenous group blocks an entrance to the COP30 U.N. Climate Summit, Friday, Nov. 14, in Belem, Brazil. (Fernando Llano The Associated Press files)

An Indigenous group blocks an entrance to the COP30 U.N. Climate Summit, Friday, Nov. 14, in Belem, Brazil. (Fernando Llano The Associated Press files)

RECONCILI-ACTION OF THE WEEK

Every week I highlight an action, moment, or milestone forwarding reconciliation, illustrating how far Canada has come — and how far the country has yet to go.

This week’s reconciliaction of the week is a bit of an odd one. This week 140 years ago, Louis Riel — who has now been officially recognized by the province of Manitoba as its first premier — was hanged after helping lead the 1885 North-West Resistance.

Riel’s hanging was a wrong that “haunts” this country as many Indigenous and Canadian thinkers have remarked and the leader’s execution is still commemorated annually by organizations, governments and citizens throughout Canada and the Manitoba Métis Federation.

This year, however, an interesting guest arrived and even laid a wreath at Riel’s gravesite: Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney.

The Canadian federal government, of course, found Riel guilty of “high treason” and executed him — so to have a Canadian prime minister show up and say the Métis leader “helps to unite” Canada is somewhat a remarkable statement.

Prime Minister Mark Carney lays a wreath at Louis Riel's grave to commemorate the 145th anniversary of Riel's execution at the St. Boniface Cathedral cemetery on Sunday morning. (Mike Sudoma/Free Press)

Prime Minister Mark Carney lays a wreath at Louis Riel’s grave to commemorate the 145th anniversary of Riel’s execution at the St. Boniface Cathedral cemetery on Sunday morning. (Mike Sudoma/Free Press)

At the moment of his execution, Riel said: “I am more convinced every day that without a single exception I did right. And I have always believed that, as I have acted honestly, the time will come when the people of Canada will see and acknowledge it.”

Apparently, he was right.

 
 

Advertisement

 

WHAT I'VE BEEN WORING ON

Niigaan Sinclair:

Lamb case an injustice then, an injustice now

Minutes after convicted killer Shawn Lamb agreed to a plea deal on two counts of manslaughter in the deaths of Lorna Blacksmith and Carolyn Sinclair, the families of the victims knew an injustice had... Read More

 
 
 

LOCAL NEWS

Gabrielle Piché:

Kinew, Carney announce another step forward for Port of Churchill project

New cash for the Port of Churchill, and a commitment to further the project, came from the province Sunday as Prime Minister Mark Carney met with Premier Wab Kinew. They issued a joint announcement ho... Read More

 

Kevin Rollason:

Sioux Valley Dakota Nation elects new chief

Sioux Valley Dakota Nation has a new chief just days after its now former chief was charged with an alleged sexual assault from 41 years ago. A post on the community’s Facebook page says newly-elected... Read More

 

Aaron Epp:

Aviation, wellness entrepreneurs honoured at VIBE Awards

E. Oliver Owen might need a bigger mantel. The entrepreneur was honoured last week in Winnipeg at the 19th annual Visionary Indigenous Business Excellence Awards. He received a custom trophy depicting... Read More

 

Nicole Buffie:

Bloodvein First Nation tells court it won’t deny hunters access to land

A Manitoba First Nation told court Thursday it won’t deny licensed hunters access to its traditional land when game hunting restarts in December — provided they stick to a no-booze rule. The Manitoba... Read More

 

Gabrielle Piché:

Norway House rebrands mining operation

Minago Critical Minerals Project part of First Nation’s plan to become Canada’s magnesium supplier Read More

 

Steve Lambert, The Canadian Press:

Manitoba government seeking suppliers for new monument in front of legislature

WINNIPEG – The Manitoba government is looking for design teams to help build a new statue on the front lawn of the legislature. The government announced plans a year ago to have a monument of a... Read More

 
 

OPINION

Melissa Martin:

Keep their names in the light

News involving killer should never overshadow memories of his victims, nor efforts of family to bring loved ones home Read More

 
 

ARTS & LIFE

Harriet Zaidman:

Indigenous anthology an inspiring resource

You Were Made for This World: Celebrated Indigenous Voices Speak to Young People (Tundra, 120 pages, hardcover, $29), edited by Stephanie Sinclair and Sara Sinclair, is a thoughtful book that will spe... Read More

 

Ben Waldman:

Galactic tales from ground up

Troupe translates southern Manitoba lore into sci-fi production Read More

 

Colleen Zacharias:

Our flora galore

Author goes far and wide on quest to document all plants native to Manitoba Read More

 
 

FROM FURTHER AFIELD

 

Share:

     
 

Download our News Break app