Biidaajimowin
Winnipeg Free Press Logo
 

Falling from the nest

Aftershocks continue to be felt — even across the world — after author Thomas King disclosed to the public that he isn’t Indigenous after writing more than two dozen books about being an “inconvenient Indian.”

Even the BBC published a piece.

Many of you read my Free Press column about King’s revelation, but I also did media rounds elsewhere to speak on the issue, asking the question: Why do Canadians — and in particular those in the Canadian publishing industry — continue to be drawn to individuals who have dubious claims to Indigenous identity?

There are lots of insightful takes on this. A notable interview was with Anishinaabe author Waubgeshig Rice, who said this was the “third time someone I’ve either looked up to or worked with in the lit world has been outed as a Pretendian.”

King, in response to the firestorm surrounding his identity, has withdrawn his next novel from publication.

Thomas King is presented the Governor General's Literary Award for fiction by Governor General David Johnston in 2014. (Patrick Doyle / The Canadian Press files)

Thomas King is presented the Governor General’s Literary Award for fiction by Governor General David Johnston in 2014. (Patrick Doyle / The Canadian Press files)

I spent time in Calgary this week with Pikani elders Reg and Rose Crowshoe — two of the wisest elders I’ve ever met (they’re also members of the Order of Canada).

Reg said something brilliant to me over breakfast when we were talking about Thomas King. I’ll try to do it justice here.

“When I was a boy, an elder said to me that we have to learn from the birds. If you look at the birds, they are very generous and share with other birds but are also very careful who they allow into their nests.

“If any individual makes too much movement by taking up too much space, eating too much, or just performing and showing off, the other birds have to then stay very still, using all of their energy to try to stabilize the nest and keep it from falling to the ground. If that happens, all of the birds then become a feast for the coyotes.”

I asked Reg what happens if that rambunctious bird continues to shake the nest even after upsetting the other birds.

“It’s a matter of patience. Eventually that bird will become so big, so full, and so focused on themselves they will fall out of the nest anyways.”

“Then, what happens?” I asked Reg.

“They become a snack.”

 

Niigaan Sinclair, Columnist

 

Advertisement

 

FIVE STORIES ON TURTLE ISLAND

This week, the Indigenous-led organization Giganawenimaanaanig (“We All Take Care of Them”) released its final report exploring the need for a Manitoba-wide Red Dress Alert — a system that would inform and co-ordinate a systemic and community response when an Indigenous woman, girl or two-spirit person goes missing.

The report was funded by the federal government and was created after a year of consultation with Indigenous organizations, leaders, and families of victims, survivors of violence and members of impacted communities.

It aims to address a long-standing conflict (particularly between police and Indigenous communities) over how to address the issue of missing Indigenous relatives.

The Manitoba provincial government is now looking at implementing the system and is already planning to implement a 24-7 phone line that can assist Indigenous families and victims.

Thelma Morrisseau speaks at the Red Dress Alert report release event on Tuesday. (Mikaela Mackenzie / Free Press)

Thelma Morrisseau speaks at the Red Dress Alert report release event on Tuesday. (Mikaela Mackenzie / Free Press)

Reverberations and a “N0” movement are already emerging across B.C. First Nations in anticipation of Canada signing a memorandum with the Alberta government for a pipeline deal this Thursday.

The pipeline is intended to be built across northern B.C.

B.C. premier David Eby has already expressed frustration at being “left out” of the talks, which he knows drives a wedge between First Nations and Canada over the issue of the environment and the infringement of Indigenous rights.

There is also the little issue of the safety and tide concerns surrounding tanker ships in northern B.C., resulting in a 2019 federal oil-tanker-ship ban because an oil spill to this coast would be devastating and irreversible.


A pretty interesting constitutional dispute is emerging in Québec after premier François Legault’s government drafted a constitution without the inclusion and consent of First Nations. The constitution ignores their status as sovereign nations.

The Québec government proposed Bill 1, the Québec Constitution Act, last month and proposes to protect “Québec’s common values” which includes French, secularism, and gender equality — but ignores, for the most part, Indigenous rights, sovereignty, and nationhood.

I wonder when in the past Canadians may have seen a government propose a constitution that ignores Indigenous rights? We know what happened then.


In memoriam this week in the Indigenous world are two grassroots, brilliant and highly impactful cultural teachers and heroes who have died.

The first was Ida Bear, who was an award-winning Cree language advocate, teacher and curriculum developer who was honoured by the University of Winnipeg, where she worked for years.

The second was Ian Ross, who was an Anishinaabe playwright, theatre teacher, and Governor General Award winner for his play, fareWel.

Ross was perhaps better known to many as the hilarious, insightful and always kind “Joe from Winnipeg.”

Both will be missed in our hearts, classrooms, and ceremonies.

Ian Ross during the set construction for The Third Colour in 2019. (Phil Hossack / Free Press files)

Ian Ross during the set construction for The Third Colour in 2019. (Phil Hossack / Free Press files)

My last news item for the week is an optional viewing for you. For 30 minutes this week, I was the featured guest on the APTN TV show and podcast Face to Face with host Dennis Ward.

I discuss the “frustrating” pace at which the TRC calls to action are being implemented, Indigenous education in schools and universities, and new book projects I am working on. Check it out here.

IN PICTURES

A long table holds photos of some of Manitoba’s missing and murdered Indigenous women, girls and two-spirit people at the Red Dress Alert report release event on Tuesday. (Mikaela Mackenzie / Free Press)

A long table holds photos of some of Manitoba’s missing and murdered Indigenous women, girls and two-spirit people at the Red Dress Alert report release event on Tuesday. (Mikaela Mackenzie / Free Press)

RECONCILI-ACTION OF THE WEEK

Every week I highlight an action, moment, or milestone forwarding reconciliation, illustrating how far Canada has come — and how far the country has yet to go.

This reconciliaction of the week is out of this world.

At the University of Manitoba, researchers with the STARLab team and Magellan Aerospace are working to develop a CubeSat, a milk-carton-sized satellite that will eventually orbit, map and collect data about the moon.

That’s cool enough, but an even cooler part of the project is Indigenous knowledge and youth are a foundational part of the building team, providing traditional knowledge for the lunar navigation system.

This is not the first time STARLab has created a satellite, but it is the first time Indigenous knowledge and youth are being used to help with the project.

The project will also help provide northern Inuit communities with information around ice safety conditions and climate change.

If you want to keep track of the progress of this amazing project, check it out here.

 
 

Advertisement

 

WHAT I'VE BEEN WORKING ON

Niigaan Sinclair:

The inconvenient truth: Thomas King’s admission he isn’t Cherokee hits hard

Intentionally or not, the real-life consequences of King’s story is that his inability to find out the truth of his own identity, which apparently wasn’t hard for others, meant Canadians were duped, Indigenous peoples were marginalized, and all of us are left to ask a lot of questions. Read More

 

Niigaan Sinclair:

Lamb case an injustice then, an injustice now

The reason Shawn Lamb served such little time after causing horrific deaths is a combination of questionable police and judicial decisions, an unaccountable justice system, and a long history of systemic and unaddressed violence in Indigenous lives. Read More

 

Niigaan Sinclair:

Premier’s words got people to pay attention; maybe that was the point

Those who have not experienced violence can listen, learn and, after that, participate in finding solutions — but it is survivors of violence who know first and foremost how to address it. Read More

 

Niigaan Sinclair:

World Series anthem outcry ignores truth of lyric change

One word in a national anthem is small, but apparently changes the world — that is, if you listen to some fans, commentators, and social media “influencers.” Read More

 
 
 

LOCAL NEWS

Steve Lambert, The Canadian Press:

Manitoba Premier Kinew asks PM Carney for sentencing, parole overhaul

WINNIPEG – Manitoba Premier Wab Kinew has asked the prime minister for stiffer sentences for repeat or serial killers, citing the recent release of one killer that Kinew says “disgustsR... Read More

 

Melissa Martin:

Indigenous organization’s report moves Red Dress Alert one step closer in Manitoba

In the weeks before Tina Fontaine’s death in 2014, her great aunt, Thelma Favel, spent hours calling authorities hoping for help to find the teen, who’d disappeared into Winnipeg’s troubled streets. T... Read More

 

Aaron Epp:

Combination of social, health problems in province blamed for increase in number of HIV cases

HIV diagnosis rates in Manitoba continue to rise due to a combination of social and health problems, according to the director of a provincially co-ordinated initiative that provides care and treatment to people living with the virus. Read More

 

Chris Kitching:

Multimillion-dollar suit against MMF leader dismissed

Chartrand, two others ‘acted honestly’ while leading Métis National Council, Ontario judge rules Read More

 

Maggie Macintosh:

Province promises ‘proactive approach’ to truancy fight

Legislation in motion, leader of non-profit not holding his breath Read More

 

Malak Abas:

U of M over the moon about satellite’s lunar launch

A milk-carton sized satellite built by Manitoba researchers will go where no Canadian spacecraft has gone before — the moon’s orbit. Read More

 

Kevin Rollason:

Métis federation sues Ottawa, Manitoba over Sixties Scoop

The Manitoba Métis Federation is suing the federal and Manitoba governments for damages caused to the Red River Métis as a whole when an unknown number of children were placed with non-Indigenous families during the Sixties Scoop. Read More

 

Nicole Buffie:

Thunderbird House up for overdue reno

The Circle of Life Thunderbird House on Main Street, known for its iconic design and signature copper roof, is in line for sorely needed repairs after years of deterioration and vandalism. Read More

 
 

OPINION

Jocelyn Thorpe and Adele Perry:

Investing for ourselves, and those downstream

We have invested large sums of money in infrastructure before. You don’t often hear Winnipeggers complaining about the results: soft, clean drinking water thanks to the Shoal Lake aqueduct and flood p... Read More

 

Jim Silver:

Adult basic education keeps youth out of crime

A recent study by Marni Brownell and colleagues at the Manitoba Centre for Health Policy, titled Crossover Kids in Manitoba: The Intersection of the Child Protection System, Youth Criminal Justice System and First Nations Identity, found that First Nations youth removed from their homes and placed in the child welfare system are more likely to end up being involved in the criminal justice system than to graduate high school. Read More

 

Sandra Bracken:

Restorative justice and safer communities

There are currently a number of public and political discussions across the country regarding community safety and how the criminal justice system through its bail and sentencing processes addresses those who come into conflict with the law. Read More

 
 

ARTS & LIFE

Ben Waldman:

Playwright, educator known as Joe From Winnipeg, Ian Ross dies at 57

Born in McCreary to a Saulteaux mother and Métis father, Ian Ross took the theatre world by storm in 1997 when his first professional play was awarded the Governor General’s Award for English Drama, making the 29-year-old the first Indigenous person to receive the honour in Canadian history. Read More

 

Cassandra Szklarski, The Canadian Press:

Long-lost adult siblings strive to rebuild severed family bonds in ‘Meadowlarks’

TORONTO – Director Tasha Hubbard didn’t have far to look for inspiration in order to capture the complex emotions of separated Indigenous siblings who meet for the first time as adults. Her new... Read More

 

Nicole Thompson, The Canadian Press:

Thomas King’s revelation he is not Indigenous sends ripples through culture sector

TORONTO – Thomas King’s revelation that he has no Indigenous ancestry sent ripples through Canada’s cultural sector, while raising questions about what responsibility a person has wh... Read More

 
 

FROM FURTHER AFIELD

 

Share:

     
 

Download our News Break app