Paul Samyn Editor’s Note
Winnipeg Free Press Logo
 

We answer for our mistakes. Big Tech scales up theirs

When it comes to errors, I realize I work in a glass house.

Over my 38-year career at the Free Press, I’ve made a few mistakes, including one glaring gaffe: I once wrote that a Supreme Court nominee had undergone a “pubic” examination on Parliament Hill when I meant to type “public.”

Such is the nature of our history-on-the-run business.

Nothing’s as thorough as a pubic grilling. (Free Press archives)

Nothing’s as thorough as a pubic grilling. (Free Press archives)

But even when you add my errors to the Free Press’s errata over the last 154 years, our missteps are nothing compared with the volume of falsehoods being generated by Google’s AI Overviews, even as I type this message to you.

AI Overviews are the small blocks of AI-generated text that now appear at the top of Google search results, purporting to summarize the information you’re trying to find.

But a new analysis has found those summaries include wrong information 10 per cent of the time.

Given the number of search queries Google processes every minute of every day, mistakes are being made at an industrial level that’s unparalleled, unprecedented — and unnerving.

Some quick math to put the scale of the problem in perspective. Google responds to roughly five trillion queries a year. That translates into tens of millions of inaccurate answers every hour, based on the analysis the New York Times used for its reporting. In the minute that it has taken you to reach this sentence, that could add up to hundreds of thousands of errors, thanks to AI.

The Free Press would have long gone out of business if we got the story right only nine times out of 10.

But those standards don’t seem to apply to the companies now dominating the information ecosystem — and creating a misinformation crisis in the process.

We’ll have more to say about AI’s impact on the local media landscape this weekend in a deep dive Eva Wasney takes into a media outlet that claims to be an altruistic alternative to mainstream media in Manitoba.

In the meantime, the Free Press will continue to put facts first — and when we do make an error, we’ll correct the record transparently, in print and online.

 

Paul Samyn, Editor

 

Advertisement

Iced drink with lime on a wooden surface beside the Savour Manitoba magazine cover.
 

COMING UP

“Mostly accurate” is an unusual boast for a media company to make in its tagline, but that’s how an AI-generated news outlet touts its coverage of dozens of Manitoba and Canadian communities.

Writer Eva Wasney investigates the local tech company’s move into the news business and what it means for the future of journalism.


Prime Minister Mark Carney has previously revealed one of his favourite albums is London Calling by the Clash. Not a surprising choice, considering Carney is the former Bank of England governor.

On that note, feature writer David Sanderson surveyed a host of local politicians about their favourite LPs.

Can you guess who has a back tattoo of Paul Simon’s Graceland album cover?


Manitoba Opera’s season winds up with a production of The Marriage of Figaro, Mozart’s beloved ensemble comedy.

In Saturday’s arts section, Eva Wasney talks to members of the cast, who say rehearsals for the once controversial opera, which premiered in 1786, have been so much fun, they don’t want the run to end.


As the UFC rolls into town for the first time since 2017, reporter Taylor Allen is the Free Press’s eyes on the Octagon for all of Saturday night’s hard-hitting action.


And at the rink, Mike McIntyre and Ken Wiebe are primed to have the upcoming Winnipeg Jets regular-season postmortem after the club’s final game Thursday night against the San Jose Sharks.

FIFA FUN

Hundreds of local fútbol fans gathered at Memorial Park Monday to take in the FIFA World Cup Trophy Tour. The trophy, which is travelling around the continent, will be the end-all and be-all of 48 countries when the World Cup begins in Canada, U.S. and Mexico on June 11. (Photos by Mike Deal / Free Press)

Hundreds of local fútbol fans gathered at Memorial Park Monday to take in the FIFA World Cup Trophy Tour. The trophy, which is travelling around the continent, will be the end-all and be-all of 48 countries when the World Cup begins in Canada, U.S. and Mexico on June 11. (Photos by Mike Deal / Free Press)

 
 

Advertisement

Savour Manitoba Spring issue cover featuring colourful mixed drinks on a table.
 

BREAKING NEWS

Malak Abas:

Winnipeg on track to reject managed encampment pilot

Front-line agencies disappointed; report estimates program would cost up to $1.39 million Read More

 

Chris Kitching:

Skip shutters Express Lane fulfilment centres

‘Important chapter in our story’: two Winnipeg locations closed, staff laid off amid talk of slowing business for once-hyped project Read More

 

Joshua Frey-Sam:

‘I can still play this game’

Reigning world champ Furber continues to dominate blind golf Read More

 
 
 

WELL-READ STORIES THIS WEEK

Taylor Allen:

Sweeting lands on her feet

Former Einarson third picks up with B.C.’s MacMillan Read More

 

Jeff Hamilton:

Former teacher misconduct commissioner contradicts premier, issues statement denying she was fired

What began as a quiet departure has rapidly snowballed into a tangled web of contradictions for the Manitoba government. Read More

 

Kevin Rollason:

Matriarch of Richardson family dies at 99

Awarded Order of Canada in 2003 for philanthropic endeavours Read More

 

Kevin Rollason:

‘It was all untrue’: Bear Clan founder feels vindicated after defamation settlement

Organization in turmoil after losing charitable status Read More

 

Scott Billeck:

‘Just staggering’: city’s homelessness crisis worsening, new data reveals

Winnipeg’s homelessness crisis is accelerating, not easing, as new data released Monday shows more people are falling into homelessness than are finding a way out. Read More

 
 

DEEP DIVES

Tyler Searle:

Stalked? Scared? Sorry

Winnipeg women left to navigate criminal justice system on their own for nearly a month until stranger harassing them arrested Read More

 

Brent Bellamy:

Step into our city’s past

Hand-drawn 1884 map captures Winnipeg at moment when frontier hadn’t fully given way to a metropolis Read More

 

Conrad Sweatman:

Who’s overseeing the seers?

Snowballing government and private surveillance awash in ethical shades of grey Read More

 

David Sanderson:

Sweet16

For celluloid champion, nothing beats spooling up vintage film format to ‘purr’ on a projector Read More

 
 

NEWS YOU CAN USE

Joyanne Pursaga:

City could freeze water rates if high usage continues

Nearly $70M in unexpected revenue poured in last year Read More

 

Daniel Johnson, The Canadian Press:

In the world of dynamic pricing, here’s when you should buy concert and game tickets

Your favourite artist is coming to town, or your favourite team is heading to the playoffs — you want to go, but don't want to pay top dollar. Here's your dilemma: do you buy tickets now or wait until closer to the show in hopes prices will fall? Read More

 

Conrad Sweatman:

What’s up, doc?

YouTube documentary archive collects Manitoba films on topics from hockey to local haunts Read More

 

Colleen Zacharias:

Pragmatic plots

Designing hardier gardens for a changing climate Read More

 

Joel Schlesinger:

To the moon

Lunar voyage coincides with heated anticipation of SpaceX going public, new funds offering pre-launch exposure to its estimated nearly US$2T valuation Read More

 

Gabrielle Piché:

Province creating resource-focused website for tech sector startups

The Manitoba government is building an online portal to showcase resources for local entrepreneurs. Read More

 
 

OPINIONS: COLUMNS AND ANALYSIS

Tom Brodbeck:

Oblivious Conservatives fiddling while Poilievre burns

The warning signs for the federal Conservatives are no longer subtle — they’re sitting in plain view on the government benches. Another one of their own just got up and walked across the aisle. Read More

 

Editorial:

Donald Trump is a danger to the world

There is no other way to say this: it is becoming clear that Donald J. Trump, the president of the United States of America, is unhinged. Read More

 

Jen Zoratti:

Moon mission Earth photo could change your worldview

Having a photo of Earth — the whole Earth — taken by a human is an incredible thing, and now we have a new one. It’s a beautiful image. But it’s also a deeply moving one. Read More

 

Niigaan Sinclair:

Governments change, priorities change… and genocide goes on

Years after Canada's prime minister recognized a genocide was occurring, very little has changed in response to the findings of the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls. Read More

 

Russell Wangersky:

It’s green for go on spring-loaded imaginings

As winter fades, anticipating the simple joys of a day by the brook Read More

 
 

ON THE LIGHTER SIDE

Ben Waldman:

Sign of the Times

Venerable local music venue celebrates 25 years with changes that stay true to its roots Read More

 

Mike McIntyre:

From ‘who’s that?’ to household name

Local product Sudarshan Yellamaraju’s rise to PGA Tour an inspiration Read More

 

Eva Wasney:

Art sprouting at The Forks

New sculptures modelled after resilient weed that flourished Read More

 

Ben Waldman:

Sweet, salty advice and plenty of drama in Prairie Theatre Exchange's Tiny Beautiful Things

As today’s internet burns, with the American president typing out annihilative intentions into a propagandist app he’s dubbed the Truth, it’s easy to feel like a helpless fruit fly caught in a world w... Read More

 

Mike McIntyre:

‘It’s been a lot of fun for me’: Jets’ Vilardi honoured by team nomination for humanitarian award

Gabe Vilardi learned plenty of valuable lessons as a child, ones that continue to guide him to this day. Read More

 
 

WEEKLY NEWS QUIZ

Test your knowledge of current events with our weekly news quiz.

The week that was: April 6 to 11

This week's news quiz topics include: fireworks, summer boating, local theatre, flood threat and more. Take the quiz

 
 

Share:

     
 

Download our News Break app