Biidaajimowin
Winnipeg Free Press Logo
 

Correcting the record on residential-school denialism

My University of Manitoba colleague Sean Carleton and I have a new piece out this week discussing this editorial by the Globe and Mail (published May 30, 2026) and how it fosters, encourages, and emboldens residential school denialism.

The Globe and Mail editorial board rejected our request to publish our response, stating it is their policy not to publish responses to their editorial board statements, but as you can see, we correct Canada’s predominant newspaper and address the significant factual errors and logical fallacies. Here is our piece, entitled “Putting truth and respect before reconciliation.”

If anyone is interested in learning more on the topic, Sean and I have edited a new collection of essays from some of Canada’s best scholars. It’s called Truth Before Reconciliation: Confronting Residential School Denialism and it comes out next month.

 

Niigaan Sinclair, Columnist

 

Advertisement

Puzzles & Diversions. Your daily dose of fun: crosswords, sudokus, horoscopes and Miss Lonelyhearts all in one email.
 

FIVE STORIES ON TURTLE ISLAND

1. For those who haven’t heard, Shark Tank celebrity and venture capitalist Kevin O’Leary has been trying to build a controversial AI data mega-centre on the traditional territory of Sturgeon Lake Cree Nation in Alberta.

A well-known friend of Alberta Premier Danielle Smith, O’Leary has received special governmental exceptions in the approval and regulatory process. I’ve previously written about this issue.

Last April, Sturgeon Lake Cree Nation asked for a judicial review of O’Leary’s license, prompting the capital investor’s lawyers to ask an Alberta court for the request to be rejected. In the first court battle over the project, the First Nation won; their request for a review of O’Leary’s license is set to go forward.

This battle is not over, of course, but this case should be compelling for anyone interested in Indigenous nations’ rights in having a say on what business happens on their territories.


2. Mathias Colomb Cree Nation Chief Gordie Bear drew attention to the housing crisis in Pukatawagan (also known as Mathias Colomb Cree Nation) when he spoke about protests in the community.

Here’s hoping this northern community, which has been devastated by wildfires, evacuations, and infrastructure issues that have led to local conflict and crime, will find some support.


3. Last week, an Alberta court officially renamed Gladue reports, opting for the term “Indigenous background report” to better articulate Indigenous experiences and encourage systemic justice reform.

Named after Jamie Tanis Gladue, an Alberta woman accused of killing her spouse in a case that prompted a landmark Supreme Court of Canada decision in 1999, a Gladue report is often prepared in court cases when an Indigenous person has been accused of a criminal offence. The report attempts to contextualize that offence in the broader experience of Indigenous Peoples in Canadian history for the purposes of providing an adequate and culturally-considered sentence.

This name change within the Alberta Court of Justice is intended to help the public understand more clearly what the reports are for. I hope other provinces will follow suit.


4. An interesting report commissioned by the polling firm Angus Reid states that while 57 per cent of Canadians want to take part in an Indigenous-led travel experience, only 18 per cent have actually done so.

The report also stated 42 per cent of Canadians who had never participated said they had not encountered an Indigenous-led experience while planning a trip and 30 per cent didn’t know where to find one.

For those who don’t know, Indigenous tourism is a growing industry in Manitoba and I encourage everyone to check out the many operators throughout the province.


5. The Manitoba Indigenous Summer Games wrapped up this past week in Sagkeeng Anicinabe Nation after kicking off in Norway House Cree Nation last month.

Featuring Manitoba’s best Indigenous athletes under 18 years old, competitors battled it out in archery, track and field, basketball, ball hockey, golf, and the most-watched event of the entire games: lacrosse.

 

IN PICTURES

An Indigenous youth holds a candle during a protest calling for the protection of Indigenous land rights and demarcations outside the Supreme Court in Brasilia, Brazil, last Tuesday. (Eraldo Peres / The Associated Press)

An Indigenous youth holds a candle during a protest calling for the protection of Indigenous land rights and demarcations outside the Supreme Court in Brasilia, Brazil, last Tuesday. (Eraldo Peres / The Associated Press)

 

RECONCILI-ACTION OF THE WEEK

Every week I highlight an action, moment, or milestone forwarding reconciliation, illustrating how far Canada has come — and how far the country has yet to go.

It was a great week for Manitoba’s educational leaders, who spent the week at Elkhorn Resort in a Manitoba Association of School Superintendents retreat working with speakers, attending planning sessions, and collectively sharing best practices on how to incorporate Indigenous education into Manitoba schools.

I was one of the speakers and was joined by Indigenous educational leaders Kevin Chief, Wade Houle and a host of others. The association of school superintendents has been one of Canada’s foremost leaders in integrating Indigenous education into Canadian schools. The organization produced a position paper on why incorporating Indigenous knowledge, perspectives, and pedagogies is good for all Manitoba students at all grade levels. Here is its most recent statement.

 
 

Advertisement

1.2 Million users visit The Free Press's network of sites each month.
 

WHAT I'VE BEEN WORKING ON

Niigaan Sinclair:

Indigenous peoples are deeply invested in Canada

First Nations voters have only been allowed the legal right to cast a ballot in Canadian elections since 1960, but many in the past — perhaps rightly — felt a sense of complicity in the country’s colonization or, worse, that voting didn’t make a difference. Not anymore. Read More

 

Niigaan Sinclair:

A measure of hope a decade after senseless death, injustice

Colten Boushie’s death and the trial of the man who killed him had an immense impact on Canadians, many of whom learned about the injustice Indigenous communities know all too well for the first time. Read More

 
 
 

LOCAL NEWS

Brittany Hobson, The Canadian Press:

First Nations, Norwegian family unite to honour adventurer’s life and legacy

WINNIPEG - Gry Skjottelvik arrived in Canada last month with a mission. The mother traded in the comfort of her home in a small village in Norway for the expansive, sprawling and sometimes treacher... Read More

 

Erik Pindera:

Opaskwayak restorative justice court to give offenders opportunity to ‘heal’

The Manitoba government, provincial court and Opaskwayak Cree Nation are signing a memorandum of understanding today to establish a community-led court focused on Indigenous restorative justice princi... Read More

 

Maggie Macintosh:

Coalition dismayed after U of M decides not to establish master’s in speech-language pathology

A new coalition representing students who stutter, speak with a lisp and struggle with other speech challenges is decrying the University of Manitoba’s decision to shelve plans to train in-demand clin... Read More

 

Gabrielle Piché:

Manitoba prepares project pitches for investment summit

Powerhouse investors may hear pitches on Manitoba mines, silica sand projects and a massive greenhouse during Canada’s first major investors summit. Read More

 

Carol Sanders:

Moving rail lines outside city would make Winnipeg ‘major transportation hub’

Axworthy to lead 90-day study of proposed south bypass along Hydro transmission corridor Read More

 

Maggie Macintosh:

Listening, healing, togetherness

RRC shelter support worker program grads seek to make difference in lives of province’s most vulnerable Read More

 
 

OPINION

Editorial:

New drug enforcement program a better approach, but not yet enough

In late June, when the Winnipeg Police Service launched a 10-day ‘crackdown’ on open drug use and illegal drug sales in areas in and around downtown, it did so without consulting or informing communit... Read More

 
 

ARTS & LIFE

Jen Zoratti:

Lay of the land

Exhibition offers up 125 different ways to look at Canada Read More

 

John Longhurst:

Churches make collective gift toward fostering reconciliation

Three Canadian denominations have taken another step towards reconciliation with Indigenous people. At a June 18 gifting ceremony here in Winnipeg, the United, Anglican and Presbyterian churches ma... Read More

 

Tiago Resko:

Fusion pop-up coming to street food festival

After surviving breast cancer and watching her husband live through a brain tumour, Marilyn Magtoto decided it was time to take a chance. Read More

 
 

FROM FURTHER AFIELD

 

Share:

     
 

Download our News Break app