Biidaajimowin
Winnipeg Free Press Logo
 

Residential school denialism shouldn’t be criminal, says Kinew — so what about Holocaust denial?

Manitoba Premier Wab Kinew stirred up a lot of attention in the Indigenous community this week after he stated residential school denialism should not be criminalized.

Kinew made the comments on a CBC morning program last Friday in response to federal NDP MP Leah Gazan’s private member’s bill, which aims to make condoning, denying or minimizing the residential school system an offence under the Criminal Code.

The bill has been endorsed by many First Nations governments and organizations, residential school survivor groups and organizations such as the Manitoba Teachers’ Society.

NDP MP Leah Gazan (Patrick Doyle / The Canadian Press files)

NDP MP Leah Gazan (Patrick Doyle / The Canadian Press files)

Kinew argued the issue should be handled through education and combating misinformation rather than criminal prosecution — a view the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs called “disappointing” and something that “creates further harm” for residential school survivors, according to the National Family and Survivors Circle president Hilda Anderson-Pyrz.

I’ve spoken many times about residential school denialism in several places: my Free Press column, in a book, and in other media such as CBC’s Front Burner podcast.

Many Indigenous leaders say the problem is the Canadian federal government is choosing to protect one group suffering from hate speech but not another, as Holocaust denialism was made illegal in Canada in June 2022 through Bill C-19 (the Budget Implementation Act).

Supporters of criminalizing Holocaust denialism have argued laws must be in place to control speech in order to combat antisemitism, ensure public order, prevent the rise of Nazism and respect the dignity of Holocaust survivors.

A 2024 Dartmouth University study showed education — while an essential part of the fight against antisemitism — wasn’t enough to curb “intolerance” against Jewish communities, and criminalization was an element that could ensure it was addressed.

Others have said criminalization of Holocaust denialism is unconstitutional and redundant.

Kinew’s government has been publicly supportive of the Jewish community in the past and made combating antisemitism a part of the provincial curriculum but, as far as I can see, has never commented on the issue of criminalizing Holocaust denialism.

The question now — especially after the Manitoba premier has said he doesn’t support criminalizing residential school denialism — is: does he support the criminalization of Holocaust denialism?

 

Niigaan Sinclair, Columnist

 

Advertisement

That's a wrap. Today's must-read stories and a roundup of the day's headlines. Get the newsletter sent every weekday evening.
 

FIVE STORIES ON TURTLE ISLAND

1. I’m thinking of my relations in Fisher River Cree Nation this week as leaders announced they were facing a “severe shortage” of at least 40 educational assistants needed to serve children in the school system owing to chronic underfunding.

It’s long been known adults requiring special needs on First Nations reserves go without basic services, but the involvement of Jordan’s Principle addressed some of these needs in recent years.

Funding for Jordan’s Principle is now being restricted and tightened by the federal government as the system is reviewed, and this is creating shortages as seen on Fisher River Cree Nation. During these moments of “review,” children are often the ones to suffer first.


2. A federal judge had harsh words for the federal government, saying Canada has continued to “shirk its responsibilities” since signing the 1997 Manitoba Framework Agreement.

Canada had promised to return land to First Nations that were given insufficient land under Treaties 1, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 10. The total land owed to the 21 First Nations eligible under the agreement was up to 445,417 hectares, but slightly more than half of that has been converted to reserve land as of March 2026.

Reports on this progress are available at the Manitoba Framework Agreement Treaty Land Entitlement Implementation Monitoring Committee here.


3. Independent Canadian senators continue to propose provocative legislation in Canada’s Senate with a bill aimed at explicitly defining and clarifying the RCMP’s legal obligations to recognize, respect and enforce First Nations’ own laws and governance systems.

Numerous First Nations have complained about jurisdictional confusion and spoken out about local government bylaws not being enforced by RCMP detachments.


4. Leaders from the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs (AMC) are in India this week as part of the official “Team Canada” trade mission to forge international business partnerships and expand economic opportunities for Indigenous-owned businesses.

First Nations leaders including AMC Grand Chief Kyra Wilson and Minegoziibe Anishinabe Chief Derek Nepinak are joining other Manitoban representatives exploring opportunities for First Nations to participate in the creation and trade of agriculture and food products, clean energy, natural resources, infrastructure, resources and technology.


5. Gov. Gen. Louise Arbour met Premier Wab Kinew and other Manitoba Indigenous leaders during her first official visit to Manitoba Oct. 7 to 9. She also met with leadership from Manitoba Keewatinowi Okimakanak, the Manitoba Inuit Association and the Manitoba Métis Federation.

Arbour was particularly interested in meeting with Manitoba Inuit Association CEO Gayle Gruben to discuss issues facing Inuit in Manitoba, including housing, health care, education and research on residential schools.

She also spent a day touring Le Musée de Saint-Boniface and learning from Grade 6 students from l’École Taché about Manitoba’s history and Métis heritage.

IN PICTURES

Members of Chābētū Apache Crown Dancers perform a traditional dance at an Indigenous Peoples Day event in Phoenix, Arizona on Monday. (Ross D. Franklin / The Associated Press files)

Members of Chābētū Apache Crown Dancers perform a traditional dance at an Indigenous Peoples Day event in Phoenix, Arizona on Monday. (Ross D. Franklin / The Associated Press files)

RECONCILI-ACTION OF THE WEEK

Every week I highlight an action, moment, or milestone forwarding reconciliation, illustrating how far Canada has come — and how far the country has yet to go.

The reconcili-action of the week goes to all of my friends and colleagues at Yellowquill College, which was officially proclaimed as the province’s first fully recognized, First Nations-owned and operated post-secondary institution and will now go by the name Yellowquill University College (YQUC).

Proclaimed Oct. 1 by the Manitoba government, YQUC now has full legal authority to grant university degrees, diplomas and certificates on par with other public universities, colleges, and religious institutions in Manitoba.

Established in 1984 by the Dakota Ojibway Tribal Council and operating its main campus on the Long Plain First Nation urban reserve in Winnipeg, YQUC offers undergraduate degrees (such as bachelor of education, bachelor of relational studies, and bachelor of First Nations studies) alongside various diplomas and certificates in fields such as child and family services, business and health.

 
 

Advertisement

The Wrap sent weekday evenings.
 

WHAT I'VE BEEN WORKING ON

Niigaan Sinclair:

Indigenous offenders need a new path to justice

Indigenous peoples – and Indigenous men in particular – are incarcerated at a rate higher than any other group in Canada. As Canada’s own Department of Justice reports from data last collected in 2... Read More

 
 
 

LOCAL NEWS

Aaron Epp:

20th annual VIBE awards put spotlight on giving back

As a student at the University of Manitoba, Terry Brown never thought that one day he might be the leader of an award-winning company. Read More

 

Nicole Buffie:

Bloodvein standing firm, won’t move blockade

Indigenous leaders are accusing the province of violating treaty rights for asking a First Nations community to move its checkstop that was set up to keep drugs and alcohol out. Assembly of Manitob... Read More

 

Free Press staff:

Manitoba delegation to join trade mission to India

A delegation from Manitoba will travel to India seeking to bolster economic ties with the South Asia nation. Read More

 

Kelly-Anne Riess:

‘Every once in a while, somebody comes along and they change… the direction of a country’

Selkirk middle school changes name to honour province’s first Indigenous judge, senator, TRC commissioner Murray Sinclair Read More

 

George Williams:

A dozen straight titles for Indigenous trainers at Assiniboia Downs

THAT’S a wrap! The 69th season of live racing at Assiniboia Downs came to a close on Wednesday and for the 12th consecutive year the training title was won by an Indigenous horseman. Trainer Jer... Read More

 

Malak Abas:

A Rocky day on the campaign trail

‘It matters how hard you get hit and keep getting up,’ mayoral candidate Kevin Klein says, referencing famous film’s fighter in wake of opponent’s allegations, apology-triggering column in his newspaper Read More

 
 

ARTS & LIFE

Ben Sigurdson:

Vermette lands on non-fiction editing short list

Winnipeg-based novelist, poet and editor katherena vermette has made the three-person short list for a new $25,000 prize given awarded to the editor of a work of non-fiction. Read More

 

Reviewed by Rochelle Squires:

Unity-based worldview key to good leadership

Indigenous leader and former justice minister and attorney general of Canada Jody Wilson-Raybould knows first-hand what courageous leadership looks like. As a politician operating in an adversarial and competitive partisan system that favours winning over good public policy, she once took a stand against a leader and his style that was contrary to her values. The move cost her her job. The public fallout was immense as she was removed from cabinet and, later, the caucus. Read More

 

Reviewed by Matt Henderson:

Betrayal on the ballot

Alberta vote on secession was spurred by a complicit premier, Patrick Lennox argues in his latest, On Treason Read More

 
 

FROM FURTHER AFIELD

 

Share:

     
 

Download our News Break app