Applause
Winnipeg Free Press Logo
 

Applause — written by a real human

Apologies in advance for yet another airplane-related Applause, but as regular readers will know, I missed last week’s newsletter owing to delays in my return from a travel junket to French Lick, Ind. (jealous?).

We are lucky enough at the Free Press to still have a stand-alone travel section and, on occasion, we are invited to visit locations — some luxurious, some less so — to write about them for our readers. (This week, for instance, Nadya Pankiw travelled to Blacksburg, Va.: you can read about her adventures in picturesque small-town Virginia here.)

Over the years, I’ve gone on assignment everywhere from Fiji to Fredericksburg, Texas (coincidentally also highlighted in this week’s Travel pages), and enjoyed everything from a marathon in Mo’orea to Greenlandic hospitality in Kangaamuit.

Advertisement

Winnipeg Gardener sent Monthly.

 

Not to toot my own horn, but I’ve even picked up a couple of travel-writing awards along the way.

Long story short, I like writing about destinations of every stripe, and I like reading about them too. So while sitting aboard my flight to Atlanta last week, I picked up the WestJet Vacations magazine from the seatback to peruse it.

Over the years, I’ve found some decent recommendations in these articles, which had previously appeared to be written by people with a passion for discovery and an eye for the unique.

Now, however, I’m almost positive they are penned by AI. The lack of any bylines was the first clue; the second was the jumbled, terminally banal copy, all clichés and buzzwords, signifying nothing.

I honestly cannot remember any of the specific destinations that were covered, as they all blended together in a wash of turquoise seas, sandy beaches, world-class dining and five-star accommodations. Superlatives were repeated multiple times in five-paragraph descriptions and almost nothing specific — a particular snorkel location, a can’t-miss restaurant — was mentioned.

The only one that stood out was Las Vegas (did you know this desert city has a great nightlife — who needs the actual names of venues or hotels? — and also plays host to an on-the-rise theatre troupe called Cirque du Soleil?), and that’s mostly because the blurb included several sentences that made me paraphrase The Princess Bride’s Inigo Montoya and say to myself, “I do not think that word means what you think it means.” (Cirque apparently has “illustrious” sets.)

It’s true that travel writing can sometimes skirt perilously close to the edge of advertorial; we tend to focus on the positives and gloss over the downsides. But whether you’re an armchair tourist on a boots-on-the-ground immersive type, you want first-hand knowledge of a place, even if it’s just the highlights.

AI can’t point you to the best conch fritters or friendliest bartenders. It can’t hear the roosters that wake you up at 3 a.m. in Vieques, or convey the taste of raw seal liver. It can’t get naked in a Turkish hammam or ride a camel named Steve in Morocco. It can’t even tell you where the most convenient free Wi-Fi is. It’s a promotional brochure — a bland and lifeless simulacrum of real experiences.

 

Jill Wilson

 

If you enjoy my newsletter, please consider forwarding it to others. They can sign up for free here.

Did you know we have many other free newsletters? You can gorge yourself on food and beverage news from my Arts & Life pals Eva Wasney and Ben Sigurdson, who write the bi-weekly Dish newsletter, or you can follow a weekly exploration of Indigenous voices, perspectives and experiences in Niigaan Sinclair’s Biidaajimowin | News from the Centre.

You can browse all of our newsletters here.

 

Advertisement

1.1 Million users visit The Free Press's network of sites each month.
 

What’s up this week

Six recommendations from Free Press staff

Winnipeg Jazz Orchestra kicks off its season with a Tomson Highway collaboration Saturday — read Eva Wasney’s story here.

• The Winnipeg Improv Festival runs all weekend.

• Kicking off at the Gargoyle Theatre on Oct. 24 is a new solo musical called Hamlet: The Modern Player’s Guide, adapted by novelist Andrew Davidson, and starring Duncan Cox, who wrote the music. It runs to Oct. 27; tickets are available here.

 
 

Advertisement

Winnipeg's most read news source. 367,000 Adults Weekly.
 

NEW IN MUSIC

Conrad Sweatman:

New South Osborne music venue Sidestage set to crank it up

All-ages venue to host punk, metal shows as well as community events Read More

 
 

AV Kitching:

Century of song

Winnipeg Boys’ Choir celebrates 100 years Read More

 
 
 

NEW ON STAGE

Ben Waldman:

Blindside creator’s new show tackles insecurities

“I don’t believe that anything is ever done,” says Stéphanie Morin-Robert. She’s referring to her own work in a category of solo theatre broadly referred to as autobiographical, in which the Timmin... Read More

 

Ben Waldman:

All the wrong moves

Production mishaps part of the fun in award-winning comedy Read More

 
 

NEW ON SCREEN

Randall King:

Rumours’ Canadian PM not based on Trudeau, actor says

TORONTO — When Rumours premièred at the Cannes film festival earlier this year, the initial shock was to seeing Winnipeg directors Guy Maddin, Evan Johnson and Galen Johnson teamed with Australian actress Cate Blanchett, easily one of the biggest stars to shine in the Maddin/Johnson firmament. Even better, once cast, Blanchett proved to be a magnet for the rest of the international cast, which includes Charles Dance, Denis Ménochet (Inglourious Basterds), Nikki Amuka-Bird (Knock at the Cabin), Rolando Ravello (Perfect Strangers) and Takehiro Hira (Gran Turismo) as the leaders of, respectively, the U.S., France, Britain, Italy and Japan. Blanchett plays […] Read More

 

Alison Gillmor:

Into the woods

Guy Maddin's absurdist end-of-the-world satire Rumours a real trip Read More

 

Ben Waldman:

American Film Institute partners with Film Training Manitoba

The American Film Institute is partnering with Film Training Manitoba to deliver a two-hour online training session focused on editing and post-production. The Thursday Zoom session with Robert Ivison — the Montreal-born discipline head for the AFI Conservatory’s editing program — marks the first training collaboration between the two organizations. Read More

 

Alison Gillmor:

Trump biopic unsparing politically but oddly sympathetic

A drama based on “real events and real individuals,” The Apprentice was a hot ticket at Cannes, mostly because its central “individual” is currently a deeply divisive candidate in the U.S. presidential election. Read More

 
 

NEW IN BOOKS

Decter brings adult debut to Free Press book club

The Free Press Book Club and McNally Robinson Booksellers are pleased to welcome Winnipeg author Nora Decter to the next virtual meeting on Tuesday, Oct. 29 at 7 p.m. to read from and discuss her debu... Read More

 

Reviewed by Shannon Sampert:

Dangerous discourse

Extremists’ weaponizing of key words could lead to dire consequences, Off warns Read More

 

Lloyd Axworthy:

A real education

Reflecting on the challenges of making U of W an anchor institution of the inner city Read More

 

Ben Waldman:

Local illustrator pens comics on society’s downfall

An illustrator born in Winnipeg has collaborated with a two-time Pulitzer Prize finalist to produce Justice Warriors, a top-selling graphic novel series that satirizes the profound instability of global democracy as we know it. Read More

 

Reviewed by Kathryen Cardwell:

Humanity permeates moving wartime debut novel

B.C. author Andrew Boden’s debut novel is a heartbreaking story about a survivor of one of humanity’s lowest moments. Read More

 

Reviewed by Nick Martin:

Newcastle thugs gunned down in Hannah’s new whodunit

The ne’er-do-well sons of Newcastle’s thuggiest crime family sneak out of their hideout in Spain to spend Christmas on Tyneside with Ma and Pa Evil — only to be gunned down as they step onto the you’re-not-welcome mat. Read More

 

Reviewed by Dave Williamson:

A literary legacy

Carol Shields’ speeches, essays and stories collected in poignant new collection Read More

 

Reviewed by Bill Rambo:

A long, hard walk

Moving memoir chronicles difficult path from civil war in Rwanda to life to Canada Read More

 

Reviewed by Douglas J. Johnston:

Rewarding reflections

Clinton breaks down all manner of political and legislative issues in engaging new book Read More

 
 

Share:

     
 

Download our News Break app