Biidaajimowin
Winnipeg Free Press Logo
 

Beleaguered leadership

Let’s set straight a basic, misunderstood fact.

In Canada’s political world, a “grand chief” is not a chief.

A chief is the leader of a First Nation and is elected by the citizens of that community, empowering that person to speak on behalf of their Indigenous and treaty rights.

A “grand chief” is voted in by a regional group of chiefs to be a spokesperson for them.

Take, for example, this description of the role of grand chief from the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs’ website.

“The Grand Chief, elected by Chiefs-in-Assembly, is mandated as the principal spokesperson on common issues for First Nations in Manitoba. While AMC functions under the direction of the Grand Chief, the Chiefs-in-Assembly are the source of all authority for AMC.”

In other words, a grand chief doesn’t represent First Nations communities, peoples or rights on any matter and must take all direction from the chiefs he represents.

This brings us to Grand Chief Jerry Daniels of the Southern Chiefs Organization (SCO), the body that represents 32 Anishinaabe and Dakota Nations in southern Manitoba.

On Monday, the Southeast Resource Development Council Corp., (SERDC), publicly released a motion calling for a non-confidence vote against Daniels. The organization represents eight southern Manitoba First Nation communities.

According to the letter, the leaders of the eight First Nations — a third of SCO’s constituency — accuse Daniels of acting “outside of the constitution of the SCO authority and decision-making” after SCO signed a five-year agreement with the Manitoba Métis Federation to work together on major infrastructure and development projects.

I wrote about this agreement in my column last week, assuming that Daniels was acting with the consent of the chiefs he represents.

Apparently, he was not.

First Nations chiefs get angry with grand chiefs — and tell media about it — all the time.

On some rare occasions, chiefs vote to remove a grand chief, especially for inappropriate conduct.

SCO Grand Chief Jerry Daniels, though, seems to be a political cat — he’s survived multiple calls by his own constituents to end his leadership over the past year.

Southern Chiefs' Organization Grand Chief Jerry Daniels talks with reporters after the Hudson’s Bay Company transfer ceremony in 2022. (John Woods / The Canadian Press files)

Southern Chiefs’ Organization Grand Chief Jerry Daniels talks with reporters after the Hudson’s Bay Company transfer ceremony in 2022. (John Woods / The Canadian Press files)

Daniels has been in the news recently for SCO’s acquisition of downtown Winnipeg’s Hudson Bay building and its plan to revitalize it.

He’s also received a lot of attention for his personal issues, which include being involved in a “drunken punch-up” at a chiefs meeting in Ottawa last December.

That incident resulted in the SERDC (the same agency that sent a letter Monday) threatening to withdraw from SCO unless a summit was held to discuss Daniels’ conduct.

Then, Daniels was suddenly removed from the SCO website and an acting grand chief of SCO was installed.

Around the same time, allegations emerged about a number of suspicious personal financial dealings and numbered companies involving Daniels.

Daniels then apologized to SCO chiefs, promised to restore any relationships damaged by his conduct, and returned to the helm of the organization.

Then, the two SCO staffers, largely considered the reason for Daniels even having control over the Hudson Bay project in the first place, were mysteriously placed “on leave” and then let go.

Daniels then sued a journalist and Indigenous news organization for their reporting.

It’s been quite a saga for the beleaguered grand chief — who is once again facing calls for his removal by the individuals he purports to represent.

 

Niigaan Sinclair, Columnist

 

Advertisement

Passages. Kevin Rollason's Sunday newsletter honouring and remembering lives well-lived in Manitoba.
 

FIVE STORIES ON TURTLE ISLAND

New research coming out of York University identifies the causes and outcomes of Indigenous racial profiling in Canadian businesses.

The researchers, who are widely recognized for their work on human rights, call Indigenous racial profiling a human rights issue.

The report was commissioned by the Heiltsuk Nation in B.C. after two of its members were profiled while shopping at a Canadian Tire store in Coquitlam in 2019.

 


 

Hundreds of Indigenous athletes from around the globe gathered in Ottawa last week for the 2025 Masters Indigenous Games.

The athletes, aged 19 and older, competed in Indigenous and well-known sports. For the first time, the event included Arctic and northern-specific sports, such as the “Seal Hop,” which features competitors bouncing on their knuckles and toes, mimicking the act of sneaking up on a sleeping seal; and the “stick pull,” in which opponents sit on the ground facing one another while each holding on to the same stick and trying to force their opponent to a standing position.

 


 

This week, my APTN Truth and Politics co-panelist Jennifer Laewetz, CEO of Paskwâw Strategies, and I discussed the federal government’s response to this wildfire season, which is the already the second-worst on record.

A water bomber provides a steady steam of water to assist crews on the ground at the Paddy's Pond wildfire, just outside St. John's, N.L., on Aug. 14. (Paul Daly / The Canadian Press files)

A water bomber provides a steady steam of water to assist crews on the ground at the Paddy’s Pond wildfire, just outside St. John’s, N.L., on Aug. 14. (Paul Daly / The Canadian Press files)

People look from the shoreline of the Alberni Inlet towards Mount Underwood, where a wildfire continues to burn across from Macktush Creek Campsite, south of Port Alberni, B.C., on Aug. 16. (Chad Hipolito / The Canadian Press files)

People look from the shoreline of the Alberni Inlet towards Mount Underwood, where a wildfire continues to burn across from Macktush Creek Campsite, south of Port Alberni, B.C., on Aug. 16. (Chad Hipolito / The Canadian Press files)

It’s not the first time this panel and I have discussed this issue. I hope now the federal government is listening and doing something about this ongoing emergency.

The government recently announced $45 million in funding for nearly two dozen projects to study how to deal with wildfires in Canada. Half of the fires are burning in Indigenous communities.

 


 

Four individuals from the same family in the Yukon are suing a woman in Ontario over online posts she made alleging the women are “pretendians.”

The Walrus recently published a feature on this issue, probing if someone can be sued for accusing a person of falsely claiming Indigenous identity.

My colleague Drew Hayden Taylor recently completed this documentary that details how falsely claiming Indigenous identity can be very lucrative and damaging to real-life Indigenous communities.

The (literal) million-dollar question is: should Canadian courts and governments be in charge of determining how Indigenous communities determine their own membership?

 


 

For decades, the Gathering of Nations powwow in Albuquerque, New Mexico has been the gold standard of powwows.

It’s the world’s largest gathering of drums, dancers, and artisans.

Mysteriously, organizers announced this week that next year will be the powwow’s last. Without providing details on the decision, organizers said the event will end after 43 years.

Dancers participate in the grand entry procession during the annual Gathering of Nations powwow in Albuquerque, New Mexico, on April 25, 2025. (Susan Montoya Bryan / The Associated Press files)

Dancers participate in the grand entry procession during the annual Gathering of Nations powwow in Albuquerque, New Mexico, on April 25, 2025. (Susan Montoya Bryan / The Associated Press files)

It’s hard not to see this as connected to recent deep funding cuts to Native American tribes under the Trump administration.

Let’s hope the Gathering of Nations — one of the coolest powwows in the world, as you can see in this video — survives.

Fourteen year-old Mylan Archuleta of Ohkay Owingeh village in northern New Mexico prepares for the horse parade at the 40th anniversary of the Gathering of Nations powwow in Albuquerque, New Mexico, on April 28, 2023. (Roberto E. Rosales / The Associated Press files)

Fourteen year-old Mylan Archuleta of Ohkay Owingeh village in northern New Mexico prepares for the horse parade at the 40th anniversary of the Gathering of Nations powwow in Albuquerque, New Mexico, on April 28, 2023. (Roberto E. Rosales / The Associated Press files)

Hundreds of Indigenous dancers pour onto the floor at University of New Mexico Arena for the grand entry during the 29th Annual Gathering of Nations in Albuquerque, N.M., on April 27, 2012.  (Susan Montoya Bryan / The Associated Press files)

Hundreds of Indigenous dancers pour onto the floor at University of New Mexico Arena for the grand entry during the 29th Annual Gathering of Nations in Albuquerque, N.M., on April 27, 2012. (Susan Montoya Bryan / The Associated Press files)

 

IN PICTURES

A woman walks past Aymara Indigenous spiritual workers' workplaces at El Alto, Bolivia, on Aug. 15. Natacha Pisarenko / The Associated Press files)

A woman walks past Aymara Indigenous spiritual workers’ workplaces at El Alto, Bolivia, on Aug. 15. Natacha Pisarenko / The Associated Press files)

RECONCILI-ACTION OF THE WEEK

Every week I highlight an action, moment, or milestone forwarding reconciliation, illustrating how far Canada has come — and how far the country has yet to go.

Content warning: readers may be triggered by the subject matter of Indian Residential Schools. To access a 24-hour national crisis line, call: 1-866-925-4419. A Community Assistance Program can be accessed by citizens of the Anishinabek Nation: 1-800-663-1142.

This week’s reconcili-action highlights the brave and tireless work of multiple research teams across the country finding lost children who attended residential schools.

Over the past month, archivists uncovered 50 additional confirmed deaths at the Kuper Island residential school while Deninu Kue’ First Nation announced the discovery of the remains and burial sites of five children who died at the St. Joseph’s residential school.

Anomalies continue to be found, including here in Manitoba, suggesting other graves may exist at residential school sites across the country.

Archivists, researchers and Indigenous leaders often have to battle a Canadian public that ignores evidence and is distracted by lies surrounding residential schools — lies that downplay the atrocities the system perpetrated.

I hope a fight of truth against lies — which holds reconciliation back for all of us — won’t be necessary forever.

 
 

Advertisement

The weekly playbook. News, notes and analysis from the week in sports - by Mike McIntyre. Get the newsletter sent weekly.
 

WHAT I'VE BEEN WORKING ON

Niigaan Sinclair:

Feasibility without First Nations isn’t feasible

Future of Canadian development must include Indigenous approval — it’s the law Read More

 

Niigaan Sinclair:

Settlement dollars paying for broken promises, missed opportunities, devastated lives

How much does it cost to compensate 151 years of suffering and lost opportunities? Much more than $99 million. Read More

 
 
 

LOCAL NEWS

 

Erik Pindera:

‘An eye for an eye’

Year after serial killer sentenced, Shingoose family, friends get day in court to voice excruciating pain Read More

 

Alex Lambert:

Tory byelection candidate sorry for residential schools comments

BRANDON — A Progressive Conservative candidate in an upcoming Manitoba byelection has apologized for comments she made in the past about residential schools. Colleen Robbins, the Tory candidate for... Read More

 

Scott Billeck:

Eight SCO communities call for non-confidence vote on Grand Chief Jerry Daniels’ leadership

An organization representing eight member communities within the Southern Chiefs’ Organization is calling for a meeting to hold a non-confidence vote against Grand Chief Jerry Daniels, alleging he bre... Read More

 

Malak Abas:

Police ask public to help identify new Buffalo Woman

Woman who died inside Main Street hotel given same name as Shingoose, with parents’ blessing Read More

 

Chris Kitching:

Southern chiefs, Métis federation join forces in economic development, Indigenous rights protection

The Southern Chiefs’ Organization and Manitoba Métis Federation announced plans Wednesday to partner on infrastructure and development projects, while seeking greater roles in initiatives led by federal or provincial governments. Read More

 

Maggie Macintosh:

Province finalizing teacher competency standards

Education Department readying new regulations for Sept. 2 Read More

 

The Canadian Press:

Roughly 1,000 residents from Snow Lake, Man., set to return home after evacuation

SNOW LAKE - A northern Manitoba town that has been evacuated twice this summer due to out-of-control wildfires has been given the go-ahead to return home later this week.  The mandato... Read More

 

Tyler Searle:

Anomalies found on grounds of former Portage la Prairie residential school

The chief of a First Nation west of Winnipeg says four “anomalies” have been found on the grounds of its former residential school. Long Plain First Nation Chief David Meeches made those comments T... Read More

 

Malak Abas:

Portage Place skatepark searching for new site as renovations ramp up

Winnipeg Centre MP calls on ‘local leaders’ to help find suitable space Read More

 

Joyanne Pursaga:

Plan to redevelop Alexander Docks unveiled with $10.8-M price tag

A $10.8-million redevelopment plan unveiled Thursday is designed to transform the Alexander Docks into a riverside park a decade after it closed to the public. The waterfront attraction at the site... Read More

 
 

OPINION

John Longhurst:

Author urges resisting efforts to clean up ‘image routes’

Last month, city Coun. Jeff Browaty proposed banning encampments along what he called “image routes” like the Disraeli Freeway just before Main Street, along with Pembina Highway, McPhillips Street, S... Read More

 
 

ARTS & LIFE

Gabrielle Piché:

‘We’re going to show the world through our art’

Ally’s Ribbons assembles group of Indigenous designers, models for iconic Milan Fashion Week Read More

 

Jen Zoratti:

Innocents project

Epidemic of children being kidnapped in Nigeria focus of art exhibition Read More

 
 

FROM FURTHER AFIELD

Stefanie Dazio And Malin Haarala, The Associated Press: A historic Swedish church embraces inclusion with minority languages
 

Share:

     
 

Download our News Break app