Paul Samyn Editor’s Note
Winnipeg Free Press Logo
 

The cost and value of local news

If you want a coffee at Tim Hortons, an extra-large double-double will cost you $2.32.

If your palate and pocketbook lead you to Starbucks, a large — sorry, venti — dark roast will run you $3.45. If you want to dig even deeper, there’s a caramel macchiato for $5.45.

And if you want a copy of the Free Press to go with your morning coffee, we can deliver it to your home six days a week for far less. Even with a six-per-cent price increase that kicked in on Aug. 1, an extra-large serving of information you can trust costs only $2.10. If you prefer your Free Press served up digitally, the cost falls to 68 cents a day.

Advertisement

Three Savour Manitoba magazine covers promoting a food, drink, and lifestyle publication.

 

I’m making the cost comparisons between coffee and Free Press subscriptions tonight because of the battle brewing in Canada over access to news. Ottawa wants the tech giants to pay for Canadian-generated journalism. Facebook/Instagram and Google don’t want to pay.

On Tuesday, Meta upped the stakes by announcing it will remove all news from its Facebook and Instagram platforms in Canada in a few short weeks. (In the case of the Free Press, Meta blocked our Instagram page on July 14, which just happened to be Bastille Day. Read into that what you will.)

At some level, this game of chicken between the federal government and two of the richest companies on the planet really boils down to dollars and sense.

The dollar side of that equation is about a bottom line critical to the sustainability of news gathering in our democracy. It ain’t cheap to produce journalism. Reporters, photographers and editors who produce fact-based journalism all need to be paid.

Once upon a time, revenue from advertisers could be counted upon to keep the news machine humming. But the digital revolution that made the likes of Mark Zuckerberg beyond wealthy, also degraded the financial capacity of news organizations everywhere. The long-standing business model was broken. Newspapers began to go broke. And in a perverse twist, the so-called Information Age suddenly had fewer sources of local information, giving rise to “news deserts” here in Canada and across the United States.

The sense side of the equation is all about values and the common good. We know what the values are of Meta and Google, given the blackouts they are prepared to impose on news in our country. But what are our values? “A community without a way to inform itself about itself is just a population of unsympathetic strangers,” warned The Shattered Mirror, a 2017 report on news democracy and trust in the digital age.

That might be what Meta and Google want, but that can’t be what we want, right?

This newsletter you are reading is available for free. But the essential service the Free Press has provided since 1872 isn’t.

Meta and Google see no need to pay for news. Facebook and Google are going to use their marketing might to block Canadians from seeing news on their sites.

If you don’t like that dystopian future, you can change the narrative. And to do so, it costs less than a coffee a day.

 

Paul Samyn, Editor

 

Advertisement

Three Savour Manitoba magazine covers promoting a food, drink, and lifestyle publication.
 

COMING UP

Pack up the car and join us for Free Press Field Trip No. 3. On the eve of Islendingadagurinn, the Icelandic Festival of Manitoba in Gimli, we head to New Iceland and explore Arborg and Riverton, with the Icelandic River as our guide. (Longtime Wrap readers will recall Field Trip No. 1, to Snowflake, and No. 2. to Elma.)

After a pandemic-inspired pivot to virtual events in 2021 and a smaller festival in 2022, the 52nd edition of Folklorama features 40 pavilions, up from 24 last year, including the return of the Cuban pavilion.

When the event kicks off on Sunday, superfan Debbie Stern will be first in line. Stern aims to visit every pavilion each year and has devised an elaborate spreadsheet system to track her progress and rate the entertainment offerings. Jen Zoratti and Eva Wasney have the skinny on the long-running multicultural festival, which runs Aug. 6-19, in Saturday’s Arts & Life section.

And: nothing says summer like a giant prehistoric shark movie, unless it’s a giant prehistoric shark movie sequel. The Meg 2 promises some cheesy B-movie thrills along with reliable action hero Jason Statham; Alison Gillmor delivers her verdict in the Weekend Review.

In sports, the best in the west collide in Winnipeg on Thursday night when the 5-2 Bombers host the B.C. Lions (6-1) in CFL action at IG Field. Game time is 7:30 p.m.

On Friday, the Winnipeg Sea Bears host a crucial Canadian Elite Basketball League ‘play-in’ contest when the Edmonton Stingers pay a visit to jam-packed Canada Life Centre. Tip-off goes at 8 p.m., with the winner continuing its playoff push.

And the World Fire & Police Games continue in the Manitoba capital until Sunday.

IN CASE YOU MISSED IT

Despite a reputation as one of Canada’s coldest cities, Winnipeg increasingly has a heat problem. Old, inefficient buildings, a shrinking tree canopy and infrastructure geared at keeping the cold out and the heat in have combined to set a dangerous precedent as the city experiences new temperature peaks.

Like many Canadian cities, Winnipeg has legislation aimed at keeping residents warm in the coldest months, but there are no such laws to keep people cool.

As Manitobans suffer the health and financial impacts of new temperature extremes made worse by a warming climate, a chorus of citizens and policy experts are calling for system-wide adaptations — from residential heat legislation to home energy retrofits.

Julia-Simone Rutgers reviews the situation in her long feature, Degrees of Danger.

ONE GREAT PHOTO

Sam Manchulenko leads a session in Enderton Park (also known as Peanut Park) in Winnipeg, on Monday. Manchulenko — who goes by Sam the Yogi online — meets with people in the park Mondays and Wednesdays at 6 p.m. for open-air yoga. (John Woods / Winnipeg Free Press)

Sam Manchulenko leads a session in Enderton Park (also known as Peanut Park) in Winnipeg, on Monday. Manchulenko — who goes by Sam the Yogi online — meets with people in the park Mondays and Wednesdays at 6 p.m. for open-air yoga. (John Woods / Winnipeg Free Press)

 
 

Advertisement

Savour Manitoba Spring issue cover featuring colourful mixed drinks on a table.
 

MORE NEWS ON TECH GIANTS

Mickey Djuric, The Canadian Press:

Tories ran on similar media policy as Liberals

OTTAWA - Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre says Liberal legislation aimed at social media platforms is ushering in censorship, despite his party running on similar policy in the last federal electi... Read More

 

David Klepper, The Associated Press:

X marks the lawsuit: Elon Musk’s social media company sues nonprofit highlighting site’s hate speech

WASHINGTON (AP) — X, the social media platform formerly known as Twitter, has sued a group of researchers — alleging their work highlighting an increase in hate speech on the platform c... Read More

 

Rod Mcguirk, The Associated Press:

Australian Senate committee recommends government ban on TikTok be extended to WeChat

CANBERRA, Australia (AP) — An Australian Senate committee has recommended a ban on the Chinese-owned video-sharing app TikTok from federal government devices be extended to China’s most popular social... Read More

 

Matt O'brien, The Associated Press:

Chatbots sometimes make things up. Is AI’s hallucination problem fixable?

Spend enough time with ChatGPT and other artificial intelligence chatbots and it doesn't take long for them to spout falsehoods. Described as hallucination, confabulation ... Read More

 

Barbara Ortutay, The Associated Press:

Elon Musk wants to turn tweets into ‘X’s’. But changing language is not quite so simple

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Elon Musk may want to send “tweet” back to the birds, but the ubiquitous term for posting on the site he now calls X is here to stay — at least for now. ... Read More

 

Mickey Djuric, The Canadian Press:

Google restricts access to AI chatbot in Canada

OTTAWA - Tech companies are continuing to push back on the Liberal government over its Online News Act, with Google withholding its new artificial-intelligence chatbot from Canada and M... Read More

 
 
 

WELL-READ STORIES THIS WEEK

Gabrielle Piché:

‘You’re buying a lifestyle’

Multimillion-dollar homes for sale a sign of Winnipeg’s changed real estate market Read More

 

Chris Kitching:

House arrest for fan who incited fight at Jets game

A brawl at a Winnipeg Jets game last year, which was caught on video and shared widely on social media and international news sites, was sparked by a couple who were being kicked out for loading up on... Read More

 

Carol Sanders:

Clean-up on all aisles

Crew clearing Bay flagship for redevelopment finds army of mannequins, potential path to better future Read More

 
 

LEAN BACK: GREAT LONG READS

David Sanderson:

Dropping the needle on a decade

Winnipeg vinyl aficionado has truly found his groove as record-and-tape shop celebrates milestone Read More

 

Taylor Allen:

Allen lets his play do the talking

Sea Bears’ star ‘Teddy Buckets’ puts adversity in past during MVP-worthy season Read More

 

Allan Levine:

‘Little Bird’ and the ’60s Scoop

If you have not yet watched Little Bird, the six-part series streaming on Crave, I would highly recommend that you do, though much of it is heart-wrenching. Read More

 
 

OPINIONS: COLUMNS AND ANALYSIS

Tom Brodbeck:

Government inaction let legitimate cases of seniors abuse slide

It’s highly probable hundreds of seniors are physically, sexually or verbally abused every year in Manitoba’s long-term care facilities and their cases are swept under the carpet. It’s hard to conc... Read More

 

Rebecca Chambers:

Calling foul on playing host to contentious World Police and Fire Games

The opening ceremonies of the World Police and Fire Games are slated for tonight at Canada Life Centre, with thousands of police and first responder athlete-competitors and their pre-approved family m... Read More

 

Charles Adler:

The peculiar, scary neighbours

If I were a religious person, I’d be thanking God every morning, afternoon and night for an extra long grocery list of items. Read More

 

Shannon Sampert:

Votes, wedges and political tricks

Well, we’re not talking about health care anymore, are we? Just like that, the Manitoba Conservatives may have found something to push the front-page focus off of health care and onto the wedge issue of searching the landfills, ahead of an election on Oct. 3. Read More

 
 

ON THE LIGHTER SIDE

Gabrielle Piché:

A century of success

Broadway Florists, Cholakis family celebrating 100 years of passion for flowers Read More

 

Joshua Frey-Sam:

Steen shows age no barrier at Games

Retired RCMP member endures ‘Toughest Competitor’ Alive event Read More

 

Gabrielle Piché:

Growing for all seasons

New 10-acre greenhouse in Dauphin set to produce tomatoes year-round Read More

 
 

Share:

     
 

Download our News Break app